throw in that even as recently as 2011 President Obama had to sign into law a bill postponing minimum wage laws and increases in America Samoa because it was literally destroying their economy after being force to accept such in 2007 and 2009.
It isn't just competitive labor markets but mobility of those who can fill the jobs that exist. then throw a likelihood of employers to increase work loads to compensate, penalties for tardiness, and such, it does not always turn out to be a boon.
with regards to Puerto Rico, this is simply an example of politicians selling out their populace to retain power and actually being around to be there when the hammer falls. it has happened in a few American cities and there are some states with very excessive and dangerous pension obligations that will be forced to vacate them or seriously reduce them .
Puerto Rico should stand as a warning to anyone who sees politicians promising the moon.
[1] http://www.scholarsstrategynetwork.org/brief/evidence-higher...
[2] http://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2014/07/19/332879409/...
On April 1, 1992 New Jersey's minimum wage increased from $4.25 to $5.05 per hour. To evaluate the impact of the law we surveyed 410 fast food restaurants in New Jersey and Pennsylvania before and after the rise in the minimum. Comparisons of the changes in wages, employment, and prices at stores in New Jersey relative to stores in Pennsylvania (where the minimum wage remained fixed at $4.25 per hour) yield simple estimates of the effect of the higher minimum wage. Our empirical findings challenge the prediction that a rise in the minimum reduces employment. Relative to stores in Pennsylvania, fast food restaurants in New Jersey increased employment by 13 percent. We also compare employment growth at stores in New Jersey that were initially paying high wages (and were unaffected by the new law) to employment changes at lower-wage stores. Stores that were unaffected by the minimum wage had the same employment growth as stores in Pennsylvania, while stores that had to increase their wages increased their employment.
They assessed Full Time Employment (FTE), a statistic which counts full time work as 1 'unit' and part time work as 0.5 'units'. That's really alarming, because we want to assess hours worked, and they used a metric that can't differentiate 30 hours / week from 10 hours / week. It's even worse because cutting hours while hiring more workers is a known way to reduce benefit costs and increase flexibility.
Neumark and Wascher redo the analysis using hours worked, and find a nonsignificant downward trend instead.
I don't think this settles the minimum wage question, but I've never heard a defense of Card and Krueger's result against this charge.
I would not say that with such certainty…
http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0166046216...
Where did you hear that?
The employment effect of the minimum wage is one of the most studied topics in all of economics. This report examines the most recent wave of this research – roughly since 2000 – to determine the best current estimates of the impact of increases in the minimum wage on the employment prospects of low-wage workers. The weight of that evidence points to little or no employment response to modest increases in the minimum wage.
If they can't produce enough value to justify minimum wages, why would they move to places with a higher cost of living? They move to the States because the States are better able to attract businesses that will pay them what they are capable of producing (even though the States still have at least the Federal minimum wage, and offlten higher minimums), because the States face more favorable federal policy because Congress and the President need their votes, whereas they don't need PR's because PR doesn't get any in the Federal government.
Mopping a floor produces economic value because there's a difference in how much a dirty store sells versus a clean one. If all you can do is mop floors for this thought experiment, this difference in how much the store sells directly effects the economic value of your labor. In Puerto Rico, this difference is less than in the mainland US, which is why the value of their labor (and the natural price of it) is lower.
In other words, since the US is more intensely capitalized, there are more opportunities to provide $7.25/hr worth of value.
Consider two countries, A and B. A has limited economic development, low technology, poor infrastructure, low education. B is far more advanced. A and B lie on opposite sides of the globe and have essentially never had trade or direct contact. (This is an accurate scenario before the Age of Exploration, where travel was far more limited than now, and there were already large differences in the relative level of development of various lands.)
Person Pa mops the floors in country A and gets paid $0.25/hr. Person Pb mops the floors in country B and gets paid $5.00/hr. (You may wonder how we can define both of their incomes in dollars if the two countries have no contact; you can define a virtual exchange rate based on respective purchasing power, for instance).
Your interpretation states that there is a transfer of wealth from person Pa to... person Pb? Everyone in country B? Everyone in country A? It's not clear, but any of those conclusions seems unreasonable. There is no causal connection between country A and country B, so there can be no wealth transfer between them. And how can the existence of country B, at the unknown and unreachable recesses of the earth, cause a wealth transfer within country A?
