News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ethical considerations of access to the HackerOne community by tptacek on Friday May 05, 2017 @12:38PM (#14274743)
I see these kinds of arguments as being something that any message board nerd of sufficient experience can generate in any situation; it's just catnip for flame wars. If you try to generate an all-encompassing framework for the ethics of your project, bored nerds will chase you all the way back to Gödel with nitpicking inconsistencies.

To me --- and, let's be honest, to pretty much the overwhelming majority of all other people --- it's enough to say "we've decided we're not going to work with spyware companies", just as for the most part it's fine to say "we're not going to work with people who publicly lobby for racism or misogyny"† without connecting the dots on that statement all the way back through Rawls and John Stuart Mill.

I think at present it's a courtesy to announce those kinds of beliefs, preferably in the simplest way possible, just so nobody is shocked when you exercise your prerogative to enforce them. I obviously don't think the resulting "code of conduct" statements need to be formally impregnable.

† You could make the opposite statement as well, as I think at least one project has sort of done implicitly. I don't begrudge anyone that right; why would I bother? If you want to pour kerosene over your professional reputation and light a match, who am I to stop you?

There are no comments on this comment yet.