News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Yad Vashem's database of Holocaust victims' names by yAnonymous on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @05:27AM (#14191940)
>The Germans suffered virtually nothing for conducting WWII and The Holocaust.

Except for the millions who died in combat or were murdered by the allied forces and the fact that we are still paying today for something we had no involvement in.

Anyway, it's almost the same for the U.S. today. All the crap they've pulled in foreign countries since after WW II has no consequences for them at all. U.S. politics are directly responsible for the deaths of millions.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_involvement_in_r...

Money and economics has ruled back then (decisions after WW II) and it still does now.

Re:Yad Vashem's database of Holocaust victims' names by taway_1212 on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @05:35AM (#14191975)
> Except for the millions who died in combat or were murdered by the allied forces and the fact that we are still paying today for something we had no involvement in.

It's not the question of whether there were consequences, but if there were proportional/appropriate. After the war, there were talks on the highest international level of destroying all of German's industry and turning it into an agricultural-only country. That maybe would've been extreme, but what has actually happened - financial help from the USA (instead of help for Germany's victims) and the Nazis/Gestapo staff transitioning to the ruling class of the West Germany was also extreme and deeply unfair.

What I ask for is just to have a minimum of respect for the victims and not say that there were murdered by "Nazis". I'm pretty sure they haven't even heard of the term back then.

Re:Yad Vashem's database of Holocaust victims' names by ptaipale on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @06:30AM (#14192228)
The U.S. gave substantial help to everyone in Europe, not just Germans. The Soviet occupation zone, as well as Finland and Yugoslavia, would have none of it, because U.S.S.R. was hostile to it.

The largest recipients of Marshall Plan aid were the U.K. (26 %) and France (18 %), with West Germany third at 11 % of total aid amount in this plan. So claiming that financial help went to Germany instead of Germany's victims is, in my opinion, disingenuous.

There were also other American aid programs besides the Marshall Plan.

Re:Yad Vashem's database of Holocaust victims' names by taway_1212 on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @06:46AM (#14192307)
By Germany's victims I mean for example Poles, who fought on the allied side against the Germans and were later conveniently abandoned to become a part of Stalin's empire. Poland suffered losses far beyond the material (although in this area they were still greater than France or UK's) - Germans and Soviets both had executed targeted plans to murder educated Poles (imagine large percentage of people with bachelor or higher degree being rounded up and executed - that's far bigger blow than even destruction of many cities and factories). No help was extended though.

Polish elites' philosophy was that, although our country is occupied and we can no longer contribute weapons and other material goods to the war effort, we can still contribute blood (by fighting both on both Eastern and Western fronts, as well as organizing a massive military resistance in Poland). It turned out to be extremely naive on our part, as at the end we got discarded like an used tissue.

Re:Yad Vashem's database of Holocaust victims' names by ptaipale on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @06:50AM (#14192330)
Marshall Plan was offered to Poland by the U.S. but not accepted by the U.S.S.R. so the Poles were left without. I can't blame the Americans for that. (I'm Finnish, and we also got none of it, for same reason: Soviets. Edit: However, there was some more covert aid, such as the ASLA program which converted an old loan from 1919, which Finns had been paying back throughout the Winter War, into university scholarships for Finnish students.)

Edit: And yes, the Polish suffered particularly badly between Germany and Soviets. But the Germans/Nazis were not the only ones responsible for that. We know of Katyn Forest, we know of the fate of the Warsaw Uprising where Soviet advance deliberately stopped, allowing Nazis (this time I'd really use that word) to crush the independent Polish resistance.

Re:Yad Vashem's database of Holocaust victims' names by taway_1212 on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @07:34AM (#14192530)
The Marshal Plan offering was actually a bluff by the US - they knew that the USSR would never accept it on priciple, so they took the free good PR and offered it anyway.

The bigger point here though is that Poland didn't just magically end up being ruled by Stalin (via local proxies). Allied forced gave it up to him in part of a political deal, even though 200,000 Polish soldiers fought on the Western front with an idea of returning to free Poland after the war. (actually, upon hearing of this betrayal, dozens of Polish military officers committed suicide).

