News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Prepack helps make JavaScript code more efficient by andreyf on Wednesday May 03, 2017 @04:21PM (#14259673)
False: an implicit patent grant means that by open sourcing a piece of software you imply that people can, you know, use it.
Re:Prepack helps make JavaScript code more efficient by Lazare on Wednesday May 03, 2017 @07:22PM (#14261137)
Some people think so. Others aren't so sure. US courts have not yet ruled on it.

However, even the people who DO think an implicit grant exists would mostly agree that the implicit grant is not sublicensable, which makes it a horrible mess and probably unusable.

An explicit grant is strongly preferable, IF people can agree on the terms. Facebook's terms are on the harsh side, but there's clear advantages to it existing.

Re:Prepack helps make JavaScript code more efficient by abritinthebay on Wednesday May 03, 2017 @07:55PM (#14261322)
> US courts have not yet ruled on it.

They sort of have. A patent has to be a major and "dominant" part of the implicitly licensed tech for it to be granted.

Basically - all existing case law says that you get some rights from implicit grants but it's also far less than explicit ones like FB's

Re:Prepack helps make JavaScript code more efficient by andreyf on Saturday May 06, 2017 @02:26AM (#14279020)
Not only does not all of the case law say this, that's not even what that case was about nor what that language said: http://en.swpat.org/wiki/Implicit_patent_licence#USA
Re:Prepack helps make JavaScript code more efficient by Lazare on Thursday May 04, 2017 @07:06AM (#14263951)
Thanks for the info.
Re:Prepack helps make JavaScript code more efficient by andreyf on Saturday May 06, 2017 @02:28AM (#14279031)
Careful. I don't know what his motivations are, but the info is misrepresenting both the context and the meaning of the language he references: http://en.swpat.org/wiki/Implicit_patent_licence#USA
Re:Prepack helps make JavaScript code more efficient by andreyf on Saturday May 06, 2017 @02:30AM (#14279035)
If you license something under BSD and continue to license under the BSD, the question of sub-licensing seems moot.
Re:Prepack helps make JavaScript code more efficient by abritinthebay on Wednesday May 03, 2017 @04:29PM (#14259745)
And the weakness, legally speaking, of implicit patent grants was one major reason why GPL moved from v2 to v3.

Explicit is much much safer for users of software, legally speaking, because implicit grants have to be settled in court.

If you really want to go to court over it, and can afford it, then you may be right. Want to test that against Facebook? They reasoned (quite rightly) that it would be silly to suggest that.

Re:Prepack helps make JavaScript code more efficient by andreyf on Wednesday May 03, 2017 @05:15PM (#14260173)
What would their case be? "Yes, we gave away the software and documented it and paid designers to design it all pretty and spent marketing effort promoting it but nobody is allowed to use it because it's patented technology"?

Has any court ever ruled that a permissive license like BSD does not include a patent grant when it says "use in source and binary forms, with or without modification, are permitted"? Because that seems flat-out silly.

Re:Prepack helps make JavaScript code more efficient by derefr on Wednesday May 03, 2017 @08:24PM (#14261459)
Patents doesn't mean "nobody is allowed to use it"; patents mean "you are required to license the patent from the patent-holder, which usually requires paying royalties."

I could totally see the point of a FOSS software project that implements a patented algorithm, where people work together to improve the thing but everyone who uses it still has to get a license from the patent-holder. (For a recently-top-of-mind example, Fraunhofer's MP3 decoding patent.)

Thus, it's not obvious that a FOSS license automatically implies patent release. Fraunhofer could have open-sourced some reference MP3 encoder themselves, without releasing the MP3 patents.

Re:Prepack helps make JavaScript code more efficient by djur on Thursday May 04, 2017 @03:05AM (#14263080)
I think the situation you mention has a significant distinction: Fraunhofer (or whoever) would presumably advertise that they expect you to get a patent license to use the code in a product. Either they'd explicitly state that up front, or their lawyers would say it with the first politely worded letter to someone who starts using the "open source" code.

Software distributed under those terms would no longer adhere to OSI's definition of open source (I think it violates points 1, 3, and 6) nor the FSF's Free Software Definition (points 2 and 3).

It might not stand up in court, but I do think it's obviously unethical to release patent-encumbered "FOSS" without mentioning your patents and then demand users obtain a license after the fact.

