News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Giving the Behemoths a Leg Up on the Little Guy by pharrlax on Wednesday May 03, 2017 @11:43PM (#14262281)
What's stunning to me is seeing Ajit Pai and conservative interest groups citing the FCC's investigation into ISPs subsidizing certain types of data (a.k.a. zero-rating) as an innovation that burdensome regulation was inhibiting.

There's plenty of room for debate on what constitutes predatory pricing. But I think it's clear that when you drop the price for a product to zero, there's no longer an argument that you are attempting to fairly compete in that market. The only rational reason is to drive your competitors out of business.

Pai isn't interested in a competitive market; he's told us that much explicitly. He's interested in a market where the powerful have a free hand to consolidate that power into full-on monopoly. And he's right, consumers will see certain benefits -- like zero-rating -- while that consolidation is occurring. But then, afterwards, we'll be stuck relearning the lessons of Standard Oil and Pacific Bell all over again.

Re:Giving the Behemoths a Leg Up on the Little Guy by whack on Thursday May 04, 2017 @09:48AM (#14264775)
To play devil's advocate, there are plenty of businesses where companies sell loss-leaders in order to bring in customers, who then spend lucrative amounts of money on other things. Black Friday deals are one example. Mexican restaurants offering free salsa and chips is another.

On a larger scheme though, I agree that companies selling things at below-cost, can lead to anti-competitive outcomes that bankrupt any competitors without deep pockets. Uber's subsidized rides are an example of this. The WTO has rules against this when it comes to international trade. Perhaps it's time we adopted similar laws domestically as well.

Re:Giving the Behemoths a Leg Up on the Little Guy by pharrlax on Thursday May 11, 2017 @07:13AM (#14315197)
Sure, but Mexican restaurants' salsa and chips isn't a separate industry. Offering free chips with dinner isn't an attempt to price people out of buying Tostitos at the grocery store.

It's one thing when you offer a subset of services within the same industry as a loss leader; it's another when you extend your reach to another industry and start pricing out existing companies to gain a foothold there.

Re:Giving the Behemoths a Leg Up on the Little Guy by jtraffic on Thursday May 04, 2017 @10:11AM (#14264924)
> But I think it's clear that when you drop the price for a product to zero, there's no longer an argument that you are attempting to fairly compete in that market. The only rational reason is to drive your competitors out of business.

This statement is far too rigid. You probably don't mean it exactly as written. To illustrate, this would imply that Robinhood was not attempting to fairly compete in the brokerage market when it first launched.

Re:Giving the Behemoths a Leg Up on the Little Guy by pharrlax on Thursday May 11, 2017 @07:17AM (#14315207)
Robinhood is an exception because their business is holding funds. When you hold funds, you can make interest off them. I guess the better way to say it is "when you drop the profit you receive from a product to zero".
Re:Giving the Behemoths a Leg Up on the Little Guy by Aloha on Thursday May 04, 2017 @02:12AM (#14262846)
I think he's trying to solve a different problem.. universal access to networks.

I don't think his measures will actually solve it, but I don't think he's protecting incumbents for the sake of protecting them.

Re:Giving the Behemoths a Leg Up on the Little Guy by matt4077 on Thursday May 04, 2017 @05:01AM (#14263539)
Trying my hardest to keep an open mind, this argument is the closest I've seen to something even remotely sane, but I'm stumped in regards to the specific mechanism. I can think of two, and would love to hear if anyone can improve them:

(a) There's a house a mile away from the city. Right now, running a cable to it isn't worth it for the X$/mo they would pay for internet. Without net neutrality, Comcast will also get 20% of Amazon's revenue, and Netflix', and the investment starts to make sense. (My criticism: Those 20% will have to be added to Amazon's prices, considering their thin margins, and the customer could have just paid the total directly to Comcast, without all the harm to people not in their situation. Also: this argument rapidly loses plausibility for even a small cluster of, say, a dozen houses. If you want to life in a cabin in the woods, slow internet seems like the sort of trade-off it involves. You get clean air, in turn. Although that may be changing, as well).

(b) A simple trickle-down theory of network access: Comcast will make so much money, some of it just has to end up in network investment. (criticism: there really isn't a point at which a company will say "we have so much money, let's spend a little more on investments bound to cost us money")

Re:Giving the Behemoths a Leg Up on the Little Guy by Aloha on Thursday May 04, 2017 @05:37PM (#14269090)
It kinda makes sense for me, it increases the effective margin on services, so it could make an area that would otherwise be not cost effective for service, cost effective. Telcos only make expansions for areas that can generate an effective rate of return, if the density required to make a rate of return drops a wider area can be serviced.

I'm optimistic but not hopeful - we didn't have these kinds of services long enough to see if they would move the needle.. but I strongly suspect that they wouldn't, and would just line the pockets of the incumbent telcos.