Re:Yad Vashem's database of Holocaust victims' names by ptaipale on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @07:46AM (#14192577)
Sure, but they gave the help to practically anyone who could receive it. The agreement on Oder-Neisse line was indeed not due to magic, it was due to geography and military power.

The alternative? Let Patton have his way, and once Germany had surrendered, ally immediately with the Wermacht and attack the exhausted Soviet troops to force a downfall of the other mustached dictator, using the atom bomb if necessary? That wouldn't have gone down too well in the public opinion in the U.S. -- or Britain or France for that matter. Even today, there's still a Stalingrad, in the Paris metro...

Re:Yad Vashem's database of Holocaust victims' names by thriftwy on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @05:31AM (#14191958)
> Money and economics has ruled back then and it still does now.

Then what becomes of the story of The Holocaust? What's the take away then?

Re:Yad Vashem's database of Holocaust victims' names by taway_1212 on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @05:49AM (#14192034)
I don't think it's actually true. Hitler had two major causes: eradication of Jews and eradication of Slavic people, and none of them were rooted in rational economics.

He of course wanted to eradicate the Jews because he believed they were the cause of much of evil in the world - hard to find much rationality there. For the Slavs, it's a bit more complicated. Hitler was hugely fond of and inspired by America's colonization of the West (which required extermination of Native Americans to make room for settlers) and wanted to repeat that in Eastern Europe - murder all the Poles, Ukrainians, Bellariusians and Russians in the territories that he manages to conquest, raze all cities to the ground (hard to find economic justification for that) and then move German settlers in their place. The goal was to make Germany large and powerful enough that it could later tackle America. The joke here was that his thinking was largely antiquated at this point - in the XX century a country's military power was determined by its industrial capabilities, and not population/territory. So again, the entire genocide was motivated by one man's delusional view of the world, and not rational thinking.

Re:Yad Vashem's database of Holocaust victims' names by expertentipp on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @06:16AM (#14192160)
Eastern lands were important for them for other reasons - they had they own "idyllic" vision of them. High officials and officers were promised as an compensation for being sent to dreaded Eastern Front a large plot of land and Poles/Ukrainians as slaves. Eastern Poland and Ukraine are among most fertile agricultural lands in Europe.
Re:Yad Vashem's database of Holocaust victims' names by thriftwy on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @06:36AM (#14192262)
> Eastern Poland and Ukraine are among most fertile agricultural lands in Europe.

Yet people are leaving these lands as if there was a plague.

Agriculture is a few % of a healthy country's economy anyway. It won't make undesirable and undeveloped land desirable.

Re:Yad Vashem's database of Holocaust victims' names by expertentipp on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @07:52AM (#14192610)
At that times agriculture looked completely different and being feudal lord was considered prestigious. Nowadays one can grow (or rather produce) food in tiny greenhouses in overcrowded Netherlands.
Re:Yad Vashem's database of Holocaust victims' names by thriftwy on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @05:59AM (#14192084)
What you're saying is hilariously true.

What Hitler wanted is basically getting a huge slab of agricultural land. But as we all know, in second half of XX century both fertility and agriculture prices fell sharply, so even if he was ultimately successful Germany will have neither people to populate these territories nor economical reason to do so. The settlers will probably be leaving the area en masse towards "mainland Germany" creating "human deserts" of depopulation while being a drag economically. Even now it happens in these territories (Poland, Baltics, Ukraine) as people move west for better life.

