News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Torcoin: Crypto's latest scam by coldtea on Saturday April 29, 2017 @07:43AM (#14226111)
>that's a bit of shifting the goal-posts, isn't it? Communism resulted in the deaths of ~100 million people due to famines from planned economy mismanagement, genocide, mass murder and so on but that's fine because Nazis were horrific murderers too?

No, that's just not a significant argument against communism in general, as similar things happened not just by the "Nazis" but by all major regime changes. Europe had power struggles, civil wars, executions, economy mismanagement etc for 2 centuries leading to the 20th century (which brought WWI and WWII and the colonial wars).

Heck, the modern democratic era started with hundreds of thousands executed in the French Revolution, and then the Napoleonic wars -- and countless other peripheral wars, power struggles, and bloody revolutions.

When Communism came about in Russia, non-communism Europe was torn by the bloodbath of WWI, pogroms, ethnic tensions, etc.

But when it's up to communism we do a sleight of hand, and gather all deaths under communism, in all countries, under various reasons, and do a mass tally to prove how bad it is.

Maybe do a similar tally under non-communism? Let's even constrain it to the 20th century.

Only then would a comparison make sense, whether communism is so worse than our cherished non-communism systems, or whether we're just summing all kinds of 20th century wars, tensions and power struggles that happened to take place under communism in some countries, and forget the similar happenings in non communism countries.

There are no comments on this comment yet.