If they are stealing the data in order to make themselves a better search engine, I find that pretty easy to argue against. Someone did work that provides value and Google is taking that data and making it look like their own.
Nobody needs to argue anything. just block google in your robots.txt if you are unhappy. case closed.
What sites need is a happy medium. For Google to index the site, but to not use that same data to eliminate the need for a visit to the site. Content has value. If Google is grabbing that content and using it on their own site, that's a problem.
It seems like the reason it's good for Google is because it's the perfect response to the query and it cements Google as the search engine that can answer my questions.
Are they directly profiting from those queries or are they just making themselves a better search engine, and indirectly profiting from that? If the latter I find it hard to argue against them.