For things like utilities I'm a big big big believer in regulated monopolies. It makes no sense from a cost perspective to have duplicated facilities rather than rate of return based financing.. and if you want universal access, you need that cross subsidization that was done before divestiture (high margin services subsidized low margin ones to ensure universal access).

In the end, the only way to have universal service is to have some sort of cross subsidization either from higher margin services the telco also sells, or from an external entity.

Re:Giving the Behemoths a Leg Up on the Little Guy by metaphorm on Thursday May 04, 2017 @12:00PM (#14265864)
it's possible for Ajit Pai to have more than one objective. He may value universal access to networks but it is just as clear from his other statements that he values deregulation of big businesses because it benefits those businesses, social side effects be damned.
Re:Giving the Behemoths a Leg Up on the Little Guy by golergka on Thursday May 04, 2017 @04:51AM (#14263499)
> there's no longer an argument that you are attempting to fairly compete in that market. The only rational reason is to drive your competitors out of business.

Wait. "Fairly compete" and "drive your competitors out of business" are opposite things now? How?

Obviously, most businesses, ideally, want to be so successful so that their competitors go out of business - as long as the market is more or less zero-sum game, one always go in hand with the other.

Re:Giving the Behemoths a Leg Up on the Little Guy by dbingham on Thursday May 04, 2017 @08:53AM (#14264415)
> ...as long as the market is more or less zero-sum game, one always go in hand with the other.

This statement derives from pure propaganda. It has almost never played out that way in history. What almost always actually happens is that once a business gets large enough, it has the power to force all of its competitors into bankruptcy or buy them out and then it gets monopoly power. Once it has monopoly power, anything goes.

There are so many examples of this just in American history up until Teddy Roosevelt busted the trusts. Even after that, there are a ton of examples of businesses being allowed to get way too close before the government got around to breaking them up.

If you want to see the clearest example what happens in an entirely unregulated free market -- look at the internet. The internet has, thus far, been almost entirely unregulated and it has the lowest barrier to entry of almost any business ever. It takes almost no capital to start an internet startup -- just the knowledge and some free time. And yet, Google has near monopoly power over search. Facebook has near monopoly power over social media. Amazon is nearing monopoly power over internet retail. In each case, they haven't wielded their enormous power in the marketplace, largely for fear of public backlash leading to regulation. If there was no threat of regulation, you could sure bet they would.

Re:Giving the Behemoths a Leg Up on the Little Guy by hueving on Friday May 05, 2017 @09:49AM (#14273390)
>And yet, Google has near monopoly power over search. Facebook has near monopoly power over social media. Amazon is nearing monopoly power over internet retail

Absolute nonsense. These players have large market shares but that is not anything close to a monopoly. Bing, Walmart, and Twitter are just 1 second away.

Here is a rule of thumb, if you can change companies in less than 5 minutes without getting dressed, they have nothing close to a monopoly.

The reason they haven't "wielded their enormous power" is because people can so easily switch. That's not a problem monopolies or near monopolies have (see Comcast for an example of near monopoly behavior).

Re:Giving the Behemoths a Leg Up on the Little Guy by api on Thursday May 04, 2017 @09:42AM (#14264724)
It's worse than that. There is no such thing as an impenetrable firewall between the public and the private sphere.

It's one of the areas where libertarian idealism doesn't quite work in the real world. I can't think of a way to limit the political influence of business without limiting the size and financial leverage of individual businesses. A libertarian society that fails to do this will not remain libertarian for long, since suitably large corporate entities will become the state.

Why compete at all when you can just write your own laws and tap the public treasury?

Re:Giving the Behemoths a Leg Up on the Little Guy by mdpopescu on Thursday May 04, 2017 @12:10PM (#14265971)
The reason why large corporate entities becoming the state is less of a problem than the actual state is because of competition.

I called the cops three times in my life (Romania), the first two times I was told "not my job" (public drunkness instances), the third time someone's life was actually in danger. They told me they're going to show up... half an hour later, I had to leave the place; they hadn't showed up. (And they never called me back, so they probably never bothered.)

I cannot fire them for that. I cannot tell them "I want to hire another company". That is the problem I have with the state. I actually don't want to bother with defending myself - I am more than willing to pay someone else to do it for me. But if the state claims to do that, I cannot go to the competition when they don't do their job.

Re:Giving the Behemoths a Leg Up on the Little Guy by dbingham on Friday May 05, 2017 @09:09AM (#14273128)
I understand why a corporate entity being the state sounds appealing -- the theory that you at least _can_ go to another company seems really appealing on its face.

But in reality, there is no difference.

