News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:NSA Blimp Spied in the United States by mmjaa on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @03:53AM (#14191562)
They are alleging that it spied on any and all electronic communications that occurred in the Long Island, New York area .. not just international shipping, though that was included, but potentially everything else as well.

And that's really the point: we don't know. Unless someone investigates and pulls the evidence, we won't know, for sure, that this device isn't being used by the political elite in order to maintain their powers.

Such is the nature of a nation run on secrets.

Re:NSA Blimp Spied in the United States by deftnerd on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @05:43AM (#14192006)
The terminology made me think that they just had a VHF receiver up there and were listening to AIS traffic https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Automatic_identification_syste...

It's similar to the ADS-B systems that airplanes use to report their location and altitude and heading.

AIS has a built-in messaging system for ship-to-ship communications and to receive alerts.

You can detect AIS traffic from satellite, but ground-based antennas are cheaper and more sensitive. Having a aerostat to increase range would be good for monitoring maritime traffic over a larger area.

UPDATE: After reading some more, I think this is a perfect fit for AIS monitoring. Ground-based solutions have a horizon limitation of 46 miles. Satellite systems get overwhelmed with too many ships reporting in and data is lost. A balloon based system would be in a sweet spot where it would allow the US to extend the AIS monitoring a few hundred miles out from the borders while not having to put more satellites into orbit.

Re:NSA Blimp Spied in the United States by mmjaa on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @08:43AM (#14192899)
Nothing in the article indicates that they are 'only spying on AIS traffic' - this is an assumption, and a poor guess, possible diversion tactic, at best.
Re:NSA Blimp Spied in the United States by willstrafach on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @09:28AM (#14193282)
The source material linked in the article (SIDtoday newsletter) is what states it was used for AIS traffic.

I am curious as to what else you believe it is used for?

Re:NSA Blimp Spied in the United States by logfromblammo on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @09:59AM (#14193542)
I'd guess they were monitoring every signal from radio bands that have a line-of-sight or one-bounce range limitations, as they could get the rest of the spectrum from their ground-based antennas.

They're experts in signals intelligence and have no practical budget limitations. They're recording everything, automatically processing to find the interesting bits, and assigning real life humans to look at those interesting bits.

I'm guessing that in the NYC area, at the very least Russia, China, and Canada are sucking up the same EM signals, or trying to.

We mere mortals tend to assume that such a tool would be used for one thing in particular, because don't have cults of patriotism or bottomless bank accounts.

Re:NSA Blimp Spied in the United States by 1001101 on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @10:15AM (#14193675)
We've had these blimps over our landlocked midwestern city. The largest ships in our area are 24' Sea Rays on a lake, nowhere near the gross tonnage that mandates use of AIS. We may have to accept that the true nature of these blimps is shrouded under layers of state secrecy, and all we have left is speculation based on observation.
Re:NSA Blimp Spied in the United States by mdekkers on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @07:14AM (#14192435)
Global AIS traffic is publicly available: https://www.marinetraffic.com/
Re:NSA Blimp Spied in the United States by rl3 on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @06:56AM (#14192356)
>... we won't know, for sure, that this device isn't being used by the political elite in order to maintain their powers.

As much as I'd love to agree with you, I don't realistically see how it would be practical to blackmail people with a blimp.

For targeting the vast majority of people (politicians included), accessing the sum total of that person's digital life already sitting in storage is more than ample. Browsing history, chat logs, video calls, phone conversations, banking information, medical history, geolocation data. It's all there already.

Re:NSA Blimp Spied in the United States by lallysingh on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @08:05AM (#14192671)
You don't have to blackmail. When you know enough about a person, you can control them with just the right messaging (ref: the point of ad tech). Quick example: An incumbent could use this to have substantially better data on their voter's preferences and tune their campaign appropriately. Or generate just the right kind of fake news to push major policy changes against people's interests. The real potential here is how subtle these moves can be while also being quite effective.
Re:NSA Blimp Spied in the United States by rl3 on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @03:12PM (#14197014)
I completely agree, my only point was that a blimp really can't add much to existing surveillance measures that essentially capture everything. A blimp might help you target extremely paranoid people, that's about it. Even then, having actual human tails would be more effective, especially in NYC.

