Hiring a security expert as a consultant is a good start. There are many larger security firms that can provide audits, but an initial consultant will help you pick the low-hanging fruit and may even be able to contribute to your code.
They could be useless. They could BE the criminals.
So you need an auditor for your auditor, and for that too you'll need an auditor. It's auditors all the way down.
In the specific case of auditors, they tend to be large, well-known companies with a reputation, a common system in our society for figuring out if people are useful or criminals. Arthur Andersen, for instance, made a series of bad ethical decisions in its accounting audit practice. They no longer practice auditing for accounting, and their consulting business has been rebranded (to Accenture) because they lost the reputation of their original name. So they did, in effect, get audited eventually. Which again is better than not bothering.