If that sentence applies, I don't think they really have a case...
If it is interpreted to mean "use", then the case is a loser as you say. But I wouldn't want to be the lawyer tasked with arguing to the judge that "the legislature meant 'use' but decided to say 'procurement' instead".
At any rate, I don't see how the definition cited would clear up the matter. It's a big leap from "the entire process of purchasing goods" to "commercial use". Like "use", which I discuss above, "commercial use" is a common term of art, and it would be strange to say "procurement" if what you mean is "commercial use".
But the courts are so random; I'm guessing this case will be determined primarily by how much the judge that gets assigned likes technology. It'll be interesting to follow up on.
A citizen cannot look at the law and figure out if they're committing a crime, which is why I said the law is unconstitutional.
It's usually more difficult to sue, though. The power is usually given to some semi-governmental group. The Courts go out of their way to find professional regulations constitutional, and the regulators try to avoid claims that might get the entire regulation struck down. That's why Illinois never goes after non-commercial speculation about house prices.
But sometimes they overreach. There was an article in the WSJ a few days ago about some state's Barber Commission levying $50 fines on cosmetologists with striped poles out front -- for improperly implying that a licensed barber was on premises.
This woman probably isn't suing to enforce the regulation, as such. She could sue without the professional regulation, but the law sets a professional standard of care for appraisers that Zillow doesn't claim to meet, so she hopes it will help her case.
If you drive by a house and say "this house doesn't look like it's worth shit" you're probably not going to wind up in court after someone complains that said house is worth quite a bit more than shit and you're driving the price down.
Laws actually can be vague while remaining Constitutional. Sometimes it's unavoidable. Court cases can be used to refine the edges.
Zillow is not a citizen.
They're also in the business of providing these numbers, which is obviously far from the same thing as making a comment while driving down a street. I think you're trying to blur a line that's pretty clear to most reasonable people.
A prohibition against unlicensed appraisals seems about as valid as hiding what is public information if you choose to make the effort and know where to look. However, I can see both decisions being overruled if appealed to higher courts.
No, but if you try and sell your opinion to make money that's when you're very likely crossing the line. An appraisal is something you pay for or make money from; opinions are not.
...and certainly as it is applied here, to a 'zestimate'.
I predict Zillow will make a motion to dismiss on first amendment grounds. I also predict the judge will grant that motion.
RemindMe! One Year
It makes it illegal to "develop a real estate appraisal" without a license. An appraisal is defined as simply "an opinion of value". So if you are driving down the street and say to your spouse, "Look at that house, it's gotta be worth a million bucks," you just committed a misdemeanor.
This law as it's written has got to be unconstitutional.