News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tell HN: Discord is violating open source licenses by packetized on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @12:09PM (#14194867)
Can you share where you found the project files in the client tar.gz?

edit: Found it, uws.js in resources/bootstrap/discord_rpc.zip

edit2: This is arguably worse, but the argument may be "it's a compiled binary":

  -bash-4.1$ strings discord_rpc.node | grep uws.*cpp$
  ../../discord_common/native/third_party/uws/nodejs/addon.cpp
  ../../discord_common/native/third_party/uws/nodejs/addon.cpp
  ../../discord_common/native/third_party/uws/src/EventSystem.cpp
  ../../discord_common/native/third_party/uws/src/Extensions.cpp
  ../../discord_common/native/third_party/uws/src/HTTPSocket.cpp
  ../../discord_common/native/third_party/uws/src/Network.cpp
  ../../discord_common/native/third_party/uws/src/Server.cpp
  ../../discord_common/native/third_party/uws/src/UTF8.cpp
  ../../discord_common/native/third_party/uws/src/WebSocket.cpp
  ../../discord_common/native/third_party/uws/nodejs/addon.cpp
  ../../discord_common/native/third_party/uws/src/HTTPSocket.cpp
  ../../discord_common/native/third_party/uws/src/WebSocket.cpp
  ../../discord_common/native/third_party/uws/src/EventSystem.cpp
  ../../discord_common/native/third_party/uws/src/Extensions.cpp
  ../../discord_common/native/third_party/uws/src/Network.cpp
  ../../discord_common/native/third_party/uws/src/Server.cpp
  ../../discord_common/native/third_party/uws/src/UTF8.cpp
  -bash-4.1$
Re:Tell HN: Discord is violating open source licenses by dsp1234 on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @12:16PM (#14194951)
Which must be doubly frustrating since they have a copy of https://github.com/websockets/ws in the node_modules folder, and that has the appropriate license text (MIT in that case)
Re:Tell HN: Discord is violating open source licenses by dsp1234 on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @12:25PM (#14195052)
edit2: This is arguably worse, but the argument may be "it's a compiled binary":

discord_rpc.node is an ELF file. It's hard to see how that would not be considered a binary distribution (if it was that file alone, and not being distributed with source files)

Re:Tell HN: Discord is violating open source licenses by packetized on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @12:31PM (#14195160)
You're correct, I was a bit too quick on the 'reply' button there.
Re:Tell HN: Discord is violating open source licenses by charlesdm on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @12:24PM (#14195043)
If it's compiled, they don't need to add anything. If it's interpreted, i.e. a JS file, they do (at the top of the JS file)