For foreign operations blimps are amazing though, since a place like Afghanistan doesn't necessarily have modern infrastructure or any shortage of people trying to hide.

Re:NSA Blimp Spied in the United States by lallysingh on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @07:22PM (#14199128)
This whole blimp thing is ridiculous. Perhaps they're worried about CB/Ham or the towers (or wiretap authorization) didn't support what they wanted.

Are blimps threatened by AK-47s?

Re:NSA Blimp Spied in the United States by rl3 on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @07:58PM (#14199358)
>Are blimps threatened by AK-47s?

Not at altitude, no.

Re:NSA Blimp Spied in the United States by mmjaa on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @08:34AM (#14192832)
Yours is rather a naive point of view. You can do a lot with a little bit of information - it doesn't necessarily need to be blackmail. Just knowing what your political opponents are investing in, for example, can be enough to exert un-seen control over them in such a way as to weaken their ability to usurp your current power status. Its not all just blackmail and Hollywood-style intrigue...
Re:NSA Blimp Spied in the United States by rl3 on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @03:31PM (#14197170)
>Yours is rather a naive point of view. You can do a lot with a little bit of information ...

You can also do a lot with a lot of information, which is already available without the presence of a blimp.

Obviously blackmail isn't​ the only form of leverage, and there's many other ways surveillance can further a bad actor's agenda.

Re:NSA Blimp Spied in the United States by PJDK on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @09:32AM (#14193320)
Is there any evidence anything like this is happening?
Re:NSA Blimp Spied in the United States by mmjaa on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @10:25AM (#14193770)
Wikileaks is full of it.
Re:NSA Blimp Spied in the United States by AnimalMuppet on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @12:25PM (#14195051)
That statement could be interpreted more than one way...
Re:NSA Blimp Spied in the United States by SomeStupidPoint on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @10:54AM (#14194053)
So link any evidence of it happening, from Wikileaks or otherwise.
Re:NSA Blimp Spied in the United States by mmjaa on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @02:09PM (#14196377)
The point is, which you missed, that Wikileaks is all we've got. So far.

There really isn't any way to know, for sure, that these apparatus aren't being used for politically motivated means, with all else being considered. We, the people, from who the politic derive their powers, have no idea what they are doing with it.

The secrecy level is too damn high.

Re:NSA Blimp Spied in the United States by kingexe on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @11:08AM (#14194174)
its literally what Hillary was accusing Russia of doing when the whole 'fake news' & her emails getting hacked debacle started.
Re:NSA Blimp Spied in the United States by PJDK on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @03:04PM (#14196940)
Don't get me wrong. I'm sure intelligence services use intelligence they gather to help their country achieve some objective - that's sort of what they're for.

That's a pretty massive difference from intelligence services in western democracies being used to further the interests of specific elites - that would be a gigantic scandal.

Re:NSA Blimp Spied in the United States by strictnein on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @10:44AM (#14193947)
> "that it spied on any and all electronic communications that occurred in the Long Island, New York area"

A blimp monitored communications that ran through buried fiber optic cables? Or were they just talking about wireless traffic? The former would, of course, be impossible.

> "Such is the nature of a nation run on secrets."

Every nation is run on secrets.

Re:NSA Blimp Spied in the United States by pdelbarba on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @10:51AM (#14194024)
I'm not really certain there is much to spy on. They mention cell phones but that traffic is encrypted and if you have the capability to capture it elsewhere (as we know they do) then why bother? There's nothing they could capture that the average joe with an RTL-SDR couldn't
Re:NSA Blimp Spied in the United States by SomeStupidPoint on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @10:52AM (#14194028)
If the NSA is targeting some legitimate and happens to intercept other traffic at a device level, then filters it out as not desired... What's the problem? That sounds like them doing their job.

And so far as I can tell, any claim they did more than that is just mere allegation to sound scary.

I'm sick of jumping at shadows every time a spy agency does anything.

The NSA fucked up with overly broad collection, but at the same time, talking with people, it sounds like that's what the majority really wanted them to do at the time.

The problem is political, and has more to do with the public wanting unreasonable things than some need to fear absolutely every thing they do.

The spy agency stuck an antenna on a blimp! Oooooo, spooky!