So you have this guy here who said he was diagnosed with Lyme and was treated for a year and did not improve, and is now not answering questions about Lyme.
edit: I bet some doctor's (or the doctor that prescribed) told him that Lyme doesn't exist, or you couldn't have it after all those antibiotics... etc and that's why he's so excited about a Celiac diagnosis (or rather anything but Lyme), because it means he can sweep Lyme under the rug, exactly like the doctor. But it won't help him though, and the doctor who told him to forget about Lyme ultimately doesn't care because he's not the one with it. The edge of science is a fuzzy place, but some people are pushed right up to it!
Nobody is saying Lyme doesn't exist. Most doctors have diagnosed Lyme - there are over 30,000 reported cases annually. It's neither rare nor controversial. I am saying that Stage 3 Lyme has a specific set of symptoms that are inconsistent with what savemylife describes. Allen Steere is saying that "chronic Lyme" is not an infectious disease caused by borrelia.
Savemylife's Lyme diagnosis was done only biochemically, which is not consistent with the CDC diagnostic criteria for reasons I described above. He was then treated for a year - a risky proposition in itself - and was unhelped. Spirochetes are notoriously susceptible to antibiotics. If you only take one dose of doxy, you cure ~75% of all Lyme cases. It's that easy! After 2 weeks of doxy, the cure rate is nearly 100%. After a year, you are simply eradicating native gut flora. He does not have Lyme disease. He has a real problem; this is not it, and pushing him towards sexy, grabbag, but clearly incorrect diagnostic labels helps nobody.
Why did chronic Lyme become a grab bag? I don't know for sure - it did so before I entered medical school, and in medical school we actually don't waste too much time (or perhaps we spend too little) talking about quackery.
Rejecting the CDC's diagnostic criteria and creating their own -- and, conveniently, profiting from doing so -- makes me immediately hypervigilant around physicians who claim to treat "chronic Lyme." In fact, just today I listened to an hourlong talk today by Allen Steere at MGH about Lyme disease, and he very clearly laid out what Stage 3 Lyme disease looks like: basically, arthritis +/- neurological deficits.
"Chronic Lyme" is distinguished from Stage 3 Lyme disease by being a grabbag diagnosis without accepted, objective diagnostic criteria. Multiple randomized controlled trials have been attempted on patients with "chronic Lyme," and in none of these trials did treatment with antibiotics help. The disease that these people are suffering from is, no doubt, real, but it is not caused by chronic, persistent infection with Borrelia burgdoferi, and it is not helped by antibiotics.