I'm guessing you're not familiar with how long Eminent Domain takes when the owner has significant resources.
In practice, Eminent Domain is only used to take things from poor people.
Will you say that this is not an environmental catastrophe? As an environmental catastrophe is this incident not a national security incident? How can the only answer to this problem be that BP be in charge of fixing it? It would be like saying that Lehman Brothers broke the economy and they are the only ones who can fix it. Obviously that is not the case as evidenced by the Governments extreme, forceful and more than a handfull of people would say illegal intervention.
Where is the extreme, forceful intervention the nation is begging for now? How can the POTUS be impotent when we need the "buck" to stop with someone who has the power to do something meaningful?
Ya, I'm mashing a whole bunch of things together but, eh, whatever. When virtual numbers flash on a screen in the wrong directions the world basically comes to a halt and there is no limit to the power and absolute authority of the Government. But when an actual real life, physical catastrophe is at hand, the Government is impotent and has no tools or imagination at it's disposal.
It's all just sickening and shameful.
[1] http://www.nytimes.com/2010/05/30/us/30rig.html
[2] http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2010/05/16/60minutes/main6490...
However under all the various and sundry legislation enacted over many years governing environmental matters and matters on the high seas, you would think somewhere in there the POTUS has power to make some sort of executive action that would have taken more control (and that this is still possible to do).
It does seem to me that the US government could be doing more with the cleanup, though, instead of just standing on the sidelines and shouting "Hey BP! Fix this faster!"
I mean, if I caused an accident on the freeway and crashed into a truck, causing toxic waste to spill out across twelve lanes of the interstate, would the Highway Patrol show up and tell me to clean up the mess I made? Hell no, they'd use government resources to clean the mess up as quickly as possible, and worry about punishing me for my negligence later.
I just can't figure out what's up with Obama's pocket veto of that....
Or as we recently learned, turning the Netherlands down flat when they offered to come over and help. I think I read that offers by 13 nations have been refused.
gulf oil spill dredge sand barrier islands refusal
Dutch gulf oil spill help refused
(OK, it did take me two tries to get a good Google first page on the former.)
When I googled the dredge stuff the first link was from RedState, a hyper-partisan republican blog, so that made me more suspicious. I found some info such as this, http://www.nola.com/news/gulf-oil-spill/index.ssf/2010/05/co..., where the Corps of Engineers has approved one such project to test the idea. And I found info about BP pushing back on paying for these projects. But I definitely did not find anything about an "Obama pocket veto". Except for Republican propaganda sites.
The Dutch refusal stuff, after wading through all the republican propaganda blogs, apparently has to do with some law I didn't understand.
There have been waivers[2] granted in the past, but very rarely. Some are advocating for a Jones Act waiver[3][4], but that's considered unlikely, due to a mix of politics, business, and possible stubbornness.
1 - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Merchant_Marine_Act_of_1920
2 - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Merchant_Marine_Act_of_1920#Wai...
3 - http://www.globalresearch.ca/index.php?context=va&aid=19...
4 - http://www.chron.com/disp/story.mpl/business/steffy/7043272....
As [2] notes, waivers have been used as recently as Katrina for national emergencies, which this most certainly is. It's hard for me to imagine that any pressure group could politically get away with resisting a long term waiver if the spotlight was turned onto them, and it's hard to see why they'd do it in the first place, since this is a unique situation where there's more than enough work to go around for all.
But let's cut to the chase, has Team Obama even tried?
"Obama pocket veto" is my term for his sitting on the direct request from Republican governor Jindal for weeks (more than a month as I recall) before even approving that one "test".
You may dislike the truth as presented by "hyper-partisan republican blog[s]", but that doesn't mean it doesn't exist or that half or more of the nation isn't listening to those sorts of sources. Or do you expect the NYT et. al. to honestly and quickly report on Team Obama's failings?
You might want to listen to the Ragin' Cajun James Carville on this general subject (full disclosure, I'm half Cajun myself and my mom grew up pretty close to the coast) for another partisan view.
The president could demand all engineering information be made available, and let the Coast Guard/ACE/DARPA manage the operation, without "repossessing" any real property.
not if you could find oil anywhere else.
confiscating BP's equipment and whatever the hell else is not the fastest way to get the mess cleaned up. it's the fastest way to guarantee oil companies think twice about engaging in any capital construction projects in the vicinity of the united states.
When the President of the United States thinks that BP is the best we can do, we are all well and truly boned. Not because that is obviously not true, but because the President has more or less abdicated his power.