Re:Yad Vashem's database of Holocaust victims' names by yAnonymous on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @06:07AM (#14192117)
When I say "back then", I'm referring to the decisions after WW II to turn Germany back into an economic force, i.e. the topic you started.
Re:Yad Vashem's database of Holocaust victims' names by taway_1212 on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @06:21AM (#14192186)
I agree then, the war's aftermath was 100% rational/cynical.
Re:Yad Vashem's database of Holocaust victims' names by andrewmu on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @05:50AM (#14192040)
Perceived excessive reparations for World War 1 were one of the grievances used by the Nazi party to gain power. It was possibly a good idea not to repeat those circumstances.
Re:Yad Vashem's database of Holocaust victims' names by taway_1212 on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @11:13AM (#14194215)
One more point on the reparations. In general, any harm done can only be forgiven when the culprit makes a genuine attempt at redeeming it. In case of Germany, there was relatively little of such attempts (some slave labor by german POWs and loss of some territory to Poland). It does not make up for the crimes committed, and thus Polish people have not truly forgiven Germans. In fact, I have friends who fantasize about Poland becoming an economic superpower and then taking out a revenge on Germany. It's truly terrible that this vicious circle was not stopped by an attempt at redemption/reparations back in the forties.
Re:Yad Vashem's database of Holocaust victims' names by taway_1212 on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @05:56AM (#14192068)
Yep I totally agree. The reparations wouldn't need to excessive - let's say Germany would pay 2-4% of their GDP every year to the victims until all damage they caused was repaired. That would probably take hundreds of years, but would be very bearable for the Germany and also pretty fair.
Re:Yad Vashem's database of Holocaust victims' names by darklajid on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @06:23AM (#14192192)
How would you even define these damages? I understand property damages, those are easy enough to calculate.

But you're talking about money/financial compensation for - in my world - invaluable things (grief, trauma, loss of life).

Judges have a hard time coming up with these on a much smaller scale and expectations for compensation vary wildly (my impression is that you can get a loooot of money in the US while the amounts would be a magnitude or two lower in Europe).

I'm not saying that we should forget about everything that happened (and people around me don't as far as I know), but I feel that your suggestion isn't easily done.

I'm from Germany, in case that matters.

Re:Yad Vashem's database of Holocaust victims' names by taway_1212 on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @07:15AM (#14192443)
As for material/financial compensations, I think it would be calculatable. We could take into account:

- damaged/destroyed infrastructure/housing/factories

- resources robbed during occupation (Poland was heavily deforested for example).

- value of slave labor

- predicted lifetime economic output of people who were killed during the war (this prediciton could be tricky)

There should also be individual payments for people who suffered hardships during the war, such as:

- malnutrition (Germany's central planning had entire Polish population on 700 kcal per day, which wasn't much more than Auschwitz's daily ratio. Luckily, Germans didn't manage to totally control the Polish agrarian economy so, thanks to the black market, we didn't quite starve as quickly as the plan assumed).

- slave labor

- torture

- loss of health

- loss of family members

For the above section, I'd argue for amounts proportional to the standard of living in Poland back in 1939, which wasn't very high (i.e. I wouldn't want modern US-style $10m per head settlements).

The hardest part to estimate are the reparations for murder of political, economical, scientific, social and artistic leaders/talents. I'm really at loss here.

Re:Yad Vashem's database of Holocaust victims' names by gonmf on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @05:53AM (#14192057)
There was also the enslavement of Germans for over a decade.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Forced_labor_of_Germans_after_...

Re:Yad Vashem's database of Holocaust victims' names by taway_1212 on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @06:02AM (#14192098)
Yep that's true, you could count their labor towards the overall due reparations.
Re:Yad Vashem's database of Holocaust victims' names by ptaipale on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @06:39AM (#14192277)
As well as loss of substantial amount of German property to Soviet Union and its satellites. In effect, Poland was shifted left on the map by 200 km or so, and the space and property claimed by U.S.S.R.

Also, lots of industrial capacity of East Germany was moved to U.S.S.R. For instance, my dad's first car was a Moskvich 401, which was effectively the same as the pre-war Opel Kadett K38 whose plans and tooling were transferred to a plant in Moscow.

Re:Yad Vashem's database of Holocaust victims' names by rangibaby on Thursday April 27, 2017 @08:54AM (#14211044)
I have a very nice KMZ Industar 50-2 camera lens which has similar heritage to that car, a Zeiss Tessar design made using plans and tooling moved to Moscow from Germany.