this could lead to serious limitations on legitimate future progress including on anything built using statistical methods that require large training data sets.
If protecting personal information limits or slows some progress, so be it. Also it could still be done, just more carefully.
[1] https://research.googleblog.com/2017/04/federated-learning-c...
Some level of public education is also required I think, to make people aware of the value/threat of just giving everything up every time someone asks for it.
If companies were trustworthy with data, than that wouldn't be an issue. Why should they get a free lunch on my dime?
Most machine learning is done against anonymous dataset and works fine.
And really the same is true for any company that has any sizeable PR problem, regardless of the cause. Examples:
- Yahoo
- Uber
- United Airlines
- Target
Personally, I believe that if it's negligence, there should be compensation - they lost something that belongs to you and is of value. But few people seem to really care. The info of 1 billion yahoo accounts was hacked, but who cares? Until that changes, the problem will continue to exist.