Tabloids have been making shit up about celebrities for decades. Brad Pitt has cancer! No, wait, he murdered a puppy! No, he kicked an orphan in the face! These things sell papers.
Then people realized the same thing works in politics: Hillary Clinton has cancer! She murdered a puppy! She kicked an orphan in the face! It's a proven formula, people click it, and you will make money given how things are monetized these days.
Attention, any attention, is something you can monetize.
That's the problem. Advertisers don't give a fuck. When they start to pay attention to where they're spending their money they might wise up and deprive these "fake news" sources of any incentive.
Also, look at state propaganda in the media in the 1930s and 1940s and even during Vietnam--the contrived Gulf of Tonkin incident as a means of generating public support for expanding the war to include mainline ground troops.
I have to conclude that all journalism is mostly lies and state propaganda is behind much of it.
I should add that I was a sports writer for a local newspaper many years ago and that gig was definitely an exercise in embellishment and outright fabrication at times.
What I find most egregious about the recent "fake news" bs is that now private Internet companies deign to tell you what is and isn't truthful information and we just watched how these same companies sided with one and only one presidential candidate. The problem was, even they couldn't carry that side of beef over the finish line!
Except now there's so much happening so fast, we can't keep up! Plus with "personalisation", no one's experience is the same. What a headache for future historians.
There's still a few that takes journalism seriously; the Guardian is one. But none can claim absolute truth or neutrality. So fake or not, I guess we still have to resort to multiple sources - or even better, stick our heads in the sand until the madness is over!
(That may or may not be taken as tongue in cheek..)
Everything anyone says should be treated with a critical eye and a healthy dose of skepticism. Nobody who's ever achieved anything significant has done it without making mistakes.
The problem is when you throw up your hands and declare the New York Times to be on the same level as the National Enquirer.
Statistics are important here. A source that's reliable 99 times out of 100 is more trustworthy than one that's reliable 1 in 100 times.
I praise my kids a lot, but I do it for meaningful things (or steps towards) that they do and for exhibiting the principles that will strengthen them as adults.
I urge my kids to practice skepticism to question the nature of things and people.
It's also educational to play games where two or three people tell a different version of the "truth" and you have to guess which one is actually right.
Schools are sadly suffering a deficit of critical thinking. The American ones in particular do not reward it at all, if anything it's punished. You must answer according to the textbook or you lose marks. Such is a test-driven education system.
non sequitur
From a few chosen examples, it's a massive stretch to say journalism is "mostly lies".
It's a further stretch to talk about state propaganda without distinguishing between various topics of journalism (political, sports, tech, economic, etc) not to mention source and past performance.
This is just FUD, and it's facile.
Most people running for governor, congress, etc. did not have a basic website explaining their stance on certain issues, etc. Some of them only had a facebook page with a series of memes.
What we need to do to fight "fake news" and targeted advertising is to fight for the source of real news. We need to stop spreading information via opinionated articles when the actual information is salient enough. We need to reject advertised news regardless of whether it is fake or not, because even the truth is used to mislead an audience.
Döpfner: Right. But was does that mean for fake news?
Berners-Lee: What’s the fake news? How do they define fake news in this case?
Döpfner: Well, that’s already where the problem starts. That means that, in the end, Facebook or another social media platform can define what fake news is, and I think it should always be the prosecutor and not a private company. Facebook should be a neutral platform. People exchange all kinds of things, good and bad, truth and lies. However, only if something is illegal, the prosecutor should intervene. If Facebook with its almost two billion users – ushered by well-intentioned politicians – morphs into a universal media monopoly making editorial decisions and even judging on who gets to read what, then we have a problem. And it is exacerbated if that happens in a closed system.
...
Döpfner: Again: How about the whole fake news phenomenon? How should society deal with that? Should publishers help Facebook to correct their fake news stories, or is it basically more about media education, that people should learn that not everything that is distributed on a social media platform is necessarily true?
Berners-Lee: I think we have to be very scientific and look at how these systems interact. The Macedonian websites we talked about earlier generated ad revenue by making up things about the US election, and affected that election even though their motivation was not at all political, only commercial. The ad network trained them that lies can generate more revenue than truth. As a system engineer, I look at that and say, "Well, now, something’s broken here." So one of the possibilities is for Google at that point to tweak the way they reimburse people not just on the clicks, but on some other function.
Döpfner: So you could say the fact that Facebook is incentivizing people to distribute bad content, fake news, has to be changed in the very interest of the social media platform.
Berners-Lee: The guys in Veles, Macedonia, they were independent , they were not on Facebook. They were only on websites. They pointed at them with Twitter. So it wasn’t a Facebook phenomenon.
There’s a separate Facebook phenomenon which I’m told was an important factor in the election. That is targeted advertising. Targeted advertising on social networks is very effective. There’s a blog. He claimed that what they did was divided the entire American voting population into 32 different subtypes, like Myers-Briggs, different sorts of people, different demographics, and so they could then send targeted information.
So to one group with children, you’d say, "Our candidate is going to fight for education." Then there’s a group without children, and they can say, "Our candidate is going to save money by cutting down education"“ Because it’s targeted advertising, it’s not public so nobody can check.
So one simple rule could be that you could say, actually, targeted advertising by political bodies is not democratic. Therefore, from now on, if you want to advertise as a political person, you have to say same thing to everybody because, that’s what democracy is.
There are several types of "fake news" which are often --- and sometimes intentionally --- conflated. As the interview does, I think it's necessary to distinguish "click bait" (which has a primarily monetary incentive) from "political propaganda" (which has a primarily social agenda).
But not all "click bait" and "political propaganda" is false, and not all that are false are false in the same way. It seems also worth distinguishing "lies by omission" (biased reporting) from "lies of whole cloth" (truly "fake" news). I'm doubtful that there is any algorithmic way of distinguishing these, or any legal definition that is not ripe for abuse.
I'm also dubious about the claim that "something is broken here, at least from a business perspective. Google and Facebook are making tons of money with the current system. It seems likely that any change would reduce their profits. Other than "don't be evil" (for Google at least), what's their incentive to change? As a society, what can we change so that such an incentive exists, and is stronger than the currently dominant ones?