To be fair, a lot of that six months was probably just nailing down the requirements. Your rewrite enjoyed having that design work already done.
I'd argue that building applications is 90% design, 10% code. The code part can balloon to a greater fraction if the developers are not competent enough of course.
Given how many clients that company had, the main conclusion I draw is that as an industry focusing on helping the .1x people improve is more likely to make a noticeable difference than chasing the other end of the spectrum.
The lack of true apprenticeship, fellowship, mentorship is an incredible disservice to our industry. The number of people who all need to rediscover the same lessons the hard way wastes so much programmer capital.
Do you think that's possible? More often than not the .1x people don't seem to care either.
The downward range goes very, very deep. And that's of people that actually do end up shipping something that "works", somehow.
I've personally rewritten an app in less than a week that had two devs on it for over 6 months. Their deliverable didn't really work at all, even after the 1+ minute loading time (Win32 app).