News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google: My interview experience by ma2rten on Sunday April 23, 2017 @04:17PM (#14180237)
Hi, I work at Google. I am sorry for this. This should never happen. How long ago was this? I can try to follow up on your behalf.
Re:Google: My interview experience by thesmallestcat on Sunday April 23, 2017 @04:41PM (#14180338)
Reading people's accounts of interviewing at Google, I would never apply, and I won't cash in on the recommendations I could get from some ex/Googlers I know. Reading the submission, look how many times the candidate has to "ping" people just to keep the ball rolling. In my mind, I'd end up working with a bunch of sycophants who are willing to do that sort of thing, the same sort of people who got a thrill out of the strategy involved in applying to Ivy Leagues. Google does some great work, but man do they carry a stench.
Re:Google: My interview experience by EmployedRussian on Sunday April 23, 2017 @05:17PM (#14180511)
> I would never apply

I guess you'll never know what (if anything) you've missed.

> I'd end up working with a bunch of sycophants who are willing to do that sort of thing

You are implying bad intentions where none are likely to exist.

Google is a very large company, and 0.001% of candidates are bound to have suboptimal interview experience by sheer bad luck (and it's likely that you see their horror stories more than you see "I interviewed at Google, had a good experience, got hired, and now work on cool stuff with incredible coworkers" kinds of stories).

Re:Google: My interview experience by yongjik on Sunday April 23, 2017 @07:06PM (#14180940)
> "I interviewed at Google, had a good experience, got hired, and now move protocol buffers from one directory to another every day"

There, FTFY. :P

(used to be a Googler.)

* Well, that and eat tons of snacks and coffee. So it was actually pretty good.

Re:Google: My interview experience by thesmallestcat on Sunday April 23, 2017 @06:00PM (#14180670)
Do you work for Google? I hate that I have to ask this, but Googlers are known to come out to defend their employer on HN, for better or worse.
Re:Google: My interview experience by EmployedRussian on Sunday April 23, 2017 @07:02PM (#14180923)
> Do you work for Google?

I do. I've also done 200+ interviews.

> Googlers are known to come out to defend their employer on HN

Well, sure. It's not because Google tells us to defend it though, but rather to state the facts as we see them.

Re:Google: My interview experience by thesmallestcat on Sunday April 23, 2017 @07:21PM (#14180987)
On the other hand, I understand that part of the employment contract is that ex-Googlers cannot bad-mouth the company. Horror stories come out, but few and far between due to this risk. Google's certainly not alone in having clauses like that, but the volume of Google defense on HN feels like astroturf. So that's where my cynicism comes from.
Re:Google: My interview experience by EmployedRussian on Sunday April 23, 2017 @07:59PM (#14181109)
> I understand that part of the employment contract is that ex-Googlers cannot bad-mouth the company.

You understand this based on what?

Out of curiosity, I just went through my employment agreement, and did not find any such clauses.

> Horror stories come out, but few and far between due to this risk.

Or due to the fact that they rarely happen (I am not disputing that they do sometimes happen).

> the volume of Google defense on HN feels like astroturf.

Like I said earlier, since you are dead set to never apply, you'll never find out what (if anything) you've missed.

Re:Google: My interview experience by thesmallestcat on Sunday April 23, 2017 @08:14PM (#14181150)
Seriously? Maybe you're an exception, but it's not like a search for "google employee nda" returns nothing. It's been discussed on HN as well.
Re:Google: My interview experience by EmployedRussian on Sunday April 23, 2017 @09:03PM (#14181301)
Google NDA covers (non)disclosure of Google confidential info. It has nothing to do with "bad-mouth"ing before or after termination of employment.
Re:Google: My interview experience by ocdtrekkie on Sunday April 23, 2017 @11:45PM (#14181832)
Perhaps not, but if you say something negative about Google, and it gets a lot of attention from the public, I think you can agree that you're probably going to get fired. Let's be real here, NDA or no NDA, this is true of working for any company.

Which is why the "personal views" of a current company employee of any organization posted publicly is close to useless.

Re:Google: My interview experience by EmployedRussian on Monday April 24, 2017 @01:44AM (#14182175)
> I think you can agree that you're probably going to get fired.

thesmallestcat claimed "that ex-Googlers cannot bad-mouth the company", and I claimed that no such clause exists in the standard contract of employment.

By the time you are an ex Googler, getting fired is unlikely to be an effective deterrent.

> Which is why the "personal views" of a current company employee of any organization posted publicly is close to useless.

Either you believe that the company is forcing me to write this (instead of just remaining silent), or your argument is not very logical.

Re:Google: My interview experience by ocdtrekkie on Monday April 24, 2017 @02:41AM (#14182357)
Ah, I do see thesmallestcat mentioned "ex", but as the topic was you, a current employee, that seems to be an error on their part. (I don't think the topic at that point was applicants, who would not have signed an NDA at that point, and the conversation had since moved to "Googlers defending Google on HN".) Correct me if I read this wrong.

The problem is that there are likely current employees with both positive and negative feedback about the company. However, you will only hear the former, because the latter would get fired for speaking. Therefore, at the very best, we have to assume your view isn't necessarily representative of the whole.

But more than that, I don't feel Google employees have a particularly balanced view about their employer. You can see my thought on the issue here, and Frqy3's response is succinct in the issue: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14159213

But moving all the way back to the top of this chain, I do see a lot of bad interview stories with Google. Whether through malice or not, there is a lot of hoops to jump through, and as thesmallestcat indicated, people who don't have an incredible amount of enthusiasm for Google are unlikely to bother to continue the process. As it stands, each time one of those "horror stories" comes out, a variety of HN members often state that they would not want to work for Google, in part because of that process.

Re:Google: My interview experience by ma2rten on Sunday April 23, 2017 @05:23PM (#14180538)
I had a great experience interviewing at Google and most people do. Google has millions of applicants per year, some of them are bound to have a bad experience.
Re:Google: My interview experience by kstenerud on Sunday April 23, 2017 @10:19PM (#14181524)
Nov 13th, 2015.

It's a bit of a moot point now, though. I've since switched to remote only, left the bay area, and bought a nice log cabin in the countryside.

Horses in the morning and no commute = a very happy me :)

Re:Google: My interview experience by ma2rten on Monday April 24, 2017 @12:08AM (#14181922)
That sounds great!