News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask: What would you do/make if you never had to monetize it? by Xichekolas on Friday March 21, 2008 @04:33PM (#142761)
An alternative to hierarchical file systems.
Re:Ask: What would you do/make if you never had to monetize it? by JulianMorrison on Friday March 21, 2008 @08:36PM (#142965)
How about a Zork style room-model file system?

You are in Foocorp documents. East is Bloggins&Smith, south is Vexcorp.

You can see Foocorp.xls

Bob is here. Jane is here.

Bob says "Jim, can we go over the numbers for Foo?"

> Use Foocorp.xls with Excel

(Excel starting...)

Re:Ask: What would you do/make if you never had to monetize it? by dkokelley on Friday March 21, 2008 @05:04PM (#142793)
I've been thinking recently about that too. It's inefficient to use a traditional folder/file system, at least for your personal documents (for system and program files I think they're better off the original way.)

What about folders that represent tags? I could tag a file (say a picture) with Danny (my name), Vacation, and 2007. The system creates 4 "folders" as we understand them, each one labeled with a tag, and the final one labeled as "images" or something similar (whatever the file type is). You could open the "images" folder and see the image, along with all other images. You could drill down further into images>vacation and see all files tagged with both images and vacation. You will also see additional folders for other items that have additional tags and fit in the images>vacation tag.

You could also get to the same file by going into the "Danny" folder, to see all files tagged with "Danny,"

It's a little difficult to explain, and I'm sure that what I'm trying to express is already being developed by someone, but either way, it is a more efficient system than what we already have. No more annoying shortcuts and restrictive folders.

Re:Ask: What would you do/make if you never had to monetize it? by Prrometheus on Friday March 21, 2008 @06:36PM (#142872)
At my work, some people organize documents on the shared drive by date and others by location of the client. So, if you want to look for the pitch we did for a certain Virginia client in January 2006 you first have to check the /Virginia/ folder and then check the /2006/Jan/ folder. If it's not in either one of those, it may be in /smith/companies/name_of_company/, where "smith" is the name of the guy that originally authored the documents. It's a mess.
Re:Ask: What would you do/make if you never had to monetize it? by wallflower on Friday March 21, 2008 @06:22PM (#142852)
What is your opinion (on the concepts) of David Gelenter's Lifestreams project?

http://www.cs.yale.edu/~freeman/lifestreams.html

One can imagine it's Time Machine'sque metaphor being extended to archive your online life (twitter, Facebook) as well (assuming the data could be retrieved)

Re:Ask: What would you do/make if you never had to monetize it? by fugue88 on Saturday March 22, 2008 @08:11PM (#143666)
What about this? Put every document in a directory called 'All' or something. Want to tag foo.txt as vacation? 'mkdir vacation && ln All/foo.txt vacation/'
Re:Ask: What would you do/make if you never had to monetize it? by staticshock on Friday March 21, 2008 @06:11PM (#142840)
I've considered this idea myself, previously, and I like it a lot. The beauty is that if you go to \Images\Vacation\2005, it's the same as going to \2005\Vacation\Images, so you can access your files in an intuitive way no matter which train of thought got you there.

The only thing I haven't been able to figure out is how to represend these tags as directories. You shouldn't see them all at the top level, that'd be pretty crowded.

Re:Ask: What would you do/make if you never had to monetize it? by Xichekolas on Friday March 21, 2008 @06:26PM (#142856)
I always just thought you'd index the tags and search on them.
Re:Ask: What would you do/make if you never had to monetize it? by frankus on Friday March 21, 2008 @06:11PM (#142839)
It seems like that would be pretty straightforward to add to any filesystem that already supports metadata.

I'm sure Windows has something similar, but on MacOS X.5 (a feature borrowed from BeOS, IIRC), you can create a Smart Folder that's basically a canned query for files matching a very large set of criteria. I'm not sure what the API is for extending the criteria, but presumably adding tags wouldn't be all that difficult.

