On the other hand, every other way of losing public land also ties the hands of subsequent governments to do with it as they please. Suppose that you sell it for a song to your friends, or allow resource extraction in an environmentally sensitive area... A decade down the road, you can't wave a magic wand, and undo that damage.
The fact of the matter is that once public lands are lost, they are gone - forever. Every election year, we must fight to keep public lands public - we only need to lose once, and then its over. Can you really blame someone for seeking a more permanent solution to this problem?
The BLM has not traditionally been enemies of the people using the land. The antagonism is a very new phenomenon.
>The monument designations maintain currently authorized uses of the land that do not harm the resources protected by the monument, including tribal access and traditional collection of plants and firewood, off-highway vehicle recreation, hunting and fishing and authorized grazing.
It's apparently also an important deal for tribal sovereignty[2]:
> Under the Bears Ears Monument designation, an intertribal coalition will partner with the U.S. Forest Service and the Bureau of Land Management to manage the area — which is slightly bigger than the state of Delaware — ensuring that tribes have access to food supplies and firewood.
This[3] says that existing grazing is usually grandfathered in, but that new grazing is limited. I get the impression that there's a lot of disinformation out there.
[1] https://www.doi.gov/pressreleases/secretaries-jewell-vilsack... [2] http://www.npr.org/sections/thesalt/2017/01/09/508586040/bea... [3] http://www.npr.org/2017/02/05/513492389/utah-representative-...
Creating a national park requires an act of congres, creating a national monument only takes an executive order[1]. I can imagine states are much more worried about executive orders as opposed to acts of congress.
[1] https://vault.sierraclub.org/planet/199611/nationalpark.asp
They have gotten a lot of guns pointed at them by people who are upset that they can't ride ATVs in an area with lots of sensitive Anasazi artifacts, though.
The BLM gets along just fine with many ranchers. There are a few bad apples out there that think that because they were the only ones using the public land for a while that they should keep it. Ranchers in general get a pretty sweet deal from the feds. Be skeptical of claims that they are getting screwed. The prices they have paid are extremely low.
See, this is the problem mindset, and the reason people are protesting. The mindset should not be "oh, it's all owned by the federal government, and everything they choose to give you you should be grateful for"
The land is literally supposed to be held in trust for the public, and free to use. The BLM prevents abuse, but it's not supposed to be making a profit from the public. For the vast majority of the country's history, fees to use public lands were token, because it was land owned _collectively by the people_
Now that a small minority of the country actually uses the land, because people have moved to the cities, nobody notices that this contract is being slowly changed, to the detriment of people who have relied on this public access for a long time.
The BLM doesn't make a profit. Actually they (rather, the Dept. of the Interior) don't charge enough for things like mineral extraction. Think of it this way. You and I and everyone else owns those minerals. The US should make sure that we as taxpayers are getting our fair share of their value. It is the same thought process behind the FCC and spectrum auctions. When there is a public good involved, the government needs to make sure it is being put to the best use for all of the citizens. Not just the first people in the door or the well connected.
>Now that a small minority of the country actually uses the land, because people have moved to the cities, nobody notices that this contract is being slowly changed, to the detriment of people who have relied on this public access for a long time.
This is an erroneous statement. Where did you read this?
More people are using BLM land, especially in the Bears Ears area than ever before. This is because of population growth and increased awareness of BLM land. In the past, it was just ranchers and hunters using the land. Now people go hiking, ride ATVs, ride horses (for fun, not work like in the past), etc.
For renewable resources, all that needs to be done is preventing a 'tragedy of the commons' and keeping the land open to most people.
However, for non-renewable resources, whomever gets it is effectively taking it from the public. It is then important that the public is compensated for this loss.
I'm not sure where it says it has to be free to use. In fact, the Supreme Court has stated numerous times that the authority of the Federal government over public lands is "without limitations."
https://www.blm.gov/press-release/blm-and-forest-service-ann...
