News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple Censors a Gay Kiss in Oscar Wilde Comic by almost on Monday June 14, 2010 @12:56PM (#1430198)
Before we all get into a rage, is there any real evidence that they objected to semi-nude homosexual kissing and not just to semi-nude kissing in general? That would still be kind of silly but it loses some of the rage-inducing homophobia...
Re:Apple Censors a Gay Kiss in Oscar Wilde Comic by jpablo on Monday June 14, 2010 @01:10PM (#1430245)
Go to page two of the article, there's another comic that was accepted that has implicit sex and a nipple showing.

"On a Picasa page, he posted some full pages from the original book, as well as one page from another comic book (from Kick-Ass) of a heterosexual couple. Apple apparently didn't have a problem with that image. Kick-Ass can be bought, uncensored, on iTunes through the iVerse comic reader."

http://www.thebigmoney.com/blogs/app-economy/2010/06/11/it-g...

Re:Apple Censors a Gay Kiss in Oscar Wilde Comic by starkfist on Monday June 14, 2010 @01:16PM (#1430273)
Apple doesn't censor comics that are purchased through iVerse.

They censor the content being sold directly through the iTunes app store.

Re:Apple Censors a Gay Kiss in Oscar Wilde Comic by jfager on Monday June 14, 2010 @01:38PM (#1430345)
I don't understand why this distinction is important. You have to click past the same "Are you 17?" scare warning to download both apps that can access external content and apps that are adult-oriented by themselves, and both can be limited with parental controls. The former can access far more pornographic material than this, and yet Apple is going out of its way to black this material out? That makes zero sense.
Re:Apple Censors a Gay Kiss in Oscar Wilde Comic by ErrantX on Monday June 14, 2010 @02:05PM (#1430424)
Simple: they are hosting the material. Im sure if there was a way to apply censorship to material obtained in other ways they would do so. That is how they view the platform.
Re:Apple Censors a Gay Kiss in Oscar Wilde Comic by jfager on Monday June 14, 2010 @02:46PM (#1430553)
Okay, that's how Apple sees the platform, and it's their right. It's also my right to point out how ridiculous their policy is, to complain to them about it, and to try to convince others to do the same.

If their goal is to be family-friendly, and they try to stay consistent with that goal with apps that can download external content by putting up a scare wall and adding parental controls, then it makes no sense at all to censor content hosted on their own servers when they can (and do) pass it through the exact same scare wall and parental controls.

Re:Apple Censors a Gay Kiss in Oscar Wilde Comic by ErrantX on Monday June 14, 2010 @02:55PM (#1430568)
Actually I see no clash there at all. Both get the same age warning, one is controlled by Apple so they can apply the level of censorship to it that they wish.

Certainly we should be pointing out it's the wrong approach; but I see no ambiguity.

Re:Apple Censors a Gay Kiss in Oscar Wilde Comic by jfager on Monday June 14, 2010 @03:18PM (#1430652)
Pointing to a technical distinction that makes no real difference to a user's experience is just geek-wanking. Whether from a 3rd-party server or from Apple itself, if adult content ends up on a kid's screen, a parent somewhere is getting pissed, and if there's any company in the world that's going to be aware of this, it's Apple. They're obviously fine with the idea that age warnings and parental controls are sufficient for apps that can display 3rd-party-server content, and because they are, it's prima facie ridiculous that they would censor the same or similar content from their own servers that passes through the same age warning and parental controls.
Re:Apple Censors a Gay Kiss in Oscar Wilde Comic by ErrantX on Monday June 14, 2010 @03:25PM (#1430679)
I think we are talking past each other..

As far as I can see it Apple consider the two things discrete issues. They slap an age 17 warning on apps which give access to adult material.

Plus content containing "pornography" on the App store is censored because they do not wish to distribute that content.

Again; I see no ambiguity there.

They're obviously fine with the idea that age warnings and parental controls are sufficient control for 3rd-party-server content

Fin in the sense they host the apps, sure. Fine in the sense they approve of that whole idea? Probably not. But how do you practically censor those apps (on their policy) without hindering the web experience for others. I guess they accept the trade off :) but are they fine with it? Who knows.

it's prima facie ridiculous that they would censor the same or similar content from their own servers.

I don't buy that argument, indeed you even make the counter point.

if adult content ends up on a kid's screen, a parent somewhere is getting pissed

Apple are directly responsible for content on the App store. So, surely, to avoid this sort of ball ache their policy isn't ridiculous.

Re:Apple Censors a Gay Kiss in Oscar Wilde Comic by jfager on Monday June 14, 2010 @03:53PM (#1430753)
Again; I see no ambiguity there.

I never said the policy was ambiguous, I said it was nonsensical.

Apple are directly responsible for content on the App store. So, surely, to avoid this sort of ball ache their policy isn't ridiculous.

My point was that a pissed-off parent doesn't care where the content came from, and that Apple, if anyone, is smart enough to realize this. Simple logic:

1. 3rd party content will piss people off as much as hosted.

2. Apple perceives scare walls and parental controls to be sufficient to manage the issue for 3rd party content.

3. Therefore, Apple ought to perceive scare walls and parental controls to be sufficient to manage the issue for hosted apps.

4. But, nonsensically, they don't.

Re:Apple Censors a Gay Kiss in Oscar Wilde Comic by ErrantX on Monday June 14, 2010 @03:56PM (#1430766)
Your logic doesn't hold. It doesn't matter what age advisories they put in place the parents can directly blame them for content in the app store.

This way they can legally wash their hands of it. Simple as.

Your taking two seperate issues and turnig them into one.

Re:Apple Censors a Gay Kiss in Oscar Wilde Comic by jfager on Monday June 14, 2010 @04:49PM (#1430937)
Earlier in the thread, you specifically said that you thought they would try to censor material served by 3rd parties if they could, as that was their vision for the platform. That's hard to square with the idea that you've been talking about Apple's censorship of apps they host as some sort of minimal grounds for absolving themselves of legal responsibility.

On top of that, the content that sparked this discussion is clearly legal. There's no possible way Apple would be in criminal danger from hosting it, and I'm sure a civil suit wouldn't make it very far either, especially considering the scare wall and the parental controls.

I guess I should also make it clear that I'm not suggesting Apple ought to host illegal (or even borderline legal) content simply because it can be accessed through a browser. Apple doesn't make the choice about what's legal, and I just assumed it was understood that that was out of scope of the discussion.

Re:Apple Censors a Gay Kiss in Oscar Wilde Comic by almost on Tuesday June 15, 2010 @04:59AM (#1432176)
Who cares? It's enough to make me think it's less about homophobia and more about Apple's prudishness. And that's enough for me not to give a crap.
Re:Apple Censors a Gay Kiss in Oscar Wilde Comic by starkfist on Monday June 14, 2010 @01:41PM (#1430355)
I don't know either, that's just the way it is.