News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Scaleway ARMv8 Cloud Servers by unit91 on Thursday April 27, 2017 @09:59AM (#14211473)
Full-stack dev here with almost no real hardware knowledge.

Why would you want to use ARM instead of X86 on a server like this? The architecture​ switch comes with dependency headaches -- what counterbalances those to make it worth it?

Re:Scaleway ARMv8 Cloud Servers by rwmj on Thursday April 27, 2017 @10:08AM (#14211538)
At the moment you almost certainly would not want to use them. The production volumes are currently far too small to say whether ARM servers will end up being much cheaper or better in other ways than Intel-based servers.

These particular servers are based on the Cavium ThunderX which has (up to) 48 cores per socket, and usually two sockets per server. Each individual core is rather slow. The servers themselves are not noticably cheaper in price than x86-based servers. As noted above it's very early days.

There are some more interesting servers coming along. In particular Qualcomm have a 48 core ARM server SoC which has great performance per core, and should ship in a few months. (They are already shipping final silicon to partners and a few developers)

What could make the difference would be:

- ARM partners currently ship around 40x cores annually relative to Intel. Of course the vast majority being phone/tablet 32 bit cores, but that kind of volume might mean that future ARM servers become very cheap, or have an incredibly high density of cores.

- Multiple vendors are allowed to design ARM SoCs, so we may find that particular vendors optimize for more niche use cases, and if your use case happens to be that niche, that could be a win for you.

As an example of the last point: Could your application use 16 x ethernet ports and some custom hardware to process SDN dataplane (eg OpenFlow) tables, all on a single System-on-Chip? Good luck getting Intel to design such a chip for you. However an ARM partner would be entirely free to develop such a chip, and maybe hardware like that will form an important part of telecoms/OpenStack cloud deployments in future.

Re:Scaleway ARMv8 Cloud Servers by discordianfish on Thursday April 27, 2017 @10:46AM (#14211856)
> The servers themselves are not noticably cheaper in price than x86-based servers

You mean given the rather slow cores? I can't think of any provider offering x86 bare metal at this price.

Re:Scaleway ARMv8 Cloud Servers by rwmj on Thursday April 27, 2017 @10:51AM (#14211901)
I mean if you buy the servers. This site has a selection of these Cavium ThunderX servers for sale with prices (in GBP): https://www.avantek.co.uk/store/arm-servers.html (Edit: Fixed the link)
Re:Scaleway ARMv8 Cloud Servers by alberth on Thursday April 27, 2017 @10:07AM (#14211530)
It all comes down to performance per dollar.

Currently, ARM can't touch the performance of a mid to highend x86.

But ARM is extremely cheap and a solid low to mid x86.

If top end performance isn't needed. And you have the ability to recompile your software to run on ARM, you can't beat ARM pricing.

Just look at the OP link.

$12/mo for 8 cores.

For x86, you'd easily pay 10x that per month.

Re:Scaleway ARMv8 Cloud Servers by kogepathic on Thursday April 27, 2017 @10:16AM (#14211600)
> $12/mo for 8 cores. > For x86, you'd easily pay 10x that per month.

Scaleway offers baremetal x86 servers with 8 cores for 17.99€/month (C2M). [0] But they are based on Intel Atom, so the performance is quite low.

[0] https://www.scaleway.com/pricing/

Re:Scaleway ARMv8 Cloud Servers by dfrey on Thursday April 27, 2017 @01:28PM (#14213240)
I don't care if a VPS as 1 core or 1024 cores. What I care about is how much work it can get done.
Re:Scaleway ARMv8 Cloud Servers by dagw on Thursday April 27, 2017 @10:38AM (#14211785)
Why would you want to use ARM instead of X86 on a server like this?

For €12/month you get 8 (slower) cores and 8 GB of RAM. At a place like Hetzner roughly the same price gets you 2 (faster) cores and 4 GB of RAM. For some workload more slower cores and more RAM gives better performance that fewer faster cores and less RAM.

Re:Scaleway ARMv8 Cloud Servers by znpy on Thursday April 27, 2017 @10:29AM (#14211687)
If you don't do platform-dependent development (low-level[* ] c/c++ or assembly development) then you're going to see pretty much no difference.

The main difference is that you get a 8-cores machine with 200GB ssd and 8 gb ram for the price of a 1 core, 1GB ram, 30GB ssd on digitalocean and similar. Scaleway is still developing some extra features [* * ], for most hobbyist to medium scale usage, i think it's going to be just fine (plus, the monetary savings).

It is to be said that each of those 8 cores are likely to be individually slower than an usual x86 core, but you get 8 instead of 1 and they're fully yours: you don't have to share cpu time with other users, as it happens on pretty much all vps providers: you're renting a whole machine.

[* ] = applications written in C/C++ will work flawlessly, as long as they don't exploit x86-specific features. If you're doing web stuff, you're unlikely to hit this spot.

[* * ] = see C14, an S3-like storage service.

Re:Scaleway ARMv8 Cloud Servers by _delirium on Thursday April 27, 2017 @10:47AM (#14211865)
> they're fully yours: you don't have to share cpu time with other users, as it happens on pretty much all vps providers: you're renting a whole machine.

That's not true with these. These are VPSs backed by a 48-core physical server. Scalaway does have an older baremetal ARMv7 server offering though.

Re:Scaleway ARMv8 Cloud Servers by makomk on Thursday April 27, 2017 @01:10PM (#14213084)
Anything that runs on a JIT is effectively platform dependent because the underlying JIT has to support the hardware - that includes Java, JS, etc.
Re:Scaleway ARMv8 Cloud Servers by alexandros on Thursday April 27, 2017 @10:04AM (#14211513)
At resin.io we keep looking for a solid arm host, as we are currently emulating a ton of arm builds on x86. I guess our use case is somewhat unique, but we still haven't found something that works for us.
Re:Scaleway ARMv8 Cloud Servers by cyberpunk on Thursday April 27, 2017 @12:47PM (#14212907)
Totally offtopic (sorry) but when I saw you mention "resin.io" I immediately thought about the java appserver from caucho which was a pretty okay product back in the day; I assume you're not related?
Re:Scaleway ARMv8 Cloud Servers by thraway2016 on Thursday April 27, 2017 @11:33AM (#14212244)
Primary reason would be finally being rid of the Intel ME. For the truly paranoid.
Re:Scaleway ARMv8 Cloud Servers by progval on Thursday April 27, 2017 @12:52PM (#14212963)
I can't find a technical reason, but at least it is a way not to give in to Intel's monopoly on CPUs.
Re:Scaleway ARMv8 Cloud Servers by nimish on Thursday April 27, 2017 @10:02AM (#14211496)
Cost.
Re:Scaleway ARMv8 Cloud Servers by pkhagah on Thursday April 27, 2017 @10:03AM (#14211505)
Performance/TDP/Cost