A degree is not much more than a fresh start, a foot in the door, and some residual credibility.
That's true in some fields. But in some fields, you simply cannot succeed without a college degree. If you want to be a civil engineer designing bridges, you need a college degree. If you want to be a physician or even a registered nurse or physician's assistant, then you need a degree. Period.
Not many people are arguing it doesn't exist. People (or at least I) am giving evidence that college is not the only way to obtain this "premia," and that there is a cost, beyond which if college exceeds that cost, college is no longer favorable over its alternatives. Of course this is highly dependent on the university attended and the degree received and also depends on the individual involved. To blindly say, "college is always better" ignores all this evidence and turns off our minds to alternatives.
Several of my coworkers do not have 4-year degrees and make well over $100k/year.
Several my coworkers have graduate degrees from prestigious universities and are on the brink of being fired (some of them have been already).
A degree is not much more than a fresh start, a foot in the door, and some residual credibility.