I don't disagree. But it's a weakness of C++, not of the language concept itself.
Perhaps if OP was saying you shouldn't use it for C++, then maybe I'd say he'd have a case.
> Perhaps if OP was saying you shouldn't use it for C++
I think that's exactly what he was saying.
Re:The Wrong Aesthetic
by loup-vaillant on Sunday June 13, 2010 @06:06PM
(#1428299)
It is.
Ah. I didn't get that from reading it.
And in Haskell,
foldl (+) 1 (map face_value dice)
would use fusion to avoid causing map to create another array!Incidentally fusion won't work for this example (at least not as currently implemented.) Only `foldr` is fusable. Fortunately, regular inlining does just fine.
There is of course an even simpler version:
sum (map face_value dice)Why does the sum start with 1? Why not eg.
foldl1' (+) $ map face_value dice
Re:The Wrong Aesthetic
by loup-vaillant on Sunday June 13, 2010 @06:10PM
(#1428307)
It should have started with 0. Sorry. And I avoided `foldl1` because I wanted to stay close to C++'s `accumulate`.
Shouldn't that be:
let total = foldl (+) 0 (map face_value dice)
Re:The Wrong Aesthetic
by loup-vaillant on Sunday June 13, 2010 @06:08PM
(#1428304)
Whoops. Yes it should.
No doubt. However, C++ stays a major contributor to that confusion. In ML languages,
is nearly idiomatic. Compare that to the C++ code. Compare that to C++ code that would use accumulate and an equivalent of map.