News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Steve Singh will become Docker’s new CEO by tyingq on Tuesday May 02, 2017 @09:50AM (#14246269)
My kneejerk reaction is that a senior leader from Concur, then SAP, is going to buzzword bingo and "enterprisify" docker into something very different. That's probably not fair though. Concur is a pretty big success story, sold for $8B, and it appears some good decisions drove that.
Re:Steve Singh will become Docker’s new CEO by ralfn on Tuesday May 02, 2017 @02:01PM (#14248835)
>"enterprisify" docker into something very different. That's probably not fair though.

But that's actually the industry containers are good for. Enterprise. Predictability trumps costs. The flaws of docker may over time get fixed. It's the small companies and startups that are making a fool of themselves by pretending they extract any kind of value out of docker.

Imagine a large 100+ man software project that spans two years and involves four different organisations collaborating. There are at least 100+ non-technical 'knowledge workers' interacting with this process. The people have the intent of 'not being responsible for anything', but establishing their position/role so their cost/budget is validated. You know, the typical large-scale Oracle/Cap-Gemini/IBM clusterfuck of incompetence.

But that's the secret! They aren't incompetent at all (as organisations). They sell something no-one else sells. They sell predictability.

Because for all what it's worth: they don't make huge architectural fuck ups. They make their deadline. And they are able to deliver something, even with this many stakeholders pissing all over the project from any direction.

For them, docker is brilliant. It standardizes something. It doesn't do it very well, but that doesn't matter. They aren't in a low-margin world. "Docker isn't really secure, you really should run every docker image in a separate VM". Sure. These sort of people are paying 500-1000 per instance anyway. No one cares. Coordinating devops with this many stakeholders, now _thats_ expensive.

The quality of the actual technology (much like on the web itself) is initially irrelevant. The value is in the fact there's a contract. A standard. Docker is a bad implementation of reasonable idea. The question isn't if it's a good technical choice. No, it's not. But it's organisational and economically more compatible with the rest of world.

And you know what? At least those enterprise idiots will run JVM instances on their docker images, so if they need more than three servers it's not because they are incompetent (like every startup wasting their time on cloud orchestration stuff). At least when they pay the price in complexity for building something scalable it's because they actually need something scalable.

Re:Steve Singh will become Docker’s new CEO by api on Tuesday May 02, 2017 @03:46PM (#14249893)
This is by far the best post about Docker I've ever seen.

We're a small company and so far we've never found a role for Docker. We just deploy stuff to VMs and bare metal servers with Chef. Docker is occasionally useful for testing and builds but that's about it.

But... the thought of coordinating the way we do things with 100+ developers working under layers of middle management is terrifying. Stuff would be breaking left and right. It would be a disaster.

For that we'd want a true zero-interdependency micro service type way of doing things where everyone's part is a different product and is deployed as a completely separate monolith.

For that Docker with all its warts and inefficiencies is an acceptable, standard solution. As you say it's not ideal or elegant but it works and people know it.

Re:Steve Singh will become Docker’s new CEO by tyingq on Wednesday May 03, 2017 @02:35AM (#14253517)
I meant something different by "enterprisify". Ever dealt with SAP?
Re:Steve Singh will become Docker’s new CEO by spIrr on Wednesday May 03, 2017 @07:55AM (#14254917)
What did you mean?
Re:Steve Singh will become Docker’s new CEO by tyingq on Wednesday May 03, 2017 @08:57AM (#14255228)
Complicated licensing, unbundling of every little feature, aggressive salespeople, hyperbolic marketing, etc.
Re:Steve Singh will become Docker’s new CEO by bdcravens on Tuesday May 02, 2017 @12:50PM (#14248058)
Walking around the exhibit hall at DockerCon, and then trying to pick sessions, I couldn't help but feel that heading a small engineering team I was at the wrong conference.
Re:Steve Singh will become Docker’s new CEO by majewsky on Tuesday May 02, 2017 @01:41PM (#14248628)
Same at CloudNativeCon by the way. I went to the technical-sounding talks (as opposed to "success stories"), but most of them were just "observe as I upload a YAML file into Kubernetes and stuff happens".

Meanwhile, the booths were 50% "we can install Kubernetes for you" and 50% "we can do monitoring/logshipping for your Kubernetes", which is interesting given that the Kubernetes guys are working on solving the first issue and Prometheus/Grafana/Fluentd solve the second issue already.

Re:Steve Singh will become Docker’s new CEO by opsunit on Tuesday May 02, 2017 @06:55PM (#14251433)
2c from my experience.

