With some massive assumptions (that I can enumerate if anyone is interested), the Bottom 20% quintile gets a 6.5% IRR on lifetime benefits vs. contributions. The Top 20%, by comparison, gets a 1.7% IRR. So despite "the rich taking more", the system is still very progressive. Just, perhaps, not quite as progressive as it used to be—but certainly not "proportionate" or "disproportionate" in favor of the wealth.
To give you a sense, had a Top 20%-er turning 65 in 2016 invested his or her SS contributions over the years in a Dow Jones Index Fund, the value of their investment would be $1.1M... versus the $290k lifetime benefit they would receive from the government. (It's pretty much a wash for a Bottom 20%-er: their DJI investment would be worth $136k vs. $130k in SS Lifetime Benefits).
[1] https://www.cbo.gov/sites/default/files/113th-congress-2013-...
SS benefits are a really bad deal for those who would otherwise save. [2]
Ergo, forcing the wealthy to participate in Social Security benefits the rest of us at their expense.
[1] https://www.aei.org/publication/cbo-study-shows-that-the-ric...
[2] http://www.reuters.com/article/us-column-miller-socialsecuri...