News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Exercise 'keeps the mind sharp' in over-50s, study finds by zeteo on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @10:01AM (#14193553)
Looking at the funnel plot in fig. 3 in the linked meta-analysis [1], the high precision studies (standard error < 0.268) are clustered around an effect size of 0. The overall positive effect derives exclusively from the medium and low-precision studies, with several visible outliers well to the right influencing the mean significantly. The medium and low-precision studies had problems with one or more of the following:

"randomisation; allocation concealment; blinding of therapists (intervention supervisors); blinding of participants; blinding of outcome assessors; handling of incomplete data (use of intention-to-treat analysis); selective reporting and any other risk of bias." [1]

Also, the result was only statistically significant for poor quality control groups that didn't engage in any shared activity:

"When the control group involved either no contact (eg, waiting list, usual care; p<0.01) or education (eg, computer course, health lectures; p=0.01) the estimate was statistically significant. Where the control condition was exposed to an active control (eg, stretching; p=0.17) or social group (p=0.62), the effect size was still positive but no longer statistically significant." [1]

In summary, a few poor quality studies with large bias account for most if not all of the effect reported in this meta-analysis.

[1] http://bjsm.bmj.com/content/early/2017/03/30/bjsports-2016-0...

Re:Exercise 'keeps the mind sharp' in over-50s, study finds by hmahncke on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @01:06PM (#14195672)
Here is a recent Cochrane review looking at high quality studies of aerobic exercise and finding no significant effect in the meta-analysis:

http://www.cochrane.org/CD005381/DEMENTIA_aerobic-exercise-t...

Re:Exercise 'keeps the mind sharp' in over-50s, study finds by criddell on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @11:40AM (#14194497)
Thank you for posting this. I almost went to the gym!
Re:Exercise 'keeps the mind sharp' in over-50s, study finds by daphneokeefe on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @10:28AM (#14193794)
Thank you for spending the time to assess the validity of the claimed result, and for taking the time to explain it to us. This is a great example of the frequently poor quality of reported scientific studies.
Re:Exercise 'keeps the mind sharp' in over-50s, study finds by QSIITurbo on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @12:58PM (#14195551)
If people used their time to study and learn new things instead of fretting about their exercise, they'd be able to interpret the results of studies like these.
Re:Exercise 'keeps the mind sharp' in over-50s, study finds by npsimons on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @01:49PM (#14196178)
If people used their time to exercise instead of watch TV/Netflix/Hulu, they'd be able to think more clearly and better absorb the results of studies like these.
Re:Exercise 'keeps the mind sharp' in over-50s, study finds by NotSammyHagar on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @03:01PM (#14196911)
Maybe they would, see above.