Re:Prepack helps make JavaScript code more efficient by andreyf on Thursday May 04, 2017 @03:22PM (#14267859)
> It might not stand up in court, but I do think it's obviously unethical to release patent-encumbered "FOSS" without mentioning your patents and then demand users obtain a license after the fact.

I would be amazed if something like this does not stand up in court. Read the BSD license — it's really relatively simple english.

Re:Prepack helps make JavaScript code more efficient by abritinthebay on Wednesday May 03, 2017 @07:53PM (#14261308)
You're asking the wrong question.

There is almost no case law that supports implicit patent grants and what little there is requires the patents be ones...

"that dominate the product or any uses of the product to which the parties might reasonably contemplate the product will be put" -- HP vs O-Type Stencil (1997)

So, again, very limited. Very dangerous. Very very open to being sued and crushed economically.

This is exactly why FB's patent grant provides you more rights that you get without it. There is no ambiguity, no fussing over what patents may or may not apply and be covered by the case law. It's explicit and better for you.

Long story short: in many ways it's less safe to rely on implicit grants.

Re:Prepack helps make JavaScript code more efficient by kbutler on Thursday May 04, 2017 @09:58AM (#14264849)
But isn't it the case that any patents that would affect the use of react/prepack would "dominate the product or any uses of the product..."?

Yes, the grant is better than nothing, but also, the risk if the grant is removed seems minimal.

Re:Prepack helps make JavaScript code more efficient by abritinthebay on Thursday May 04, 2017 @10:35AM (#14265105)
Any patents? Not at all.

It's of course possible that they have (or will have) some that would be covered by an implicit grant - though you'd need to go to court to confirm that.

But it's quite possible that they could have many patents that cover non-substancial parts. Guess what? You're now in violation of those if you haven't already licensed them.

So, again, even in the best case the implicit grant still requires you to go to court to maybe get clear of some liability.

Explicit ones have you covered from the start. More rights for you, broader coverage for you.

Re:Prepack helps make JavaScript code more efficient by kbutler on Thursday May 04, 2017 @06:08PM (#14269298)
It seems very unlikely to find a way to use these products in an unintended way that would violate some tangentially related patent, but a) it's all hypothetical and b) one should never underestimate the ability and willingness of IP lawyers to allege an infringement.

"You have stored the software on electronic media and used that media as a doorstop, violating our access control patents by keeping the door open."

Hmm. Has that been filed yet?

Re:Prepack helps make JavaScript code more efficient by slavik81 on Wednesday May 03, 2017 @05:29PM (#14260312)
I can read and understand the MIT or BSD licenses. That is an extremely valuable property of a contract to me. Both clearly state that I may modify and distribute the software.

Adding a huge pile of details about what exactly that means makes me rather nervous. I am not a lawyer, and I worry that somewhere in that huge pile of explicitness that there are consequences that I don't anticipate, and that don't match up with the broad simple language those explicit details replaced.

Re:Prepack helps make JavaScript code more efficient by eropple on Wednesday May 03, 2017 @06:10PM (#14260676)
That "pile of explicitness" replaces a pile of implicitness wrapped up in case law and statutes that are relevant to any case that arises but you don't know about. Because what you read in a license is not what matters--how do you know you understand them as they will be interpreted by a court of law? What do you not know that you do not know?

(This is why companies have legal teams.)

Re:Prepack helps make JavaScript code more efficient by andreyf on Wednesday May 03, 2017 @07:41PM (#14261237)
This sounds like FUD. When has a simple license like BSD been interpreted to not grant rights to the patents implemented in the technology being licensed? The language there is really clear.
Re:Prepack helps make JavaScript code more efficient by eropple on Wednesday May 03, 2017 @10:37PM (#14261999)
I don't know. Turn it around: when has it been interpreted to grant rights to patents implemented? Is there case law that establishes estoppel for such a thing? Has it been tested? Are your lawyers good enough?

These are questions that you should be asking because the name of the game is minimizing risk.

Re:Prepack helps make JavaScript code more efficient by andreyf on Thursday May 04, 2017 @03:28PM (#14267910)
Still FUD. When someone distributes something under BSD and spends non-negligible resources promoting that software, they lose the ability to sue people for using it, because the language of the license says "you may use this". The risk is 0 and I would be surprised if this has even been argued in court because it's so trivially clear.
Re:Prepack helps make JavaScript code more efficient by eropple on Thursday May 04, 2017 @04:02PM (#14268230)
Don't be "surprised if", don't make blurfy engineer claims--cite your sources or withdraw your claims of safety that do nothing but encourage other people to undertake risk on behalf of your ideology.

