News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AI That Picks Stocks Better Than the Pros by yummyfajitas on Thursday June 10, 2010 @11:51PM (#1422708)
On the day in question, the algorithms' "oh crap" mode kicked in, the bots no longer felt they had a grasp on fair value, and decided to withdraw all their bids and offers.

The algorithms were not turned off because they didn't work. They algorithms were turned off because everyone knew the exchanges were going to break trades.

If your smart algorithm finds the bottom at 10, buys, sells at 20, and the market goes up to 30, you just made $10, right ($20-$10)? If the exchanges break your trade at 10, you are now short the stock at $20, and the current price is $30! Unfortunately, it's impossible to predict whether the trade will be broken; it's a human making that decision.

Incidentally, most high frequency traders get no special privileges. There are a few that do (the ones you describe), but they are special cases rather than the general circumstance.

Re:AI That Picks Stocks Better Than the Pros by leelin on Friday June 11, 2010 @01:35AM (#1422921)
I agree with you, and in cases where the HFT bot gets no special privileges, then they are under absolutely no obligation to be there when hell is breaking loose. Why is everyone so mad at the bots for playing it safe and deciding not to trade?
Re:AI That Picks Stocks Better Than the Pros by djb_hackernews on Friday June 11, 2010 @09:13AM (#1423720)
I've seen that explanation that people ended up short and deep in the hole after the trade is broken but it just doesn't make sense. Got any links where I can read more?
Re:AI That Picks Stocks Better Than the Pros by yummyfajitas on Friday June 11, 2010 @01:26PM (#1424005)
Re:AI That Picks Stocks Better Than the Pros by djb_hackernews on Friday June 11, 2010 @02:35PM (#1424244)
So basically you have nothing to back your statements up. It appears that when the exchanges break the trade, its completely unwound, as if it never happened. Shares go back to the seller, money goes back to the buyer. No one ends up short.
Re:AI That Picks Stocks Better Than the Pros by yummyfajitas on Friday June 11, 2010 @03:12PM (#1424379)
Nothing you said contradicts what I said. The scenario is that you make two trades - a buy at $10 and a sell at $20. The buy is broken but the sell is not.

Now it's as if you sold but the buy never happened (i.e., you sold stocks you didn't own). That's a short.