The more reasonable interpretation is the opposite: it is person Pb who is receiving a transfer of extra wealth. From whom? From the past and present inhabitants of country B, who have created the wealth, technology, infrastructure and knowledge that allows Pb to receive more for the same amount of work. This interpretation, unlike yours, is backed by clear causal connections.
I do agree, however, that people often fail to account for this transfer of wealth.
You are correct about the greater transfer of wealth going to Pb, in that if Pb visits country A, s/he will have vastly greater purchasing power and thus economic opportunity (is s/he wants to settle down there) than the reverse situation of Pa going to country B.
Consider the possibility, in these days of globalization and corporate reach, that both are employed by the same firm, such as Walmart of 7-11 (let's forget about franchising and other specific details and consider only the obvious labor cost variations).
So now we have two employees, working for the same entity in different contexts, doing the same amount of work, and enjoying the same amount of purchasing power in their local economies - but very different levels of purchasing power if they wish to visit each other, which asymmetry will inevitably be compounded over time.
My basic point is that it's a matter of luck whether you are born in country A or B, but ceteris paribus there will be a significant and increasing opportunity gap through no fault or merit of the individuals involved. This is in my view a Bad Thing.
I am sorry for not laying this out more clearly, and by using the phrase 'transfer of wealth' I may have obscured my point. I agree that Pb primarily benefits from the whole economy of country B, but invite you to consider the low and inevitably worsening bargaining position of Pa (and by extension, the whole of A) in any kind of international transaction.
Is A a worse country because of some moral deficiency? Absent a specific and obvious cause, that conclusion might be the result of a 'just world fallacy.' Regardless, this is of little comfort to Pa, who can hardly be held morally responsible for the past failings of the society in which s/he originates.
First, this is at least as strong an assumption as the just world hypothesis, and at least as poorly supported. As it happens, invoking the "just world fallacy" is usually a sign that one is about to commit a fallacy that is just as bad. In fact, I would say it is worse, from a series of theoretical and practical considerations.
In my previous comment I have already shown an example of how your hypothesis (I am going to be charitable and not refer to it as a fallacy) leads you to a paradox. But there are many more.
Consider people born at different times of history. Do people who were born in the past suffer an injustice from the people who live in the present? "Well, but I can't do anything about it." Not for the ones who were born two hundred years ago, but what about fifty? You are clearly a young guy. Maybe even more of your income should be taxed and given to the baby boomers, to compensate them for the injustice of having been born in an age without the internet. (This is starting to look like a just world hypothesis applied to the system of defined benefit pensions...)
It gets worse. Demographically, socialism is the ideology of bourgeoise youths who hate their parents. Psychologically, its root is the rejection of one's parents, and of the advantages received from them. Therefore, guilt for "unearned privilege". But while it is true that the child did not earn the privilege, it is not true that it was not earned. It was not earned by the child, but it was earned for him, by his parents. (It is not a coincidence that adults, and especially married people, are more likely to be conservative.)
So try putting yourself in the shoes of the people whose work produced that wealth, which their children now inherit. Do they not get a say in who gets it? (Remember that they are already suffering from the injustice of being born in the past, so by denying them a say we are adding injustice to injustice.)
And of course, it does not stop at material wealth. There are all sorts of advantages (or disadvantages) one inherits from one's parents, in terms of education, social network, genetics, and so on. The family is the fundamental unit for the generation and transmission of inequality. Which is why the early socialists, who were intellectually honest, made it their explicit program to abolish the family.
Of course, there are many social problems with destroying the family. But there are also economic problems! Being able to transmit wealth to one's progeny is an extremely strong incentive for economic activity and growth beyond pure self-sustenance. In fact, property and inheritance are universal to all developed human civilizations: all of those proto-communist tribes anthropologists found never got much further than the stone age. The most likely conclusion is that they cannot: property and inheritance (in other words, inequality) appear to be an essential social technology that is required for development. The best a communist can hope for is that they may become unnecessary at some later stage of technological super-abundance, when we can all go off and play cowboys in space.