I have seen significant preservation efforts regarding a name scratched on a hillside near the Grand Canyon. The author was still living down the street from me, but the scratching was 50 years old.
The abandoned houses across town are blight, but the one in Yosemite is a national treasure. My child's mud hut is a safety hazard, but the one up the cliff is a sacred Anasazi artifact.
On the other hand, I have seen a small local wilderness area turn from a fun spot for a family Easter egg hunt to a regional ATV attraction so crowded the local Boy Scouts could no longer camp there.
Balancing the past, present, and future is always a subjective thing. When the BLM actually does its job, it does land management. But that is a hard job. It is often easier to just close everything down and not let anyone in. That is not management. But when pressure on a wilderness grows from a couple hundred visitors a year to a couple hundred visitors a day, a policy of "anything goes" is also not management. Management can be expensive.
The people in the best position to observe and propose solutions are always local. But BLM struggles to build local partnerships. They try to manage through a multi-layered bureaucracy that ultimately makes decisions from Washington, D.C. The result can often look like the United Airlines video--constructing and enforcing a policy in a manner that doesn't fit the local situation. There are any number of ideas that could get the job done cheaper and with more sensibility.
That boardwalk is called the "Petroglyphs Trail", and it's there for ancient Native American art. Fixing the names of some people that carved their names near it would cause harm to the petroglyphs, so they opted to leave them instead of repair them. I feel like you're being intentionally misleading in completely omitting the fact that the boardwalk is there specifically for Anasazi Petroglpyhs.
> The abandoned houses across town are blight, but the one in Yosemite is a national treasure.
Care to share which house this is? Only information I could find was on the Bodie Ghost town, which is a historic mining town. Again, there's obvious cultural significance to an old gold rush town that is not present in some abandoned craftsmen in the inner city.
> My child's mud hut is a safety hazard, but the one up the cliff is a sacred Anasazi artifact
Really? Do you really not see the difference?
> On the other hand, I have seen a small local wilderness area turn from a fun spot for a family Easter egg hunt to a regional ATV attraction so crowded the local Boy Scouts could no longer camp there.
Which is exactly what a National Monument designation protects.
> Balancing the past, present, and future is always a subjective thing. When the BLM actually does its job, it does land management. But that is a hard job. It is often easier to just close everything down and not let anyone in. That is not management. But when pressure on a wilderness grows from a couple hundred visitors a year to a couple hundred visitors a day, a policy of "anything goes" is also not management. Management can be expensive.
This is literally the opposite of what National Monument land does. They're not "closed down." They're actually far more accessible for generations, just not by way of vehicles that cause massive destruction.
> The people in the best position to observe and propose solutions are always local. But BLM struggles to build local partnerships. They try to manage through a multi-layered bureaucracy that ultimately makes decisions from Washington, D.C. The result can often look like the United Airlines video--constructing and enforcing a policy in a manner that doesn't fit the local situation. There are any number of ideas that could get the job done cheaper and with more sensibility.
Can you cite some sources for that? Let's look at Utah, which is at the center of the National Monument controversy. Yuba Lake, a state park, is an absolute disaster of motorhomes, ATVs, and speedboats. Capitol Reef, Canyonlands, Arches and Zion, all federal land, have all maintained a large percentage of their natural beauty and cultural significance. What exactly would the state do better with those lands?
Edit: I also want to bring up Goblin Valley, one of the more popular state parks in Utah. It's $13 for day-use access to 3500 acres. Grand Staircase, on the other hand, is 1.8 MILLION acres, free day use, and arguably far more fragile and spectacular.
Also, the propaganda that calls this a "land grab" is misleading. The land was already owned by the federal government. They aren't taking anything. Yes, they are placing restrictions on use (which will negatively impact me, btw), but the popularity of the area has exploded just in the last few years. I don't think the current "free for all" (which is fun) approach can continue forever.
The only thing that concerns me about national monument status is that they might try to make it into a Disney Land experience like the other national parks. It would be ruined in my mind if they created giant paved RV campgrounds with flush-toilet bathrooms.