The sooner the software developers of the world realize that there are reasons that we hire lawyers for legal tasks just like we hire programmers for programming tasks, the better. The profound arrogance you are choosing to exhibit regarding complex professions you don't fully understand is one of the absolute worst things in tech.

Re:Prepack helps make JavaScript code more efficient by slavik81 on Wednesday May 03, 2017 @06:39PM (#14260861)
If I can't trust the justice system to interpret a simple contract plainly, then I don't have a chance of actually understanding the legal implications of a more complex contract.
Re:Prepack helps make JavaScript code more efficient by derefr on Wednesday May 03, 2017 @08:27PM (#14261470)
I don't understand this perspective.

The justice system is like a computer. It has no common sense; it has no "Do What I Mean" button. You have to write things out in full explicitness, for it to do anything predictable/sensible at all.

And just like with explicitness in programming, explicitness in a contract doesn't translate to "more things that could go wrong"; it's instead fewer degrees of freedom. More things pinned down; fewer left to interpretation.

Re:Prepack helps make JavaScript code more efficient by slavik81 on Wednesday May 03, 2017 @09:30PM (#14261739)
I expect that unexpected results may come from unexpected scenarios, but not in relation to basic questions that appear to already be addressed in the contract, like "can I use this software?" If I can't trust that a statement means what it says, no amount of elaboration can clarify the contract.
Re:Prepack helps make JavaScript code more efficient by eropple on Wednesday May 03, 2017 @11:30PM (#14262227)
I get what you're saying, but calling it "like a computer" is a little misleading and feeds that weird habit amongst technical people of assuming that The Letter Of The Law is all that matters, when really it's the boatload of precedent, moral justification, and historical context that informs that law.

It ain't hard fact until a judge says it is, and even then it can be moved with a big enough lever. That that specificity reduces axes of freedom on which to have what you think is obvious be not obvious is why I upvoted you, because that's the super important part everybody ignores.

Re:Prepack helps make JavaScript code more efficient by derefr on Wednesday May 03, 2017 @11:49PM (#14262313)
Right, you can't actually "rules lawyer" in real law; there is a spirit of the law that informs connotation of the text where edge-cases are concerned.

A good lawyer tries to phrase their contracts et al to expose the connotation of the relevant laws in the text, so that you don't need to read the laws, only the text. Sort of like explicitly including default parameter assignments to a function.

Re:Prepack helps make JavaScript code more efficient by eropple on Thursday May 04, 2017 @12:40AM (#14262504)
Yeah, totally--I knew you knew, just didn't want the implication to leave room to well-actually.
Re:Prepack helps make JavaScript code more efficient by jaredklewis on Thursday May 04, 2017 @02:10AM (#14262836)
You seem convinced that your interpretation of a "simple" contract is the only obvious one and that any other interpretation is unecessarily convoluted. But I don't think that is the case at all. Simplicity almost always comes at the expense of clarity, which is why simple documents like the MIT license or the US constitution produce so many conflicting interpretations. Not because there are bad actors; just because it is unclear.

If you ask a lawyer what is best, they will likely recommend a professionally drafted license like the Apache License v2. Just as you may not understand every aspect of a doctor's diagnosis or prescription, it may not be feasible to understand all the relevant statutes and case law. But I think it makes more sense to defer to expertise advice than to bury one's head in the sand.

Re:Prepack helps make JavaScript code more efficient by pluma on Thursday May 04, 2017 @05:26AM (#14263620)
You're assuming that because a contract is simple you're more likely to understand it correctly. That is horribly misguided.

In all likelihood you don't fully understand contracts regardless of length because you're unaware of the entire legal environment they exist in. The reason contracts often have weird stilted phrases is that they have specific meanings established over decades if not centuries of legal battles over those semantics.

A good example for doing this right are the Creative Commons licenses: they come with a summary in plain English for humans and a full license text for the legal system.

Re:Prepack helps make JavaScript code more efficient by eridius on Wednesday May 03, 2017 @04:26PM (#14259722)
AIUI this issue still hasn't been settled to everybody's satisfaction.