But we ended up focusing on economic factors again. Your idea of equality has much broader implications, though. If you say that the luck of one's birth is injustice, you cannot limit that to wealth. Differences in intelligence are unjust. Differences in attractiveness are unjust. We could go on and develop all the implications, but I'm going to stop here.
The employment effect of the minimum wage is one of the most studied topics in all of economics. This report examines the most recent wave of this research – roughly since 2000 – to determine the best current estimates of the impact of increases in the minimum wage on the employment prospects of low-wage workers. The weight of that evidence points to little or no employment response to modest increases in the minimum wage.
"Modest" here seems like an unproven assumption. The gap between the Puerto Rican economy and US state economies is much larger than the gap between, say, Pennsylvania and New Jersey.
As far as I know there's no real disagreement on the direction of the labor demand curve. If you put the minimum wage at $40/hour (or $10/hour in China) it would have massive consequences.
So even granting the 'little or no' result, we haven't proved the "modest increase" charge for Puerto Rico.
There are alternative views on this. Marx's theory for example says that workers are not paid according to the value they create, or what their labour creates, rather they are paid at the rate which is required to sustain them. The commodity which the worker produces and sells is termed 'labour power', requiring among other things food, enough to support a family if he has one and some amount in accordance with the moral character of society, varying with supply and demand accordingly. This is the minimum that needs paying.
So Marx would say that wage has nothing to do with value created. It only has to do with the value of labour power, which is equal to the value needed for the worker to sustain himself.
This is cartoonish. I can't believe people say stuff like this in the 21st century.
This is not a refutation. Just like the raw materials used for production, the means of production, land rent etc. what is purchased is a commodity. Labour-time is that commodity. It makes good business sense to not only buy commodities at their value (and no more) but even to try and buy commodities under their value.
Why do you think labour-power is any different? It must be paid in accordance with its value, and how much extra is minimally required to ensure the continuance of the production of this commodity.
>The owner of labour-power is mortal. If then his appearance in the market is to be continuous, and the continuous conversion of money into capital assumes this, the seller of labour-power must perpetuate himself, "in the way that every living individual perpetuates himself, by procreation." The labour-power withdrawn from the market by wear and tear and death, must be continually replaced by, at the very least, an equal amount of fresh labour-power. Hence the sum of the means of subsistence necessary for the production of labour-power must include the means necessary for the labourer's substitutes, i.e., his children, in order that this race of peculiar commodity-owners may perpetuate its appearance in the market.
>Included in the value of labour power is both a physical component (the minimum physical requirements for a healthy worker) and a moral-historical component (the satisfaction of needs beyond the physical minimum which have become an established part of the lifestyle of the average worker). The value of labour power is thus a historical norm, which is the outcome of a combination of factors: productivity; the supply and demand for labour; the assertion of human needs; the costs of acquiring skills; state laws stipulating minimum or maximum wages, the balance of power between social classes, etc.
If the capitalist paid for labour-power at more than its value consistently, in the long run the capitalist will tend to make no profit at all. Profit originates in surplus value being extracted, and although there is leeway (there is a rate of surplus value, for example 0.6, though it could be 0.3 and the capitalist would still make a profit) any sensible capitalist will aim for the largest extraction possible.
You don't feed a baby steak. That doesn't mean steak is bad, it means it's not what a baby needs or can use until its older.
A Marxist society (or, Communist) does not have wage labour at all.
Puerto Ricans definitely live in a mixed economy, not the system that Marx described as capitalism, but it arguably shares the salient features of capitalism that Marx was addressing in the excerpt under discussion.
In my opinion this is enough to say that a particular society is 'capitalist', though like all words there are variety of nuances and exceptions and additions that can be attached. Capitalism in my view neither necessitates nor excludes government controls on production, social democratic policies, taxes, the state (except for defense of private property) etc.
A good example of a capitalist (state capitalist) country is the Soviet Union.
Since in the post you were responding to, I was challenging the premise you quoted, I think that I am quite aware that there are alternative views to it.
This is one of the effects of Puerto Rico being subject to US minimum wages. Since it's illegal for large portions of the population to receive pay commensurate to the value they're able to produce, and it is legal to move to the US, guess what folks do?