News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Review of Ayn Rand by stcredzero on Sunday June 13, 2010 @10:16AM (#1427461)
Objectivism takes as its metaphysical foundation the existence of reality that is unchanged by anything that an observer might think about itβ€”"A is A," as Aristotle put it, and as Rand often repeated in her own work. Objectivism's epistemology is based on the capacity of the human mind to perceive reality through reason, and the adamant assertion that reason is the only way to perceive reality. In Rand's view, notions of intuition or spiritual insight were hokum.

This sounds an awful lot like the philosophy of the Bayesian conspirators over at lesswrong.com. However, instead of pronouncing intuition to be hokum, they just say that intuition isn't magic. I wonder how Ayn Rand would've been informed by the wealth of knowledge we've gained in the study of the brain and cognition and by computer science? Objectivism would have been quite different. (Not suffused with the false notion of mind as tabula rasa.)

EDIT: An excellent Review. http://lesswrong.com/lw/m1/guardians_of_ayn_rand/#more

Re:Review of Ayn Rand by grandalf on Sunday June 13, 2010 @11:36AM (#1427558)
Eliezer is not reviewing Rand's work, he's accumulating a variety of gossip about her life and judging the organization that she formed (which still exists) on that basis.

I think Eliezer is trying a bit hard to have a negative view of Rand (which is a very faddish view these days). Rand's scientist heroes would fit right in among the LessWrong crew, and Rand acknowledged that her own role (as a philosopher and novelist) was to help elucidate the moral issues around reason and capitalism. She was not particularly interested in the mechanics of reason itself, but I would guess that she would very much have enjoyed LessWrong.

Rand's heroes were driven, passionate, often outcasts from society. They sought only their work and the fulfillment they gain from it. Their processes involve reason, but their identities do not. Their creative drive is more like what we expect from artists these days. Perhaps this feels foreign to those in academia who live grant to grant.

note: I consider Eliezer Yudkowsky one of the most important intellectuals alive today. Of course, I judge him by his primary work not by his personal habits or his occasional rant about subjects that are not his focus.

Re:Review of Ayn Rand by stcredzero on Sunday June 13, 2010 @12:08PM (#1427610)
he's accumulating a variety of gossip about her life and judging the organization that she formed

By my lights, an individual or organization can be judged by how well they adapt to reality: do they interpret facts to suit their ideology, or does their ideology grow by accepting new facts and knowledge?

By this measure, it's much easier to have a negative view of certain of Rand's followers.

They sought only their work and the fulfillment they gain from it.

I think this will be my new credo.

Perhaps this feels foreign to those in academia who live grant to grant.

Perhaps this is like certain entrepreneurs who live to exit, or head hunters who live only for their fee. We should navigate and groom our incentives instead of letting them rule us.

Re:Review of Ayn Rand by grandalf on Sunday June 13, 2010 @12:29PM (#1427654)
By this measure, it's much easier to have a negative view of certain of Rand's followers.

I completely agree. I have generally had a fairly negative impression of the organizations that exist today to support her philosophy, but I read most of her books (fiction and nonfiction) and enjoyed them tremendously.

Re:Review of Ayn Rand by stcredzero on Sunday June 13, 2010 @12:43PM (#1427679)
I have generally had a fairly negative impression of the organizations that exist today to support her philosophy, but I read most of her books (fiction and nonfiction) and enjoyed them tremendously.

I've had a generally negative impression of her followers. All self identifying "Objectivists" I've met seem to be "second-handers" latching onto greatness as a substitute for their own work. This term comes from The Fountainhead, which I enjoyed greatly. I am certain that it's useful to occasionally ask oneself, "Am I second-handing?" My answer in a few cases has been "yes."

(In particular, regard for the individual and reason are not gods. They are not absolutes but best regarded as good policies and tools.)

Re:Review of Ayn Rand by grandalf on Sunday June 13, 2010 @12:52PM (#1427694)
Note that Rand herself disliked the term "objectivism" and so I think she'd be in agreement.
Re:Review of Ayn Rand by SkyMarshal on Sunday June 13, 2010 @12:49PM (#1427690)
>I wonder how Ayn Rand would've been informed by the wealth of knowledge we've gained in the study of the brain and cognition and by computer science? Objectivism would have been quite different.

Now that would make a quite interesting blog/thesis/book. If you or anyone else ever gets motivated to write such a thing, I'd certainly be motivated to read it. :)

Re:Review of Ayn Rand by ThomPete on Sunday June 13, 2010 @02:27PM (#1427879)
Anyone who even think a little about A is A will realize how little it provides beside some circular reasoning.

The problem with Rands repetition of A = A is not that it's wrong but that it doesn't bring anything to the table.

The real question obviously is what is A?

Re:Review of Ayn Rand by maxharris on Monday June 14, 2010 @12:08AM (#1428854)
"The real question obviously is what is A?"

A is any entity.

Re:Review of Ayn Rand by ThomPete on Monday June 14, 2010 @01:34AM (#1428995)
That is not an answer to what we are talking about.
Re:Review of Ayn Rand by maxharris on Monday June 14, 2010 @07:20PM (#1431336)
Asking "what is a" with respect to identity is like asking "what does x stand for" in an algebra problem. It really isn't hard...