You absolutely can opt out by choosing to exclude employers that are either mandated, or who have chosen despite not being mandated, to participate in SS. Or by choosing to live by some means other than wage-labor (if you make all your income from capital investments, you have successfully opted out of SS.) No one is coercing you to the contrary (well, except the coercion to wage-labor that affects most of the population under capitalism and which has not generally been eliminated in modern mixed economies; but even there there are some wage-labor options outside of the Social Security mandate.)
To the extent capitalism isn't slavery they absolutely are.
We can, of course, debate the extent to which capitalism is or isn't slavery.
Of course, again, you can still opt-out of Social Security within the wage-labor economy, it just narrows your choices of acceptable employment opportunities. [0]
[0] http://finance.zacks.com/groups-not-pay-social-security-syst...
As for how its used by retirees today and in the past, would anyone sell stock that is paying insane an unsustainable dividends? Would you blame the investor or the company? Even if its compulsory to buy?