News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is it time to break up Google? by bdcravens on Saturday April 22, 2017 @04:43PM (#14174653)
> Apple is hugely monopolistic

Being a large company doesn't make you a monopoly, nor does anti-consumer mean the same as anti-competitive. In both product segments you mention (smartphones and personal computers), Apple has a minority marketshare. "Monopoly" isn't a catch-all phrase for "mean business"; it has a very specific meaning, and Apple isn't even close.

Re:Is it time to break up Google? by xigency on Sunday April 23, 2017 @05:33PM (#14180576)
Yes, but they have monopoly influence over iOS and Mac software as well as restricting development. It would take a Supreme Court of about a century ago to take them down, but it seems over-the-line to me, personally.

If that was your strategy as an off brand clone-OS it's not a concern, but at the $700B valuation range there should be increased scrutiny. Depends on the court system as well. See Microsoft and IE bundling? Virtually identical circumstances to mobile Safari.

Re:Is it time to break up Google? by bdcravens on Sunday April 23, 2017 @06:45PM (#14180856)
> monopoly influence over iOS and Mac software as well as restricting development

This is generally not what is considered a monopoly. You're describing control over a product segment that is a small part of a larger industry.

> See Microsoft and IE bundling? Virtually identical circumstances to mobile Safari.

Except Microsoft was 95%+ of the desktop market, whereas iOS is less than 20% of the smartphone market. Bundling wasn't the problem; bundling that used one monopoly to extend another market segment is. iOS doesn't have that critical first piece.

Re:Is it time to break up Google? by Nomentatus on Saturday April 22, 2017 @05:33PM (#14174945)
Not clear in law, especially re questions of patent misuse - an area of the law which in the U.S. is now a mass of contradictions, admittedly.