Re:A New Social Contract with Basic Income
by frgtpsswrdlame on Thursday May 04, 2017 @05:23PM
(#14268961)
It would be the second and even though they may not be necessary, they would still be beneficial.
See this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Job_guarantee
http://www.levyinstitute.org/pubs/wp_732.pdf
The rest of the world is finally catching up the advantage we made for ourselves post-WWII and combining that with technological change we're going to be facing a labor market with a lot of (at least frictionally) unemployed people. In that case you do what FDR did and hand them a shovel and tell them to improve their community.
Re:A New Social Contract with Basic Income
by colorint on Thursday May 04, 2017 @05:13PM
(#14268884)
Are all social services unnecessary because they're created ex nihilo by the government? Most job guarantee programs involve looking at something like that, as well as things like art grants and infrastructure and maintenance and so forth.
Re:A New Social Contract with Basic Income
by abecedarius on Thursday May 04, 2017 @06:01PM
(#14269255)
You're equating not-done-in-the-market with unnecessary. Public goods are hard to fund via markets -- for instance, if the U.S. military vanished tomorrow I don't think it'd be replaced by corporations competing to sign you up for defense against invasions by offering the best service at the lowest price. (This also shows a downside of governments providing public goods: we in the U.S. are buying way more "defense" than optimal.)
Re:A New Social Contract with Basic Income
by maxerickson on Thursday May 04, 2017 @05:28PM
(#14269003)
Basic mechanization makes it hard to put a lot of people to work physically, but there's all sorts of things that can be done that improve the world in small ways.
Here's a dumb one: end "Adopt a highway" and pay people to clean up along roads.
- The government can force companies to give jobs to people they would not otherwise hire
- The government can invent unnecessary jobs and then hire people to do them. (The jobs would have to be unnecessary in order to be invented, because if they were necessary, they would already exist.)
Both of these solutions are terrible, and I can't think of any others that are qualitatively different -- you either put people in existing jobs or create new jobs.
The point of UBI, according to most of its proponents, is that it deals with a future of automation in which many people will not be able to find work.