News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Thieves Who Steal Sunken Warships, Right Down to the Bolts by devoply on Saturday May 06, 2017 @08:26AM (#14279945)
I am personally with the salvagers. They are making good use of an economic resource for themselves and for others. They are also cleaning the ocean of old debris, not getting lost in some misplaced sense of sentimentality. If the home countries of these vessels want them so bad they should simply salvage them themselves. It's stupid that we have laws that protect stuff that sunk over a few decades ago. If you can't clean it up in 10-20 years, someone else should be entitled to it who can.
Re:Thieves Who Steal Sunken Warships, Right Down to the Bolts by DanBC on Saturday May 06, 2017 @09:23AM (#14280122)
What's the difference between scrap metal and historically significant sites?

The Neolithic stone circle at Avebury, Wiltshire, had several stones removed by local villages who wanted stone to build cottages. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Avebury

In the centre of this screen, just south of Tunnel House In, you can see a square outline in a field. https://www.google.co.uk/maps/place/Coates,+Cirencester/@51....

That's a Roman camp. It's been ploughed over (it's just a field) and unscrupulous metal detectorists have plundered the site: http://www.bgas.org.uk/tbgas_bg/v119/bg119083.pdf

People taking this metal from sunken ships aren't just cleaning up a mess, they're destroying historical information.

And who knows what stuff is on the ships (oil, fuel) that isn't being properly cleaned up, just dumped into the ocean?

Re:Thieves Who Steal Sunken Warships, Right Down to the Bolts by Arizhel on Saturday May 06, 2017 @10:33AM (#14280401)
>People taking this metal from sunken ships aren't just cleaning up a mess, they're destroying historical information.

Who cares? If you really cared about that historical information, you'd salvage it and put it on display in a museum. "Historical information" isn't doing anyone any good sitting on the ocean floor.

>And who knows what stuff is on the ships (oil, fuel) that isn't being properly cleaned up, just dumped into the ocean?

Again, who cares? If you cared, you'd clean it up properly yourself, instead of just leaving it there to leak out into the ocean. The USS Arizona is still visibly leaking diesel fuel out into the water, and no one's doing anything about that, so it's hypocritical for you to complain about this.

This whole subject is just fraught with silly, misplaced sentimentality. I do personally agree that oil and fuel should be properly cleaned up, but we don't do that now, so it obviously isn't a valid concern. I do agree that historical information should be preserved, but we don't do that now (by leaving it inaccessible to the general public on the ocean floor in a remote part of the Pacific), so it obviously isn't a valid concern.

Re:Thieves Who Steal Sunken Warships, Right Down to the Bolts by Matt3o12_ on Saturday May 06, 2017 @10:22AM (#14280356)
Historical sites are normally somewhat maintained and preserved. They are also quite often seen by tourists who are interested in those sites.

Most sunken ships, they just sit there and nobody wants to take responsibility and maintain them so that no oil and fuel gets into the ocean. Furthermore, there is little to see. Sure there is some historical information on them but we should save those otherwise the ocean destroys them (surely but slowly).

If those sunken ships were properly maintained, I would also call those scrapers thieves because they take something that belongs to someone else and it has value to them. But since most are just sitting there, waiting to slowly decay.

The only things those scrapers should be held responsible for, is when they damage a tank or something like that which pollutes the ocean (and there should be resources on how to do that safely). But then again, those fuel tanks will leak at some point anyway (they won't last forever) and it should be our responsibility (as humans) to make sure that does not happen.

Re:Thieves Who Steal Sunken Warships, Right Down to the Bolts by marcosdumay on Saturday May 06, 2017 @11:19AM (#14280603)
The article goes to a great length about how those ships are popular tourist destinations.
Re:Thieves Who Steal Sunken Warships, Right Down to the Bolts by Freestyler_3 on Saturday May 06, 2017 @07:01PM (#14282748)
Sometimes it says that, other times it says that its not that many at all.
Re:Thieves Who Steal Sunken Warships, Right Down to the Bolts by johan_larson on Saturday May 06, 2017 @09:03AM (#14280051)
I agree. I think it would be best to legalize this sort of salvage operation. It's kind of cool that anyone can make this sort of operation pay. More power to them.

One issue that does deserve some attention is what should be done to any human remains in the wrecks. But if the salvage operations themselves were legal, so the recovery operations didn't have to operate on the sly, it should be possible to get them to obey minimal standards of decency.

The governments that owns the vessels should also get a cut.

Re:Thieves Who Steal Sunken Warships, Right Down to the Bolts by jfoster on Saturday May 06, 2017 @09:26AM (#14280135)
It should actually be the responsibility of a government/military to salvage. It may have sunk against their will, but they built it and put it in the water knowing that risk.
Re:Thieves Who Steal Sunken Warships, Right Down to the Bolts by Arizhel on Saturday May 06, 2017 @10:29AM (#14280387)
I agree completely. Even worse is how some people (in the article) think that there should be regular patrols to prevent "illegal" diving at these sites. So we want to waste resources and fuel just patrolling some remote ocean site to keep people from messing with an old ship sunken decades ago, and also not let any non-salvagers just look at it? It's crazy.

I'm all for museums and saving history, but this isn't it. Museums are great: you take something that could otherwise be lost, and you preserve and protect it and put it on display so that people can see it and learn from it. Keeping people away from a sunken warship doesn't do that at all. And the concern for the feelings of relatives of these long-dead crew is nuts too. How much concern is there for the feelings of the descendants of King Tut with his body on display? With these old ships, there are no bodies in many cases: human remains don't last long in the sea, unless they're locked up in a watertight compartment.

