Re:You're Doing It Wrong: CS in the real world
by jemfinch on Saturday June 12, 2010 @05:07PM
(#1426520)
> I mean, he's basically arguing that CS hasn't revisited heaps since 1961...But that's of course not the case.
Then kindly link me to the paper which describes his B-heaps; I'd love to read it.
Re:You're Doing It Wrong: CS in the real world
by _delirium on Saturday June 12, 2010 @05:34PM
(#1426571)
His specific B-heaps might indeed be novel; I'm not claiming he makes no contribution. I'm just objecting to the portion of his paper that claims that nobody in CS has ever thought of the idea of optimizing heaps for the properties of a modern computer's memory hierarchy. He seems to really believe Knuth's 1961 paper is the last word on the subject, or at least says so.
Fwiw, here's a widely cited 1996 paper that describes a different variety of block-aggregated heaps, "d-heaps", aimed mainly at cache-aware performance: http://lamarca.org/anthony/pubs/heaps.pdf
It's quite possible that no existing heap layouts solve his specific problem, but he could've at least acknowledged that there exist heaps newer than Knuth's, and that many of them specifically look at the influence of the memory hierarchy on performance.
Re:You're Doing It Wrong: CS in the real world
by jemfinch on Saturday June 12, 2010 @11:41PM
(#1426923)
That's a great paper, thanks for the reference.
Re:You're Doing It Wrong: CS in the real world
by gaius on Saturday June 12, 2010 @05:34PM
(#1426570)
Undergraduate CS education certainly hasn't.
Re:You're Doing It Wrong: CS in the real world
by _delirium on Saturday June 12, 2010 @06:29PM
(#1426640)
Hmm, my undergrad algorithms class at least mentioned the existence of cache effects, though it didn't really go into any detail. It had a bit of disclaimer along the lines of: for simplicity, we don't take into account caches in this class, but more modern models of computation do, and for real-world applications you might want to look up cache-aware algorithms.
Re:You're Doing It Wrong: CS in the real world
by stcredzero on Saturday June 12, 2010 @07:38PM
(#1426709)
Hmm, my undergrad algorithms class at least mentioned the existence of cache effects, though it didn't really go into any detail.
There should at least be exposure on the level of a walkthrough of the optimization of a real-world server. There was a concurrency optimization video posted to HN a couple of weeks ago.
In mine, we learnt about the hardware, the cache hierarchy and so on, completely separately from the algorithms and complexity theory. Two different classes, two professors. Probably they both knew it themselves, but it never occurred to them to cross-pollinate their course materials.
I mean, he's basically arguing that CS hasn't revisited heaps since 1961, and hasn't noticed that things like caches or VM pressure might change what the optimal algorithm looks like. But that's of course not the case.