Details here: http://thehill.com/blogs/congress-blog/economy-budget/204996... and https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_Security_Wage_Base
Given that, sure, the top 7% or 1% or the 0.1% don't fund SS proportionately (but they also do not receive higher benefits than the people at exactly $127,000).
The article isn't really talking about the 0.1% or 1%, though, which is a tiny portion of SS payouts, but instead the top 20% or 40% (top quintiles).
The first pays $3500 per year in SS tax, the second pays $8750, and the third $8750. But each one gets the same SS benefit (assuming same number of working quarters and lifespan).
You are right about tax rates, but those rates don't affect the benefit.
The article makes the point that lifespans are not equal, which tilts the SS program in the regressive direction. But (unless I misread the numbers), SS is still a progressive system overall.
I could swear that it didn't work that way before -- did somethibg change?
The feature that does make social security progressive it's the diminishing contribution to benefit ratio a lifetime contributions increase.
People making that are doing pretty well in relative terms.
I guess the cutoff for 'wealthy' is often higher than that though.
Personally (and I realize this goes against a lot of the HN values here), I'd like to see some form of reduced benefit paid out if people are already earning income. If social security guaranteed a minimum monthly income, but didn't pay out what you were already making in other income, it would both help to maintain solvency of the program, and also encourage older folks to retire and make more room for younger people to move up in the workforce. The big problem with that approach is I imagine it would probably cost more to police than it would save, and there are likely some unforeseen consequences to the way it would encourage people to act.
We do that without complicating benefit calculation by way of income taxes. It might be desirable to redirect the additional income tax resulting from that policy back into the OAS trust fund rather than the general fund, though.
https://faq.ssa.gov/link/portal/34011/34019/article/3831/mus...
Social security is taxed on individual income, so you shouldn't look at this like a household income figure.
If you use the traditional capitalist-economy "middle class" (the petit bourgeoisie who live primarily by applying their own labor to their own capital, rather than doing wage-labor for a capitalist or being a capitalist that rents labor rather than supplying it), I actually don't think that's unreasonable.
If you use "middle class" to mean the middle income segment of the working class, then, sure, it seems weird.
There is certainly a very valid separate point to be made about how in the US wealth leads to longer/healthier lives and we definitely need to think about how to fix that, but putting it in terms of receiving more social security feels disingenuous to me.