News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Puerto Rico files for biggest ever U.S. local government ... by anigbrowl on Wednesday May 03, 2017 @06:03PM (#14260605)
Two (heavily loaded) questions.

First: what you do with a debt is to you pay it off

Why? not all debts are created equal. Some contracts are unconscionable, and there's a related question of why people should be obligated on contracts that were negotiated on their behalf but in bad faith. I'm not saying that describes all of Puerto Rico's debts, but bad faith contracts are common enough that that they shouldn't just be passively accepted.

Of course I know this has been litigated a lot already and I don't expect you to start over that whole process from the beginning, but I'm always a bit skeptical of blanket moral assertions like this.

Second: I presume that, like most places, there are a lot of poor but more-or-less honest people who know little of complex business and governance affairs but are heavily impacted by them, to their economic detriment; and I presume further that there are rather fewer people who are expert at conducting such affairs, and have enriched themselves through this knowledge without having provided equitable value in return to those they have been dealing with.

Has anyone explored the idea of prosecuting the latter group and confiscating ill-gotten gains? While doing so risks infringing upon cherished concepts of property rights and due process if not conducted correctly, bankruptcy is a singular event that results from some breakdown or conceptual weakness of The Rules, and in collective contexts it seems only natural that the pain of bankruptcy should be distributed in approximate proportion to the pleasure that preceded the bankruptcy.

After all, one of the practical benefits of wealth is the ability to spend a lot of resources on placing procedural barriers between your wealth and anyone else who might want to make a claim upon it, whereas poor people are generally limited to hoping their door is strong enough to keep out wolves. The degree of legal or physical security you can afford is not necessarily correlated with the validity of one's moral claim on the property in question.

Re:Puerto Rico files for biggest ever U.S. local government ... by rovr138 on Wednesday May 03, 2017 @11:41PM (#14262273)
What I would love to get from this, is an open government.

I can't trust the government on the island. We got in the mess because of them. They've been slowly getting us more in debt. They've lied. It wasn't until the island was $70 billion dollars in debt that they came out talking. And now we have the son of the most governor that had the most people investigated by the FBI.

I can't blame him for the actions of his dad. But I can't trust the government.

I can't trust that they will bring in a firm to analyze the debt and be fully transparent. The government is the client of the firm. There will be NDA's in there. They will have a statement somewhere with something like, "with the data/access we've been provided, this is what we understand..."

I can't trust it.

If we can get our hands on the data. If we can analyze it. If we can get experts on it. Publish everything and be transparent about it. We can make a non profit. Ask for contributions (so people are able to claim that) and analyze everything.

- How much do we actually owe? - What should we pay first? - Based on the terms, what has the highest positive/negative impact on the island? - From what we owe, what is actually legally binding? (apparently there are some terms that may not be 100% legal)

This is what I want. For us as citizens to come together and do this. For us to be able to answer our own questions.

But people just keep saying things along the lines of,

> We aren't happy with what you are doing, fix it. > We need this fixed. > We don't want the university or anything to get funding cut off, but fix this. > O'neill bellaco (something else going on on the island in regards to the mayor of a town regarding sexual harassment complains)

The people living in Puerto Rico, the people of Puerto Rico living outside the island, we all need to come together and at least analyze the fucking mess we are in.

Tenemos que resolver nuestros problemas. Pero para poder resolverlos, debemos analizarlos, entenderlos y tener un plan de acción. (We need to fix the issues. In order to do so, we need to analyze it, understand it, and have a plan to execute).

We need the data. Even if they make some law where they pardon everyone involved/implicated in issues because of it, we need the data to understand the mess we are in.

Re:Puerto Rico files for biggest ever U.S. local government ... by anigbrowl on Thursday May 04, 2017 @05:51PM (#14269186)
Thanks for your wonderfully comprehensive reply. I'm very interested in PR and would love to visit sometime but I really only know what I read in the newspaper. It's great to get a first-hand perspective from a lifetime resident.