Find a copy of the book "Desert Solitaire" for a better written summary of the issues out there. My views track pretty closely with the author's.
The states actually have a far worse record on providing public access and use for land owned by them. While the federal government is bound by law to allow, for example, hunting or hiking, states tend to seek avenues for monetising their land, often charging for access or leasing to mining/drilling/farming operations which in turn prohibit public access.
Those national monument designations were also, in turn, just a reaction to the "drill, baby, drill" chorus echoing through the last few Republican campaigns.
The actual economic impact of exploring the remaining natural resources is uncertain at best, considering the low market prices and the practical reasons why these deposits have remained untouched so far. That creates the impression that this is an emotional subject, meaning that parts of the political spectrum would gladly drill a well and pump oil right into the next Alaskan creek as long as it sufficiently enrages liberals.
There's emotion on the other side as well, without a doubt. But those lucky bastards somehow get to trigger their opponents by protecting the Orange Oregonian Owl.
Whatever you do, the land has to be managed. "Managed" can mean a dozen things to a dozen people. Some folks want it completely untouched. Some folks want to manage it as perhaps a farmer or rancher would. Some folks want a place to ride ATVs and raise hell.
Political systems exist for political reasons. That is the only reason they exist. Lately, any political system in the States is going to gravitate towards one group throwing mud at another group.
So, to address your first sentence, I do not believe there is any way for this not to be political. Perhaps the key question instead is this: at what level of politics should these decisions take place? Should everything happen at the national level? If so, why? Personally, I'd prefer a limit of thirds between national, state, and local governments. That way any one political group doesn't start monopolizing all the power. It shouldn't be possible for us to have a single election at any level of government and decide how to treat huge sections of public land. For that reason alone, I'm against the current trend of federalizing everything.
It's not because I want the land to be commercialized. In fact, I want just the opposite. But those are my tastes. I understand others have their own views. Let's stay as far away as possible from more winner-take-all political structures.
Some of the giveaways from state legislatures boggle the mind.
I live in a small desert community that was largely agricultural in my youth. Today, most of the water rights have been sold away and most of the farm land has been developed for other uses.
I think it is unfortunate. Sometimes I think the remaining farm land should be protected from development. But I do not own the land, and I did not do all the work to turn it into farm land. I believe the owners of the property have the right to do as they decide for themselves.
So, if I really want the land to be preserved, I can try to raise millions of dollars and buy the land from the farmers. But I can't otherwise just block them from selling it to a developer.
If you think state officials mismanage public lands and would prefer the feds to mismanage it, the feds should buy it from the state. This should not be a forced sale, either.
If a state has willingly sold its land to the feds... well, I guess they can't complain. Can you tell me how the federal government came to own 80+% of Nevada? Ask the Sheahans [1] and the Bundys [2].
Edit: Corrected typo
[1] http://origin-stage.reviewjournal.com/news/military/family-f...
[2] http://www.bizpacreview.com/2014/04/16/why-does-federal-gove...
Private land is private land. If farmers want to sell it to condo developers they (albeit sadly) can.
My problem is that state government is largely unprofessional. Say what you want about the revolving door in DC between public and private, but state governments make that look downright respectable: generally instead there's kickback + sneaking an agreement in at the last moment + underfunded local news not noticing = public gets screwed and someone gets a cushy private sector job next year.
[1] http://www.myajc.com/news/opinion/opinion-lease-deal-leaves-...
How much can you actually say that. Were there polls done? Was it done by referendum?
"The Government is taking our public land to make it public forever but limited use! I know let's sell our public land so it's never public again! That will..... fix it?"
Turning federal land into national monuments greatly limits the traditional uses of these publicly held lands -- restrictions on livestock grazing, hunting, camping, etc.
Obviously there needs to be responsible land stewardship, but abusing the antiquities act to carve out enormous not-parks-but-not-free chunks of land isn't the best way to get everyone working together there.