The final paragraph of the article is the only place where they really got it right: if you want to preserve these things, then salvage them yourself and put them in a museum. If you're going to leave something abandoned in the middle of nowhere, you can't get mad when someone comes and takes it.

Re:Thieves Who Steal Sunken Warships, Right Down to the Bolts by Nexxxeh on Saturday May 06, 2017 @11:13AM (#14280574)
Long-dead? This was only 75 years ago. My nan could have gone to school with some of the men that were killed on these ships. My nan is alive and well.

These ships are maritime war graves. The remains were of men that weren't vikings or ancient Egyptians. They were our grandparents generation. That's pretty damned recent.

Re:Thieves Who Steal Sunken Warships, Right Down to the Bolts by jmcdiesel on Sunday May 07, 2017 @10:40AM (#14285678)
Can you find a concrete, non-emotionally biased reason that they should be left alone? They are dead, hey memories live on not in the ship, but in the people who's lives they impacted.
Re:Thieves Who Steal Sunken Warships, Right Down to the Bolts by Nexxxeh on Tuesday May 09, 2017 @12:06AM (#14297663)
Is there any concrete non-emotionally biased reason we bother with gravestones? Or do anything ritualistic with our dead? Why we have tombs of the unknown soldier? We are emotional beings.
Re:Thieves Who Steal Sunken Warships, Right Down to the Bolts by keithpeter on Saturday May 06, 2017 @12:49PM (#14281111)
I take your point. I grew up in a seaside community that was notorious for questionable activities in the 18th and 19th centuries[1],[2]. There is a blunt harsh practical opportunistic side to seagoing people that might surprise you.

How do we balance the opportunity afforded to the salvagers against the grazing rights of the local fisherfolk? Is there a replacement structure that can be sunk locally like a concrete wall or honeycomb? Is there research on the time scale needed to seed the coral colonies? Should we place all pre-1942 steel in a UN mandated market?

[1] http://www.historyofwallasey.co.uk/wallasey/story_of_the_day...

[2] https://www.tutorhunt.com/resource/7035/

Re:Thieves Who Steal Sunken Warships, Right Down to the Bolts by rogerwilco1 on Saturday May 06, 2017 @08:57AM (#14280031)
Most of the ships are final resting places for the crew that went down with them. You don't disturb them for personal economic gain. Just like you don't steal a 100 year old stone from a graveyard.
Re:Thieves Who Steal Sunken Warships, Right Down to the Bolts by Nullabillity on Saturday May 06, 2017 @09:48AM (#14280209)
They're dead, good luck annoying them.
Re:Thieves Who Steal Sunken Warships, Right Down to the Bolts by jaimex2 on Saturday May 06, 2017 @09:19AM (#14280106)
Wouldn't the crew be long disolved?
Re:Thieves Who Steal Sunken Warships, Right Down to the Bolts by jfoster on Saturday May 06, 2017 @09:28AM (#14280143)
So you take their remains and give them a proper grave at the same time as cleaning up the shipwreck.
Re:Thieves Who Steal Sunken Warships, Right Down to the Bolts by douche on Saturday May 06, 2017 @09:04AM (#14280053)
Eh, we loot people's tombs and put their grave goods in museums all the time. It's essentially the entire business model of the field of archaeology.

The only difference is the amount of time that has passed.

Re:Thieves Who Steal Sunken Warships, Right Down to the Bolts by Nexxxeh on Saturday May 06, 2017 @11:05AM (#14280544)
>The only difference is the amount of time that has passed.

To me, your wording makes it sound like you think that is a minor difference.

I think it's a major difference in the negative direction.

These maritime war graves that are being robbed are of men whose children or grandchildren are alive.

(How many souls were lost aboard the HMS Electra alone, over a hundred ?)

A question I'm not sure I want to know the answer to - what are these thieving scumbags doing with the remains of the sailors who died aboard these ships?

Re:Thieves Who Steal Sunken Warships, Right Down to the Bolts by glubGlub on Saturday May 06, 2017 @10:18AM (#14280333)
The ocean is quite a different place. Wrecks are often debris fields, and not simple plots of land.

It's not appropriate to wax indignant about remains that may have all but disintegrated into unrecognizable mud. These are not organized places, like the parks on land with paths that people walk.

Consider the wreckage of the Titanic:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wreck_of_the_RMS_Titanic

No one can simply swin to the bottom of the ocean to pay their respects.

Re:Thieves Who Steal Sunken Warships, Right Down to the Bolts by marcosdumay on Saturday May 06, 2017 @11:18AM (#14280601)
They are destroying historical artifacts, and impoverishing the local ecosystem.

It's unsettling that a local population can not sink some steel to create a rich fishery anymore.

Re:Thieves Who Steal Sunken Warships, Right Down to the Bolts by coredog64 on Saturday May 06, 2017 @11:08AM (#14280559)
In doing so, they also destroyed an artificial reef that was aggregating fish for the local fishing industry. We should at least have a plan to replace that.
Re:Thieves Who Steal Sunken Warships, Right Down to the Bolts by ajnin on Saturday May 06, 2017 @10:37AM (#14280416)
I mostly agree with you. After 50 years untouched it should be up for grabs for anyone who cares. However as the article explains these old ships are one of the only sources of radioactivity-free steel (newer steel is contaminated by radionuclides due to the atmospheric nuclear explosions that took place from 1945). We should keep better track of it.
Re:Thieves Who Steal Sunken Warships, Right Down to the Bolts by MrJagil on Saturday May 06, 2017 @10:40AM (#14280431)
Do you have more info on this?