In both freedom of speech and privacy, you have to be willing to support the rights of those people consider 'horrible' in order to help the greater population as a whole.
Letting people say whatever they want on the Internet does result in bullies, trolls, extremists and other horrible people talking louder than more thoughtful speech, and in the end it silences reasonable people.
There is no law that forces me as an individual to respect what you say or to not try to silence you.
Censorship can only be done by the government, not by individuals; no one should trust the unfair bully who cries unfairness at being silenced.
***
It's the silencing of obnoxious voices
that allows thoughtful voices to be heard.
***Merely because they don't (directly) have the power of law behind them, doesn't make them less dangerous than a government.
See how that works? "Horrible," "thoughtful," "reasonable"--as defined by you. Might-makes-right and the-ends-justify-the-means. Astounding hubris and a stubborn refusal to learn from history. And an apparent inability to reason from abstract principles.
This is why national borders (and federalism within national borders) are good: compartmentalization prevents damage from spreading. Without bulkheads, flooding easily sinks the whole ship.
It is ok if someone that doesn't understand it says those sorts of things, but when an organization like cloudflare[1] jumps on the goof-troop bandwagon, it really does make a difference.
They specifically built controls so that web sites can remove CAPTCHAs for Tor users completely.[0]
They also do not block/CAPTCHA Tor users automatically. They treat Tor IPs like any IPs: if they detect abuse from the IP, they start giving the CAPTCHA.
Finally, Cloudflare has stated publicly[1] that they have a desire to setup .onion sites for their customers automatically. But they cannot do so until the Tor project is able to upgrade the hashing algorithm used for .onion addresses. If the two organizations could work together, this could be game-changing for online anonymity. Imagine millions of web sites automatically supporting Tor!
I can't understand why the HN crowd is so anti-Cloudflare. This Tor thing seems to be one of the major misconceptions.
Disclaimer: I'm not affiliated with with either Tor or Cloudflare in any way.
[0] https://support.cloudflare.com/hc/en-us/articles/203306930-D...
In addition, their response to the memory leak issue a few months back left a bad taste in a lot of people's mouths. They attacked Google unfairly for not purging their leaked content fast enough, while trying to downplay the severity of the mistake they made.
I do not believe cloudflare on your first link (that they treat tor ips like any ips).
I can tell you from experience that I have never connected to a cloudflare backed site with tor that didn't require multiple captchas. So every tor ip is hostile to cloudflare sites? If so, how is that practically different than just blocking tor?
I think that if you read the response at your first link again, you can see that they are implying what you are saying, but that are not saying what you are saying. I think they are blocking tor, but explaining it in a diplomatic way.
> My link was a direct response to your second link.
Yes, and they only take issue with the the claim that 94% of Tor requests to Cloudflare are malicious. It's a shame that Cloudflare hasn't responded with the data they requested, and it's fair to hold that against them. But I'm also not aware of a response from Tor regarding Cloudflare's desire to make automatic SSL certificate generation possible for .onion addresses.
As a huge fan of both organizations, I wish they would act like adults and work together, rather than spend so much time pointing fingers.
> If so, how is that practically different than just blocking tor?
Because Cloudflare allows their web sites to disable CAPTCHAs for Tor if they choose to.
> I think they are blocking tor, but explaining it in a diplomatic way.
We'll have to disagree on that. The Cloudflare post outlines not one, but two ways that the two organizations could work together to solve the problem.
But again, I agree it would be great if Cloudflare would release more detailed data about the attacks they see from Tor.
OP blog post claims 96% of the traffic going to their tor hidden service is hostile. It doesn't seem unreasonable to me at all that every tor ip is hostile.
so you manually looked up the provider of every site you visited?
sounds like 100% of cloudflare sites that are configured to require captchas require captchas.
Mitigating abuse while supporting the TOR ecosystem is an open problem and they have certainly done more than any other CDN afaik to explore ways to allow legitimate TOR users past their firewall. Unfortunately, if I remember correctly the solution involves tracking IDs which can deanonymize users.
I had an idea a while back of a distributed, anonymous reputation system with rotating tokens. I still believe this is a better solution than the permanent tracking IDs currently used and maintained by other companies. It would return control to the user.
Cloudfare /did/ invest a lot of time communicating and trying to remedy the situations with the DDoS. The is evident in the amount of communication that can be found in the bugtracker.
The prescient Upton Sinclair: “It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends on his not understanding it.”
I mean, yeah, it's not the early 1990s anymore, where mostly academics and enthusiasts were on the internet. But is the hacker manifesto a standard to hold infosec practitioners who likely were in diapers during the halcyon days you refer to?
Look, I agree that anonymity is important. I agree that the world is better if some things are kept absolutely private, from everyone, to whatever extent is possible. But let's not pretend that there aren't trade-offs.
I wish these values were more popular.
You could partially refute this argument by claiming that gun control is hard to ignore or bypass (although not that hard, speaking as someone who knows a fair amount about fabrication and guns).
On the other hand, this argument ported over to Tor doesn't make any sense; if Tor intentionally cripples its functionality, criminals will move over to non-crippled solutions like I2P. The best you can hope for is to mildly and temporarily inconvenience criminals while really hurting innocent people who need Tor.
> The things that makes TOR useful for people avoiding prosecution also makes it useful for people avoiding prosecution.
> Although the Tor Project could promote options to restrict these malicious actions, they choose to do nothing. Seriously: if a TOR hidden service offers hard-core drugs or human trafficking or fake IDs, then they should be shut down.
I hope I can convince some folks here to be skeptical of this kind of thinking.
Think about it: If the Tor project came up with some clever way to take down bad hidden services, then what would be stopping a government from forcing them to take down legitimate hidden services too? And meanwhile, the criminals would move on to some other Tor-like service, and keep doing their thing.
In short, you're not going to stop criminals, who will always find a way to keep doing what they're doing. You will, on the other hand, impede the free speech of honest users.
The Tor project should focus on making it impossible for hidden services to be taken down--even by the Tor project itself! And they do :)