Re:Google's controversial groundwater withdrawal sparks ques...
by sctb on Sunday April 23, 2017 @09:07PM
(#14181317)
Please don't post like this here.
Re:Google's controversial groundwater withdrawal sparks ques...
by friedman23 on Saturday April 22, 2017 @07:44PM
(#14175550)
We use economics to understand how resources can be exchanged for human benefit. If google had offered 100 billion dollars for this water, none of us would believe it immoral for them to make this transaction because the money could be used for good by the community.
Obviously however, 100 billion dollars is too high a price so the problem becomes not if it is immoral for google to take this water but what price is this water worth such that both google and the community come out ahead.
Re:Google's controversial groundwater withdrawal sparks ques...
by ue_ on Saturday April 22, 2017 @08:30PM
(#14175719)
In the case where the money goes to "the community", then sure, maybe. But are the people selling it doing it for the interests of the community? How is the money used to benefit the community?
I am a Socialist myself, so perhaps that's why I am sceptical of the claim that 100 billion dollars would be enough to offset any kind of moral questions. Is it ethical to accept 100 billion dollars from an exploiter of labour?
Re:Google's controversial groundwater withdrawal sparks ques...
by function_seven on Saturday April 22, 2017 @07:42PM
(#14175539)
That’s a pretty uncharitable reading of parent comment. When things are not correctly priced, these issues will constantly crop up. A simpler thing to do would be to price common resources correctly and rebate those who have special needs (like old people, or the poor, etc.).
Looking at everything as a psychopathic economic agent is fun!