News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:“Google Is as Close to a Natural Monopoly as the Bell Sys... by ghaff on Wednesday May 10, 2017 @02:16PM (#14310324)
The assumption around natural monopolies is that they're the inevitable result of the economic dynamics of an industry. Therefore if you carve things up to force competition, the theory goes, you're going to increase capital requirements overall and therefore prices to consumers.

It's also fairly clear that at least over long enough time horizons there aren't many natural monopolies.

Re:“Google Is as Close to a Natural Monopoly as the Bell Sys... by nickik on Thursday May 11, 2017 @11:09AM (#14316561)
I think actually there are many natural monopolies in terms of economic profit and doubling infrastructure is inefficent.

There is a nice private solution to this, and this sort of thing is not talked about enough.

Imagen we have two companies, both are ISP with their own infrastructure. Then because of other reason a new expensive infrastructure project is needed. These two could ban together and form a new organisation (non-provit or a club) that economises on the infrastructure but provides access and price garanties to both companies and maybe even sell access capacity to third parties.

The differnce to a normal company providing infrastructure is that the costumers of that company always need to be afraid of price raises. Once you have this club situation you essentially have one infrastructure, but you avoid monopoly pricing because competitive game has moved to a higher abstraction. This would provide very low cost and very low price to consumers.

If you apply a regulatory system as soon as you think there is a natural monopoly the industry will almost certantly stagnate.

Re:“Google Is as Close to a Natural Monopoly as the Bell Sys... by notduncansmith on Wednesday May 10, 2017 @03:08PM (#14310751)
> It's also fairly clear that at least over long enough time horizons there aren't many natural monopolies.

Would you say this is because the benefits to decentralization don't often bear themselves out as visibly as the costs over a shorter time horizon?

In other words, is a "natural monopoly" simply externalizing the costs of centralization to the future?

Re:“Google Is as Close to a Natural Monopoly as the Bell Sys... by ghaff on Wednesday May 10, 2017 @03:25PM (#14310887)
If you're talking about protecting a supposed natural monopoly through regulation, there's probably some truth to that. The thinking probably goes something like "We must protect the public from an unregulated monopoly today." Left unspoken is "And the future is someone else's problem. They'll deal with it if they have to."

As for whether there really are natural monopolies, the classic examples are things like electrical distribution systems. If one company has already wired up a city, it's going to be hard for someone else to come in and wire up the same city in competition. (And may not be a great idea from the perspective of public policy.)

However, over longer timeframes technology change and market forces overturn many monopolies. IBM, Windows, Ma Bell--these were all considered to have monopolies at one time.