What you're missing here is that in a monopoly situation there is no competition. You can't go hire another company. You can tell the monopoly you want to hire another company until you're blue in the face, but they don't care. They know you don't actually have the option, because there is no other company to hire.

You can try to start another company, but in a monopoly situation, the monopoly can always out compete you. They can simply drop prices in your small area of competition below you (or to zero) until you go out of business. Even if people hate the monopoly, they often won't be able to afford your higher prices.

And if you look at history, when companies achieve monopoly power, they do often essentially usurp the power of the state, up to and including coercive force. Look at the history of unionization attempts in the mining industry, particularly in the Appalachians here in the US. In the late 1800s and early 1900s, union attempts were often suppressed with privately hired military force -- or with the state's military hired out as a private military force.

And there's another level, corporate entities as state are worse, in many respects than an inefficient or corrupt democratic state. With a democratic state, it's still, ostensibly, answerable to the people. If you can organize enough of a popular response against it at the polls and in street protests, you can change it. A corporate entity is answerable to its owners and stockholders. It's an oligarchy. When it becomes the state, it becomes the worse kind of dictatorship and your only choice is revolution.

Re:Giving the Behemoths a Leg Up on the Little Guy by api on Thursday May 04, 2017 @12:37PM (#14266278)
How do you compete with a corporate entity that has become the state?

Getting back to net neutrality: you also have the concept of a natural monopoly.

A natural monopoly is something where there is an intrinsic barrier to competition. In the case of telecom there is a natural monopoly over last mile connectivity because it makes zero economic sense to create more than one or two redundant last mile connectivity networks. It would also be an eyesore. Imagine huge sprawling bundles of wires or constant digging everywhere.

So for telecoms like Cox, Comcast, etc. you have a double whammy: they are natural monopolies and competition is also restricted by a state over which they have achieved regulatory capture.

These companies are monopolies, plain and simple, and if they can leverage that monopoly they can effectively shut down the Internet as a venue for entrepreneurship.

Re:Giving the Behemoths a Leg Up on the Little Guy by mdpopescu on Thursday May 04, 2017 @03:39PM (#14268022)
If by "become the state" you mean "is supplying state-like services" (like defense), you compete by creating another company supplying the same services. We have dozens of private defense companies in Romania.

If you mean "is preventing others from supplying the same services"... if it does that by using force, we're no worse off than now. If it does that by enticing people to sign bad agreements... I can't say I like the idea, but I'm not seeing it as a big deal long-term.

> In the case of telecom there is a natural monopoly over last mile connectivity because it makes zero economic sense to create more than one or two redundant last mile connectivity networks

And yet, I have one ISP that put up 7 km of fiber optics, that have been stolen several times, in order to get my business. (I live in the country side.) I had another ISP that put up 15 km of regular cable for the same reason. (I no longer use them because at some point I had 3 ISPs and I was trying to cut costs. I honestly regret that now that I'm making a lot more money.)

Re:Giving the Behemoths a Leg Up on the Little Guy by scarmig on Thursday May 04, 2017 @06:33AM (#14263839)
There's a world of difference, in context.

One is in kind of an equilibrium, where the costs of a product or service are included as part of the good. Consumers can choose the product that makes legible the costs and labor that went into it. Some suppliers will win, others will lose, but it's based on transparent pricing, which markets function best with.

The other only sustains low prices through some exogenous means. It could be a VC dumping money to subsidize a product until all other competitors are gone and network effects take over. It could be a company taking revenues from one profitable product line and investing them to subsidize other product spaces where competitors have to rely on making money from the explicit pricing.

On the surface they're similar, in that one company has consumers choosing their product over another's.

The difference is what will happen down the line to consumers. In one situation any bad behavior can be quickly corrected by the market.

The other is the image of Comcast charging you for a boot stamping on your face forever, even though you never asked for the boot and have requested half a dozen times that they stop the boot stamping on your face service.

Re:Giving the Behemoths a Leg Up on the Little Guy by humanrebar on Thursday May 04, 2017 @06:16AM (#14263791)
You can be the best at what you do by improving yourself or you can be the best at what you do by making sure nobody else can even do it in the first place.

The problem with zero rating is that it is unlikely that new players will end up getting zero rated. So we're not talking about established players being really good at using less bandwidth or something, we're talking about established players having entirely different rules than newcomers.

Re:Giving the Behemoths a Leg Up on the Little Guy by white-flame on Thursday May 04, 2017 @09:31AM (#14264648)
Regarding "zero-sum game", a very basic principle is that the labor of the individual creates new value, thus the sum of the market can expand.
Re:Giving the Behemoths a Leg Up on the Little Guy by devrandomguy on Thursday May 04, 2017 @05:41AM (#14263670)
IMO, the "fair" part implies a set of rules that promote a more interesting playing field, rather than total war.