Re:SEO Is Mostly Quack Science
by Aaronontheweb on Saturday June 12, 2010 @09:55PM
(#1426829)
"By testing and iterating one can determine sufficient detail to game the algorithm and produce better rankings. This is science. Hypothesise, test, analyse, improve, iterate."
The point of the article is that the people who conduct this type of research get the science wrong more often than not.
You largely echo this sentiment of the article. However you're missing on 2 very important points IMO.
One is that there are hidden algorithms used to determine where a page ranks in the SERPs. By testing and iterating one can determine sufficient detail to game the algorithm and produce better rankings. This is science. Hypothesise, test, analyse, improve, iterate.
Two is that a minute difference in page "score" can be a lot in terms of rank and hence expected return assuming visits can be turned to sales.
Certain SEOs can and do acquire and maintain top rankings. They're not doing it by doing the same as everyone else, the algo's shift and these SEOs maintain their positions.
Those minutiae you're hair-splitting are like deviations to the fine-structure constant, the results cascade to greater final effects.