Thank you for this comment, it connected with some of my feelings that have precolated up since my initial question.
I agree, I need to establish a vision, and launch it fast.
Thanks for those book recommondations. Thats always been my problem: marketing
So, I would say come up with your own vision and launch it ASAP because it will probably change over time. I think when reddit launched, they put a lot of emphasis on the recommendation algorithm, which no one ended up using. They didn't even have comments in the first version, yet the comments are now the most important part.
Edit: Try reading the books "Positioning", "Innovator's Dilemma", and "Innovator's Solution." Your challenges aren't technical ones, they're marketing ones. You're taking on big established websites, and you need to position your website in the correct way to even have a chance at taking them on.