News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Decommission of Cyrus Email by Tharkun on Saturday May 06, 2017 @08:01PM (#14283009)
On the other side of that, sending mail to gmail can be rather challenging. They have a tendency of 541-ing mails for no apparent reason, under the pretense of "poor mail server reputation".

Basically you don't control who gets to send you mails. You're entirely at Google's uncompromising and unreachable mercy.

Re:Decommission of Cyrus Email by colechristensen on Saturday May 06, 2017 @08:21PM (#14283102)
If you run DKIM, SPF, and DMARC, you shouldn't have any delivery problems.

DKIM is signing your email with the public key in DNS.

SPF is whitelisting which mail servers send mail from your domain

DMARC is how receiving ends should report how your mail is delivered (or not).

Unless you're actively spamming (ahem, "marketing") to large volumes of users, you should have no trouble at all getting mail delivered to users.

If you are doing mass email marketing, stick with your core competence and let someone else handle the mail servers.

Re:Decommission of Cyrus Email by interfixus on Saturday May 06, 2017 @11:58PM (#14283771)
You shouldn't have any problems. But you do.

After fifteen years running my own mail systems, I have finally given up. Ever more outgoing mail was getting lost, despite everything being up to date and done by the book. The arch villains, over and over, were Gmail and the MS thing - Hotmail, outlook.com, Live, whatever they call it.

Re:Decommission of Cyrus Email by techsupporter on Sunday May 07, 2017 @04:09AM (#14284407)
> After fifteen years running my own mail systems, I have finally given up.

Same here. I've been hosting my own e-mail for two decades (as of this year) and I gave up earlier this year. My spouse's e-mail to friends who use GMail--something like 80% of them--would, every couple of months, disappear into the recipient's spam folder or sometimes just disappear entirely. My logs would show a successful delivery but the recipient couldn't find the message anywhere. Occasionally messages would start going into junk in the middle of a conversation.

Nothing I changed would permanently fix it. I'd send from a different IP in my block (something.something.194 instead of something.something.193) and mail would flow again...for a couple of months and then stop. My domain registration predates Google's existence by 18 months. I've been sending from the same IP subnet for six years. My colo provider is actually so small that I'm the only customer left on my "neighborhood" /24 (they've recently asked me if I want the entire block routed to me for the lulz). I have SPF, DKIM, and DMARC all set up and they've not changed for at least two years. The amount of mail outbound from my server is (was?) so little that I could tail the outbound mail log and keep up with each message being sent.

None of that mattered. I even signed up for Google's Postmaster Tools but, and this really cooked my goose, I send so little e-mail that I don't qualify to show up on their reports. I tried contacting Google but hahahahahahahahahahahaha--wheeze--hahahahahahahaha.

No other recipient had a problem with me. Messages were successfully delivered to Microsoft and Yahoo just fine. Only Google had a problem with my e-mail.

I finally caved. Google has SO MUCH of the e-mail market that unreachability to them is a catastrophe...and they know it. I don't have the leverage to make them play nice.

Thankfully, Fastmail does so I've changed to them. For the first time since February 1997 my MX doesn't point to my own server and that makes me a little sad.

Re:Decommission of Cyrus Email by interfixus on Monday May 08, 2017 @12:35AM (#14289283)
My experience exactly, though I didn't bother to spell it out in detail. Also the final move to Fastmail, who, it must be said, serves me nicely and well.
Re:Decommission of Cyrus Email by techsupporter on Monday May 08, 2017 @09:46PM (#14297149)
Yep, if it weren't for Fastmail I'd still be hosting my own e-mail and just quietly cursing the existence of Gmail. Now I get to have high significant other acceptance factor and curse the existence of Gmail.
Re:Decommission of Cyrus Email by JoshTriplett on Saturday May 06, 2017 @09:32PM (#14283355)
If you're not careful with how you do those things, though, then you'll be unable to send mail through quite a bit of standard mailing list software. It's possible to configure some (not all) of those in a way that allows mailing lists to work, but some of them are just completely incompatible.
Re:Decommission of Cyrus Email by colechristensen on Saturday May 06, 2017 @10:15PM (#14283477)
True. When it comes down to it, I'm on the side that says mailman is doing wrong when it modifies messages breaking their signatures.

Here's some background https://wiki.list.org/DEV/DKIM

Re:Decommission of Cyrus Email by bradknowles on Sunday May 07, 2017 @12:18AM (#14283824)
The people who designed DKIM didn't care about how mailing lists worked, they just did it anyway. But Mailman has adapted over the years, and Mailman3 is greatly improved. IMO, it's the best mailing list package out there, especially with regards to DKIM and DMARC compliance, but only if it is configured correctly.

However, even that can only carry you so far. Gmail is screwed up in how they handle reputation, especially with regard to IPv6. The exact same message delivered to Gmail via IPv6 will get refused versus sending it via IPv4 will work fine.

This problem has existed for years. There are even standard hacks for postfix to cause all mail addressed to Gmail to be sent via IPv4 only, just to avoid this problem.

And any domain hosted with GAFYD is likewise screwed.

You can't know what your false positive stats are, because you don't have access to all the remote SMTP spools or logs on the 'net. All you can know for sure is the false positives that you find out about. But you literally have no way to tell how big the iceberg is under the water.

Re:Decommission of Cyrus Email by lloeki on Sunday May 07, 2017 @03:07AM (#14284263)
> But you literally have no way to tell how big the iceberg is under the water.

Aren't DMARC reports supposed to tell you that, especially ruf?

Re:Decommission of Cyrus Email by tankenmate on Sunday May 07, 2017 @05:34PM (#14287816)
I've found DMARC reports to be incomplete or flat out lies from time to time.
Re:Decommission of Cyrus Email by JoshTriplett on Saturday May 06, 2017 @11:25PM (#14283680)
I'm not a big fan of mailing list software that modifies the non-header parts of messages. But, for instance, some of the signature schemes utterly break the ability of a mailing list to send mails on to the rest of the list members while preserving all the headers.
Re:Decommission of Cyrus Email by andybak on Saturday May 06, 2017 @08:14PM (#14283066)
Is this bulk mail? (I'm not implying spam - transactional or opt-in)

I only ask because I don't recall any problems over the years with one to one emails either to my gmail or from me to other people's gmail accounts.

Re:Decommission of Cyrus Email by peterwwillis on Saturday May 06, 2017 @08:59PM (#14283236)
AOL and Yahoo and a bunch of other providers used to be tough as well. I don't think there is much benefit to being _less_ scrutinizing when your user base is mostly consumers.
Re:Decommission of Cyrus Email by skarap on Sunday May 07, 2017 @07:28AM (#14284932)
> They have a tendency of 541-ing mails for no apparent reason

There is a reason. It makes people switch from own email servers to gmail.