Re:Is it time to break up Google?
by davidgerard on Saturday April 22, 2017 @08:18PM
(#14175670)
Yeah. I find it disconcerting to use Bing and discover the results are as bad as Google in incognito mode.
That is: search is such a hard problem that the search engine literally needs to know more about me than I know about myself to give me good search results.
This is disconcerting for fairly obvious reasons, but it also seems to be true.
But in many ways this is anti user. There's a huge value in getting search results based on context and knowledge about you. Its nice that when I google "go", the first result is golang, whereas DDG returns Google.com, Go.com, the disambiguation page for Go on wikipedia, and finally golang.
Further, when I type "frequent flyer number" into a google search bar, it returns my personal frequent flyer number (scraped from emails). Some people (rightfully!) find that creepy and invasive. I find it incredibly useful. Making a tool used by billions of people less useful isn't good.