News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:There’s no good way to kill a bad idea by RcouF1uZ4gsC on Monday May 01, 2017 @10:03AM (#14237491)
Yep, we still believe in the humors theory of medicine. In fact, there is a popular app to help remind people to get their blood drained regularly. There are also billboards reminding everyone that washing your hands is a waste of water. We also believe that the sun rotates around the Earth. As such, since we are the center of the universe, everyone laughs at the crackpots who suggest that we would ever want to travel to other planets or even the moon. /s

Of course, there has been a good way to kill ideas - evidence with real world effect and patient engagement of naysayers over time. It makes me sad as from the 1500s - 1900s we had so much invention and progress and revolutionized people's thinking about the world, and we the heirs of all of that despair that we can't get rid of bad ideas. If so, the fault lies with us, and this fatalistic view is a bad idea that needs to be killed.

Re:There’s no good way to kill a bad idea by ythn on Monday May 01, 2017 @01:42PM (#14239701)
> We also believe that the sun rotates around the Earth.

Is it possible to prove that the sun doesn't rotate around the earth other than saying "the supporting mathematics are much, MUCH easier if the earth rotates around the sun"? From a relativistic perspective, couldn't you define the earth as being still and everything else as moving relative to it?

Re:There’s no good way to kill a bad idea by GavinMcG on Monday May 01, 2017 @08:50PM (#14243145)
What do you mean by "prove"? Yes, you can define the earth as stationary, but if you're taking that definition seriously – rather than just doing it to make the math easier within that frame of reference, or for rhetorical purposes – if you're taking it seriously then you've got a whole host of implications that you have to explain. For example, why is Earth stationary, with the sun rotating around it, while all the other planets rotate around the sun? Given what else we know about gravity, how do you account for the sun with its huge mass orbiting the relatively tiny mass of Earth?

One response is that you throw those "known" things out as well, and so on down the rabbit hole.

We prefer theories to be coherent with the rest of our knowledge. Depending on the extent to which you're willing to dispense with that – and to dispense with a huge number of claims we take as settled – sure, you can choose to hold on to basically any view. The question is why you're holding on to that and throwing out the rest.

Re:There’s no good way to kill a bad idea by rm_-rf_slash on Monday May 01, 2017 @10:27AM (#14237661)
Living with the internet has made rational people less tolerant of ignorance, as the real answers are certainly out there to dispute dubious claims.

However, the internet has also provided enclaves for those who wish to embrace ignorance with solidarity.

The big question: are we as a species and a civilization moving forwards, or backwards?

Re:There’s no good way to kill a bad idea by metaphorm on Monday May 01, 2017 @12:22PM (#14238880)
> The big question: are we as a species and a civilization moving forwards, or backwards?

malformed question. do you believe that there is a linear trajectory of "civilization development"? I certainly don't.