News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The solution to the housing crisis is extremely simple by pavel_lishin on Saturday April 22, 2017 @11:47PM (#14176368)
I may not be understanding his proposal fully, so please bear with me. If I'm making a complete jackass of myself through misunderstanding, let me know.

> It’s worth noting that more tax on land doesn’t mean higher housing costs! For those living in enormous houses in very expensive neighbourhoods, it certainly will: but that’s by design. But shifting the tax burden onto rich folks like this, means that the average person pays less.

I'm confused - what exactly is going to stop the company that owns the 50-unit apartment building that I live in from passing that tax directly onto me and the other tenants via rent?

And how does this help my parents, who own land and have completely paid off their house? Should they, age 60 and 80, start working the land to produce a profit to offset the tax? Should I come back and start having more kids to work the farm?

Re:The solution to the housing crisis is extremely simple by djrobstep on Saturday April 22, 2017 @11:59PM (#14176409)
> what exactly is going to stop the company that owns the 50-unit apartment building that I live in from passing that tax directly onto me and the other tenants via rent?

Competition. Your landlords are already charging as much as they can get away with.

> And how does this help my parents, who own land and have completely paid off their house?

The enormous pool of money raised could help fund public healthcare and social security programs that they would benefit from.

> Should they, age 60 and 80, start working the land to produce a profit to offset the tax? Should I come back and start having more kids to work the farm?

If they own a farm but don't want to do anything with the land, they should probably downsize to a smaller property, yes?

Re:The solution to the housing crisis is extremely simple by fiter on Sunday April 23, 2017 @12:12AM (#14176456)
Competition will not resolve the issue of taxes being passed on, because all properties will have an increased tax burden.

The smallest tax/rent increase will go to those using the land relatively optimally (to be decided by tax surveyors).

Re:The solution to the housing crisis is extremely simple by djrobstep on Sunday April 23, 2017 @02:47AM (#14176893)
Tenants are already "taxed" this amount. It just goes to the landholder, rather than the government.
Re:The solution to the housing crisis is extremely simple by fiter on Sunday April 23, 2017 @01:47PM (#14179282)
I think your statement requires some justification. After a property has changed hands, the speculative value has gone away with the seller (who was a landholder but is no longer). The new landholder paid for the cash flow at market rates and so any significant additional cost (tax) would result in a loss. The new landholder will have to increase rents to make up the loss. This will be played out across the market.
Re:The solution to the housing crisis is extremely simple by fiter on Sunday April 23, 2017 @01:57PM (#14179360)
I'd also like to suggest that a lot of the price increases in the SF bay area are related to difficulty developing new units. The intention of the land tax is to increase the usage (density) of valuable areas; however, that requires being able to develop! Development is very hard and risky in many parts of the SF bay area.
Re:The solution to the housing crisis is extremely simple by infogulch on Saturday April 22, 2017 @11:59PM (#14176410)
The path is a bit roundabout but it makes sense.

The point is to make underutilized land uneconomical to keep that way. Landowners can no longer just sit on land that's not generating revenue. To generate revenue they will build more housing. The economics of supply and demand with additional supply will make housing cheaper more than additional taxes passed on to tenants will make it more expensive.

Re:The solution to the housing crisis is extremely simple by Jtsummers on Sunday April 23, 2017 @12:17AM (#14176469)
But the article's proposal is summed up here:

  Income from land is thus completely unearned and thus any
  income gained from land ownership should be completely taxed
  at 100%.
Taxing income from land, not land itself, based on some formula to determine it's value. This wouldn't cause unutilized land to be used, because it would have no taxes (other than base property taxes), but renting it out, for instance, would net you nothing. And if you can't sell it for a decent amount, or utilize it yourself (which the essay isn't clear, would income from a farm also be taxed?) you might as well leave it empty until the property taxes (if you kept them in this scheme) became overwhelming.
Re:The solution to the housing crisis is extremely simple by pavel_lishin on Sunday April 23, 2017 @12:13PM (#14178742)
That's not his proposal being summed up, that's the problem summed up.

> you might as well leave it empty until the property taxes (if you kept them in this scheme) became overwhelming.

I believe he's proposing increasing property taxes until they're 100% (though I'm not sure what this means; you basically have to pay to purchase the land every year?)

Re:The solution to the housing crisis is extremely simple by SomeStupidPoint on Saturday April 22, 2017 @11:58PM (#14176405)
How do they pass a 100% tax on net income on?

Raising the rent more (to offset the tax) generates new taxes in exactly the amount raised.

Now, I'm sure they'll just layer it through a few steps to avoid the tax (like outrageously priced management services they happen to own), but I'm not seeing how they'd (directly) pass the tax on.

Re:The solution to the housing crisis is extremely simple by pavel_lishin on Sunday April 23, 2017 @12:15PM (#14178751)
I don't think OP's proposal is to tax the income from the land, but the land itself. The whole idea is to prevent people from just sitting on un-utilized land.
Re:The solution to the housing crisis is extremely simple by Xoros on Saturday April 22, 2017 @11:57PM (#14176401)
My guess (and I´m ok it's not what is in the article) is that taxes should be on benefits and not on land surface. A 100% tax on benefits mean that there are no need to overprice the rent once all maintenance costs are paid.

And then there will be no more interest in renting. Just own your piece of land.

And then all collapse.