I've used shorewall for some time. As a matter of fact, installed it on my recent laptop as well (archlinux). But till now I didn't like quite often config file format changes, because of which I needed to figure out how to change current config to match the latest one. PF in this regard was more consistent and more readable and didn't requre to use anything on top of it. Then again - I never needed very complex FW rules.
Re:New in Debian stable Stretch: nftables
by BrandoElFollito on Tuesday May 09, 2017 @04:30PM
(#14303544)
There was a question about that on the list and the answer from shorewall author was "no".
While I'm excited to hear about a simplified abstraction at the kernel level, for most setups I've had to configure, I really like the highlevel abstraction it provides.