Regardless of efficiency, we have certainly exceeded the range, cargo capacity, top speed, and passenger space of most birds.
Similarly, even if signal propagation in the brain is not understood, we could conceivably beat the brain in other metrics.
This is the core point. Our technology may still suck compared to nature, but we've been beating nature consistently since before humans learned to write, because we don't have the same set of constraints that natural biological systems have.
So just like we can make inefficient flying machines that beat nature on most other conceivable metrics, we could presumably build an energy-inefficient but smarter mind at some point.
> we could presumably build an energy-inefficient but smarter mind at some point.
So this smarter mind will probably be our own, but that would also be achieved by some sort of artificial means.
> So this smarter mind will probably be our own
It's plausible for me too, but not because we can't do stuff outside what evolution did - just because it's usually easier to hack an existing system than to build a new one from scratch.
Sure it does, because physical laws are a fundamental part of Nature
Sure, the very first calculators beat brain in some metrics. But we are not talking about those metrics here.
It doesn't need to assume all, just some non-trivial amount. I don't know the ratio of inter-neuron to intra-neuron processing in brains, or if such a metric even exists. But it seems theoretically possible at least to measure the computing power of a neuron in isolation, and see if artificial analogs exist (or could be built) that exceed that by some margin. Ultimately we're just looking for avenues of evidence to explore.
The author makes a good point about intelligence not being one-dimensional, and I think the same thing holds for flying ability. Efficiency is one dimension, but you also have speed, range and so forth.
This assumes that all the processing that human brain does is by sending signals across the neurons. Which we really don't know. Right?
>We can look at other evolved/biological capabilities, like swimming or flying, and compare them to state-of-the-art artificial analogs..
Do we yet have an airplane yet that can come close to the efficiency of the most clumsiest of the birds?