News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Can Germany's High-Speed Trains Get Back on Track? by masklinn on Friday June 11, 2010 @09:00AM (#1423677)
At this point, for europe it might just be a better idea to let the TGV network grow outwards from France. It's already started to spread its tendrils in other countries anyway.

Not that the network is that good in France though, Paris-Lyon-Marseilles has been nice for years, the connection to Lilles (and now to Bruxelles in Belgium as well) and to London via the channel tunnel is nice, a line recently opened to the east of the country (Strasbourg) but the TGV network has a few glaring issues:

* Everything goes through Paris. Lyon-Paris takes 3 hours, Paris-Strasbourg take about the same time, but a direct from Lyon to Strasbourg (not via Paris) takes 6 hours even though there is pretty much the same distance (~450km) betweem all of them (yep, Paris-Lyon-Strasbourg almost forms an equilateral triangle). Likewise Paris-Marseille (800km) takes 4h but Marseille-Nice (south-east to south-east but further east, 200km) will be 3h30

* There are no LGV (high-speed train lines) to western France, they stop at Le Mans and Tours (200~250km from Paris) so travelling from Paris to Marseille (800km) takes 4h, and Paris to Bordeaux (550km) will take you 4h as well (as the TGV has to use regular lines for half the travel). Paris to Toulouse (670km direct, 780km via Bordeaux) will waste at least 7h (TGV to Bordeaux then regional train).

Thankfully this is changing, there are new lines in the work and projected to start solving this issue (see dotted lines: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:France_TGV.png) and overall TGV is awesome, but it's nowhere near perfect right now.

PS: I note that my timings differ from Spiegel's, I got mine from the SNCF database so...

PPS: For those unfamiliar with french geography and cities, Paris is of course the french capital (inner city population 2.2M, 11.7M including suburbs), Marseilles is France's second biggest city (852k inner, 1.6M metro), Lyon comes third (472k inner but 1.75M metro), Toulouse is the fourth biggest (437k inner, 1.1M metro), Nice stands at 5th (348k inner, 990k metro), Strasbourg 7th (273k inner, 638k metro) and Bordeaux is 9th (250k inner, 1M metro)

Re:How Can Germany's High-Speed Trains Get Back on Track? by pmjordan on Friday June 11, 2010 @09:30AM (#1423776)
At this point, for europe it might just be a better idea to let the TGV network grow outwards from France.

I doubt that would solve the problem where political wrangling is the issue. I especially can't see the Germans allowing the French to build and run their trains and lines. ;)

The ICE has run to Vienna for a while now, and Austria's ÖBB recently started their high-ish-speed "Railjet" [1] service (vmax currently 200km/h, due to increase to 230). Both suffer from the same network problems as Germany - trains pass through far too many smaller towns; old tracks. Plus there's the additional difficulty of the Austrian geography. The Vienna-Munich/Frankfurt route runs through one of the flattest parts of Austria, much of the rest of the country is covered in mountains.

They are building bypasses (mainly colossal tunnels, as "flat" around here still is pretty hilly) but it takes decades and consumes a phenomenal amount of taxpayer money.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Railjet

Re:How Can Germany's High-Speed Trains Get Back on Track? by ugh on Friday June 11, 2010 @09:37AM (#1423798)
Oh, I don’t think that’s such a big problem. Thalys already exists [1] and they use TGV trains.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thalys

Re:How Can Germany's High-Speed Trains Get Back on Track? by pmjordan on Friday June 11, 2010 @03:04PM (#1424346)
I'm aware of Thalys, though Aachen/Cologne isn't exactly a long journey.
Re:How Can Germany's High-Speed Trains Get Back on Track? by eru on Friday June 11, 2010 @09:32AM (#1423784)
> At this point, for europe it might just be a better idea to let the TGV network grow outwards from France. It's already started to spread its tendrils in other countries anyway.

You can make the same argument about the ICE network.

Re:How Can Germany's High-Speed Trains Get Back on Track? by masklinn on Friday June 11, 2010 @09:47AM (#1423846)
> You can make the same argument about the ICE network.

Nope. First because there are big issues with ICE in germany alone, the program isn't in its best shape where TGV is proven and pretty healthy, and second because TGV has already started expanding its network into neighboring countries.

Re:How Can Germany's High-Speed Trains Get Back on Track? by eru on Friday June 11, 2010 @09:50AM (#1423856)
You may be right about the first points. I only wanted to say, that the ICE network, too, has started expanding into neighbouring countries. You can go from Paris to Frankfurt by ICE. Or to Switzerland, or Brussels.
Re:How Can Germany's High-Speed Trains Get Back on Track? by jackfoxy on Friday June 11, 2010 @01:58PM (#1424129)
Your point #1 is the inherent problem with rail passenger transport, and why air travel has an advantage. For rail you have to engineer and build both the vehicle and transport medium (rails). This gives you two very different engineering challenges. Building the transport medium between every two points is a new undertaking. Air travel on the other had presents one engineering challenge, creation of the vehicle. (I'm dismissing the airports, because essentially they are very simple structures. Of course the air traffic control system is not simple.) And when you have the vehicle your choice or routes is practically unlimited.
Re:How Can Germany's High-Speed Trains Get Back on Track? by mrtron on Friday June 11, 2010 @02:36PM (#1424253)
I am not sure I agree here. It seems to me this is an area where restrictions have both benefits and drawbacks.

Rails seem much more efficient, safe, and have faster terminal service. Riding on any good rail service is vastly more enjoyable to the passenger than flying. I would rather travel Europe, Asia, and North America on high speed trains than by air.

Re:How Can Germany's High-Speed Trains Get Back on Track? by anamax on Friday June 11, 2010 @04:39PM (#1424672)
> Rails seem much more efficient, safe, and have faster terminal service.

While that may be true, those aren't the only criteria. (And, the efficiency is only fuel efficiency.)

> Riding on any good rail service is vastly more enjoyable to the passenger than flying.

When the journey is the goal, that's great, but I'm usually travelling because I want to get somewhere else.