Re:Ask: What would you do/make if you never had to monetize it? by Xichekolas on Friday March 21, 2008 @05:26PM (#142809)
Yeah my thoughts on the matter have always included tagging. It just seems logical to have the same file in more than one group (or folder if you want to call it that), and I hate drilling down seven levels to find something. My problem has always been in dealing with system files. The current setup seems rather logical for them anyway. Maybe a two pronged approach like you suggest makes the most sense.
Re:Ask: What would you do/make if you never had to monetize it? by halo on Sunday March 23, 2008 @02:48AM (#143860)
You could do something extremely similar with BFS 10 years ago, and that's the concept behind the long-delayed WinFS.
Re:Ask: What would you do/make if you never had to monetize it? by projectileboy on Friday March 21, 2008 @06:44PM (#142882)
Google Docs is organized this way.
Re:Ask: What would you do/make if you never had to monetize it? by dkokelley on Friday March 21, 2008 @07:04PM (#142899)
Is it really? I thought it was just search for your documents by keywords found in them. There is no way to look at all the tags or navigate through them. That's actually one of my issues with GDocs. You don't have many organizational tools for the documents. They would actually be a good candidate for an overhaul similar to what we're discussing.
Re:Ask: What would you do/make if you never had to monetize it? by projectileboy on Saturday March 22, 2008 @12:09AM (#143095)
Maybe I'm confused, but I think the "folders" in Google Docs behave the way you'd like. I can put a doc in one or more folders, and then I can look at the contents of only one folder. And I can have sub-folders. And really the folders are just tags.
Re:Ask: What would you do/make if you never had to monetize it? by Hexstream on Friday March 21, 2008 @05:17PM (#142807)
Indeed. I came up with a new motto lately: "Premature hierarchisation is the root of all rigidity."
Re:Ask: What would you do/make if you never had to monetize it? by frankus on Friday March 21, 2008 @06:22PM (#142851)
One of my many "I'll never have time for that" interests is experimenting with OS-wide transparent persistence.
Re:Ask: What would you do/make if you never had to monetize it? by andr on Friday March 21, 2008 @04:47PM (#142773)
Microsoft is already working on that. ;)
Re:Ask: What would you do/make if you never had to monetize it? by sabat on Friday March 21, 2008 @05:09PM (#142797)
All the more reason for someone else to work on it, and do it right.
Re:Ask: What would you do/make if you never had to monetize it? by mixmax on Friday March 21, 2008 @05:44PM (#142815)
i wouldn't worry about Microsoft actually developing something new and useful. Unless Apple did it first of course.
Re:Ask: What would you do/make if you never had to monetize it? by pius on Friday March 21, 2008 @06:10PM (#142837)
To be fair, WinFS (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/WinFS) had some really exciting ideas in it. I distinctly remember being a sophomore in college, looking forward to "Longhorn" because of things like WinFS, but having trepidation about it because of things like Palladium. Of course, that was a good six years ago. They ended up gutting both of those features out of Vista to get the OS out the door and even then it was years late. But I digress. :)
Re:Ask: What would you do/make if you never had to monetize it? by strey on Friday March 21, 2008 @07:23PM (#142912)
Bah, stop pandering to the Microsoft haters.
Re:Ask: What would you do/make if you never had to monetize it? by mixmax on Friday March 21, 2008 @10:05PM (#143024)
It wasn't meant to pander anybody - it was merely stating an opinion...
Re:Ask: What would you do/make if you never had to monetize it? by strey on Friday March 21, 2008 @10:18PM (#143041)
Ah, good point. On another note, people who vote on HN are the smartest people in the world. That's my opinion.
Re:Ask: What would you do/make if you never had to monetize it? by strey on Saturday March 22, 2008 @04:00AM (#143199)
Apparently the voters disagree.
Re:Ask: What would you do/make if you never had to monetize it? by icky on Saturday March 22, 2008 @04:18AM (#143205)
Maybe they felt pandered-to? ;)
Re:Ask: What would you do/make if you never had to monetize it? by strey on Saturday March 22, 2008 @04:29AM (#143209)
No, no, I'm just expressing an opinion, like mixmax. It's up to the voters whether they actually think they're so smart. For example, here is another opinion: icky is the best handle ever.
Re:Ask: What would you do/make if you never had to monetize it? by icky on Saturday March 22, 2008 @01:25PM (#143424)
Why, thank you! :)
Re:Ask: What would you do/make if you never had to monetize it? by sabat on Friday March 21, 2008 @09:49PM (#143011)
Actually that's not how I meant it. Regardless of who is working on it, it shouldn't stop you from working on it yourself and doing it better.
Re:Ask: What would you do/make if you never had to monetize it? by strey on Friday March 21, 2008 @09:53PM (#143016)
And that's why you stuck "do it right" on at the end, eh?
Re:Ask: What would you do/make if you never had to monetize it? by sabat on Friday March 21, 2008 @11:45PM (#143077)
"Do it right" means as opposed to doing something the way a big corporation would do it (generally design by committee or by apathetic drones). MS is certainly guilty of that, but I wasn't picking on them.
Re:Ask: What would you do/make if you never had to monetize it? by strey on Friday March 21, 2008 @07:27PM (#142913)
Windows has had the ability to categorize files for awhile. If you look in a file's properties, you can add custom properties to any file. I don't know if there is a way to use these properties in the file system, though.
Re:Ask: What would you do/make if you never had to monetize it? by soxos on Saturday March 22, 2008 @12:06PM (#143366)
Why not take over the ReiserFS project? We all know about the difficulties it's leader is having...
Re:Ask: What would you do/make if you never had to monetize it? by nkohari on Saturday March 22, 2008 @01:33PM (#143429)
Because Reiser is hierarchical, no?