Doesn't mean they wouldn't have preferred to keep it.
> Plus we have hundreds of years over which to know if such a procedure had adverse effects and the incidence rates.
Really? Please link a study, published in a respectable publication, that compares physical and subjective sex performance parameters of the two type of men.
And the answer is?
Obviously the same is not true of people losing a finger.
Regret doesn't factor into that and is a separate issue. Clearly you can have productive and fulfilling lives with or without regrets. Whether the lack of regrets is rational or merely a self-defense mechanism of the person's mind is another question.
The main people who can answer that are adult males who were circumcized.
I am confident that if you asked 1000 religious Orthodox Jewish men whether they would have preferred to NOT have been circumcized at 8 days old and instead had to choose it later, an overwhelming majority would say they were glad they were circumcized that early. And they prefer that over never having been circumcized.
I would be hesitant to say the same about non-Jewish men. The reason Jewish men are happy about having been circumcized early is because (perhaps this sounds ironic) it gives them FAR GREATER CHOICE when it comes to their own community and membership in three thousand year old people, marriage and - above all for most religious people - serving God in the way spelled out in the Torah.
They can choose to leave the lifestyle or increase their observance etc. much more easily since one of the biggest challenges is already out of the way.
You can of course tell them they don't understand what real choice is, that this is stockholm syndrome and that religion is mass delusion.
But they may not agree and they collectively are ultimately the judges of what was better for them.
It is a different conception of morality and rights than the individualism that comes out of the Scottish Enlightenment
These ideas that a parent "knows better" because they - and millions of others - were in the same situation and are glad this was done, are valid.
It is a collective morality of a people. And again I would say that unless they believed that God commanded it, it could be possibly changed but as it is, when the vast majority of complaints are from the OUTSIDE of the community, perhaps the downsides far outweigh the upsides.
I'd be happy to read that study i asked for at the start though.
No statistically significant difference in:
* Ejaculation time
* Erectile dysfunction
* Sexual desire
* Orgasm difficulties
* Pain during or after sex
This is important, because circ'd individuals are often targeted online as having inferior sexual organs (count how many times the word "mutilated" is used in this thread). I'm willing to bet the mental health impact of this rhetoric is greater than the impact of circumcision itself. If circumcision should be banned, it shouldn't be banned on exaggerated pretenses that intact men have superior penises and circ'd men are inferior or incomplete (which seems to be underlying a lot of the arguments).
As for incomplete. I'm sorry, but there are no two ways about it. Incomplete means to be missing a part. It is. How important this is in the big picture is a different question.
The question of whether Jewish men proceed to success after the alteration may indicate something about the severity of the alteration, but it certainly isn't a reason supporting routine circumcision.
Your point regarding gender reassignment surgery is irrelevant and, as far as I can tell, a way to imply hypocrisy and substitute that as a counter argument for pro-abolotion positions.
Assuming the better life outcomes aren't just because of culutural values, I wonder if there are benefits to circumcision we simply don't have the scientific tools to measure.
People keep saying this, but fail to link to sources substantiating their non-obvious claims. Link to a study please?
Ask 1000 men born to Orthodox Jewish parents whether they regret being circumcized.
And ask 1000 Orthodox Jewish men who were not circumcized whether they wish they had been.
In the West, we have values of individualism. So being part of a millennia old people or a tradition or serving God are not seen as primary values by many atheists. I bet the people downvoting and commenting here negatively about circumcision are not of an Abrahamic faith - Judaism Christianity or Islam.
Fine but the individualism has also led to more depression, tiny families, often broken homes (also permanent effects on the child). So when you talk about tradeoffs tou have to consider the complex set of interconnected benefits. And different people perceive different benefits depending on their cultural upbringing. I can tell you that the vast majority of Orthodox Jewish men are glad they were circumcized at 8 days old and not had to choose it later.
According to the Torah you should be stoned to death for merely breaking the Sabbath, and a murder victim's family members should be permitted to kill the murderer - and yet Judaism has modernised, recognising these acts as barbaric. Maybe Judaism needs to modernise a bit more, and allow children to grow up and make their own choices regarding the mutilation of their bodies.
Should people with religious beliefs really be able to mutilate their children in the name of their beliefs, however 'benign' that mutiliation is seen to be?
I don't see the problem with allowing children to grow into adulthood, decide for themselves what, if any, religion they want to follow - and make their own choice about how, if at all, to mutilate their bodies?
I understand that there are hundreds of years of tradition involved, but you could say the same about plenty of practices that are frowned upon or outlawed, so I don't think that argument stands up on its own.
Is your standard for acceptable mutilation really "it isn't noticeably harmful"?
What if my religion calls for the removal of a single testicle instead of the foreskin - is that ok? Afterall, men with one testicle can still father children and lead productive lives.
Rights generally begin as a very individual thing... the right to vote, the right to free speech, etc. So the right not to have one's body mutilated without consent is pretty individual the way I look at it. It's hard (for me) to separate granting the right to mutilate a body that is not yours from the notion of the person being mutilated somehow being "chattle" of the person doing the mutilation.
But I'm not arguing that the same set of laws should apply to all groups and all cultures, but for an area where rights and protections are very minimal (such as infants) there is a lot of room for improvement.
My guess is that if circumcision were banned religious communities would not be harmed because the symbolism of circumcision would adapt to be more figurative in the same way that many other traditions are now done in a "lite" way that lacks strict historical accuracy but still holds great ceremonial significance.
But don't take my remarks as disrespectful of religion or of Judaism. I think that trying to figure out how to accomplish (broadly speaking) moral progress is very difficult, and I'd much rather improve the rights of prisoners than see circumcision ended, even though in principle I hold the view that circumcision should only occur when the person whose penis is being circumcised can consent. In the US there are much lower hanging fruit for humanitarian improvement. Not sure about Norway.
This is not meaningful unless you control for social circumstances.
Also, for now, all i'm asking you to do is only state things you can substantiate, and state them exactly and clearly.
This thing can operate in various fashions. Unmodified it works like this, modified it works in another way. Leave it as is and there's the option for both at any point. Make the decision now and one of the options is forever gone.
Now, this may be anecdotal, but Eastern European men are (almost) all uncircumcised and on average Eastern Europeans seem to be regarded as better coders than Americans and Indians, who are all routinely circumcised.
Is the argument here that if someone happens to believe in a particular practice (that impacts on somebody else's life), it should be completely off-limits and tolerated without question just because it appears in a religious text?
> why right away submit them to permanently changing into a transsexual? Yet the same progressives who argue against circumcision would argue for gender reassignment surgery.
Which "progressives" are arguing for babies to have gender reassignment surgery?