Fluentd is a terrible log shipper: sub-second timestamping is not yet supported in the stable build, support is patchy in the plugin ecosystem in 0.14. There's also some humdingers buried in the source (Rational numbers for time arithmetic?) Abstractions leak all over the place. The plugin ecosystem is weak and the API shims in the minor version API break are poor and in my experience break semver.

Prometheus has the right idea, but I wouldn't want to be running and scaling my telemetry system if I'd also taken on the burden of running my own container scheduler. Whilst I've no doubt Prometheus can be made to scale, I'd rather somebody else made the federation decisions for me.

Re:Steve Singh will become Docker’s new CEO by meddlepal on Tuesday May 02, 2017 @01:51PM (#14248729)
Agreed. There was a remarkable difference between 2017 DockerCon and 2016. I felt right at place in 2016 but 2017... just missed the mark. Felt very much like all the session were geared toward "Introducing Docker" or "How to convince your manager about Docker".

Oh well :\

Re:Steve Singh will become Docker’s new CEO by shykes on Tuesday May 02, 2017 @09:39PM (#14252368)
Did you try any of the black belt track? It seems like that might have been a good fit for you.

One problem with the Austin convention center is that it's VERY spread out, so it's easy to miss an entire chunk of sessions because they're almost impossibly far if you don't know what you're looking for.

Re:Steve Singh will become Docker’s new CEO by bdcravens on Wednesday May 03, 2017 @01:05PM (#14257737)
I think the app and sessions guide did a pretty good job of informing about sessions, but I'll second the point about the layout of the Austin convention center. For those not in perfect health (I have a lung condition) it was a bit .. extreme. Probably the longest hikes of any conference I've ever been to.
Re:Steve Singh will become Docker’s new CEO by cookiecaper on Tuesday May 02, 2017 @09:51PM (#14252408)
If only more of us had managers that needed convincing to switch to Docker.

As this thread insinuates, Docker is a VC-driven fad that has been seized upon by posers as the next buzzword to plaster across their resume. I wish more engineering managers were willing to stand up to this nonsense.

Re:Steve Singh will become Docker’s new CEO by vertex-four on Tuesday May 02, 2017 @10:04AM (#14246373)
Docker has been targeting enterprise use cases for a good while now. Frankly, aside from in development, it's not terribly useful until you get to a certain scale which requires a certain development model (complete separation of application and storage, different teams managing different components, etc).
Re:Steve Singh will become Docker’s new CEO by xyzzy_plugh on Tuesday May 02, 2017 @10:05AM (#14246381)
I mean, the whole rebrand is still a bit of a bait-and-switch. It leaves a real bad taste in my mouth and while I may not have been the biggest fan of Docker in the past, but I am certainly going to bias away from them now, rather than simply being indifferent.
Re:Steve Singh will become Docker’s new CEO by tyingq on Tuesday May 02, 2017 @10:12AM (#14246442)
Clever, though, to force your predecessor to do that bit of dirty work before you're announced.
Re:Steve Singh will become Docker’s new CEO by phonon on Tuesday May 02, 2017 @10:13AM (#14246449)
Time for "The Box".
Re:Steve Singh will become Docker’s new CEO by pthreads on Tuesday May 02, 2017 @10:23AM (#14246559)
Spoiler alert! Steve Singh was Jack Barker all along!
Re:Steve Singh will become Docker’s new CEO by nunez on Tuesday May 02, 2017 @04:22PM (#14250221)
That is already happening. They are going for the "build enterprise version then have partners sell it and consultants support it" model as their main revenue funnel. It's the only way that something like this can make money, and given the unbelievable amount of hype for the product right now, it's the smart thing to do IMO
Re:Steve Singh will become Docker’s new CEO by monkey2005 on Tuesday May 02, 2017 @10:36AM (#14246660)
Docker already tried to go the enterprise route but they're getting killed in the market.

The small number of enterprises that are doing containers are going to Kubernetes for technical credibility or Redhat OpenShift for enterprise credibility.

Instead of trying to be a platform company for the enterprise, Docker should have just licensed and supported the Docker engine to the mass market (their one moat) and absolutely cleaned up.

Re:Steve Singh will become Docker’s new CEO by tyingq on Tuesday May 02, 2017 @10:47AM (#14246757)
>Docker should have just licensed and supported the Docker engine to the mass market (their one moat)

I give them a lot of credit for noticing that nobody else was capitalizing on the existing container tech. But it did exist already. They didn't invent something new. They just put a nice cli, daemon, and image repository around it. I think they know the "license the engine" bit is a non-starter, as the higher level container orchestration platforms are already abstracting away from it.[1]

[1]http://blog.kubernetes.io/2016/12/container-runtime-interfac...