News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What I Learned About Life by Becoming a Landlord by dbg31415 on Saturday April 22, 2017 @04:25PM (#14174552)
I have a rental property... I used to live there, then I bought a house closer to work and rented out the original house with plans of moving back there some day. Now... I'll never move back. It's in a nice neighborhood, rent requires the people who live there to probably make $150-200k a year... you'd think it'd be OK... But nope. Anyway every part of the article is true.

The rest of this is just be venting for therapeutic reasons. Ha.

First... you really don't make that much money off the property. Once you pay for maintenance upkeep, and taxes, and taxes on the income you get as rent... you just aren't making much... if anything from the renters. I'm probably losing money on my renters... but I make it back (in theory) in property value gains.

Second... holy hell, some people just should never leave apartments. And all the stereotypes are true. You have to assume they are all out to fuck you over... and incompetent... if you don't, you'll be in for a lot of disappointment.

I rented to an Indian family for 12 months, and after I had to have the place scrubbed top to bottom, ducts all cleaned... and it still smelled like curry. New tenant was furious at me for "not cleaning"... I have no idea how to get the curry smell out. I spent over $2k in professional cleaning services... over 2x what it cost to de-cat-pee the place... now I never want to rent to another Indian family. We literally hand-washed the walls, twice... Then eventually repainted everything inside (another $4k)... the house has no carpets or curtains... no clue how the smell stayed. And I had to give a discount to the new tenant for 4 months because of the smell. There is a fan over the stove... but it clearly never got used when they were cooking.

I rented to a Chinese family for 6 months... and I think they moved like 10 people into a 3 bedroom house. I only met the first couple... but every time I went there were 2 cars in the garage, 2 in the driveway, and at least 4 on the street. And every time I would knock on the door a different person answered in broken English.

Families with kids... will trash your property. And they will bitch and bitch that things were broken before they moved in, their precious snowflakes didn't burn parts of the walls, or drill holes, or kick the drywall under their desk so much it cracked all up the wall...

Pets are disgusting. Cats stink. Dogs are destructive. I had to re-do the wood floors after a tenant's dog clawed them all to shit... had to sue the tenant for damages. "It's normal wear and tear!" they insisted... but they had a 120 pound dog whose nails they never bothered to trim. I got smart and just replaced everything with tile after that. For a rental... just pretend you're dealing with malicious jerks who are bent on destroying anything nice you put in the house... and then plan accordingly.

Tenants will lie and lie and lie again to get out of paying for damages. And worse than lie, they do shit that makes it hard to find the true damages... forget toothpaste in the walls to cover up nail holes... I had a tenant put duct tape over drywall and then use spackling paste and paint on top of that. It looked just good enough that if you were in a rush you may have signed off on his move out damages. I had another family try and prop a closet door up, one that took out the inner glass of a window so it wouldn't appear broken (still had the outer glass) -- but then it made it a harder job to replace the glass because they had bent the frame all to shit. Cost them more than if they would have just told me about the break in the first place...

They aren't at all honest about what they fuck up, and they don't have a clue what it costs to fix something correctly. "Man, faucets only cost like $40 at Costco... why you charging me $500?!" Well... because the faucets you destroyed were nice faucets that cost around $350 each, and there's an installation fee... and I'm not even charging you for the other faucet that I have to replace so the two will still match in the master... I'm also covering the damage to the granite counter top where you hit it with a hammer or whatever when you were trying to tighten your vice grips on the faucet handle instead of calling me when you initially broke it a year ago..."

Tenants always sneak in dogs, cats, extra roommates... My first lease agreement was 10 pages... the last one I used was about 45. It spells out everything that I know to include... plus penalties... "Don't sit on the damn roof, asphalt composite shingles are not meant to be walked on when it's 100 degrees outside... you're getting charged for replacing 1/3rd of the roof because you put lawn chairs up on the roof and literally were up there so often you wore a path in the shingles..." "Don't smoke in the house, but if you are going to smoke in the house... don't just cut the wires to the smoke alarms and just tuck them back up in the drywall."

Despite hiding all the shit they do, and bitching about things they notice... most of them are incompetent at owning a house... won't report water on the windowsill leaking in right away until there's rot in the wood and the whole frame has to be replaced... won't report a wasp nest growing out of the rafters in the roof until it's a $1,200 job to remove it... will let their kids hang off of the ceiling fans and fuck those all up... Some people should never live in a house... put them in an all brick apartment building with cement floors and reinforced windows. There's a reason public schools are built the way they are.

You lose so much faith in people when you rent property. If you don't assume they're all out to fuck you over... you'll get fucked over. It'll cost you a fortune in repairs, and so much hassle and stress because the dipshit who rented from you will fight you tooth and nail... and cry about every little cost... when in fact they aren't even paying 50% of what it really cost to get it repaired... let alone the time you lose because you can't rent it in the shitty condition they left it in.

Re:What I Learned About Life by Becoming a Landlord by askafriend on Saturday April 22, 2017 @04:42PM (#14174649)
You've just convinced me that I never want to be a landlord. I don't need to read any more. All of that stuff sounds like stuff out of my worst nightmare.

In fact, I don't even want to own a home any time soon. Sounds like way too much work.

Re:What I Learned About Life by Becoming a Landlord by dbg31415 on Saturday April 22, 2017 @10:13PM (#14176063)
It's a lot less work if you own your own house.

You catch things that are broken early, so the repair is like a squirt of caulk instead of a whole new window frame. You can spray the wasps when the nest is small... not when it's grown so large an exterminator says, "Sorry my insurance won't cover me going up on a ladder for a nest that large... you'll have to call someone else..." Ha.

I really like doing home repairs / minor home improvements for myself. It's satisfying work, and on average I probably spend less than 2-3 hours a week on maintenance. I love doing yard work, I find it really relaxing. Mow the lawn, trim the trees... that sort of stuff. When you do it for yourself... you do it right, and you stay ahead of the entropy. With rentals you're relying on the tenant to report issues, and contracted help to take care of things... and they don't ever do as good of a job that you can do. Nothing I hate more than riding some handyman to re-do something the third time because he slopped it together... but it is what it is.

If you do buy a house, make sure to ask if it was a rental before you buy it. And regardless, DO NOT skimp on the home inspector... a good home inspector will spend a full day in your house, and charge you around $500-750 (that's in Texas, you can adjust for where you live). They will find all sorts of stuff that will save you money and give you negotiating power.

But yeah on the whole I really enjoy owning my own house. Just not so much renting... I bought when the value was like 1/2 what it is now... very tempting to sell the rental property... but it's been going up 10%+ a year... and I haven't had a tenant's lease end at a good time to sell (March - June are good times to sell in Texas, probably other places too... July - August are good times to have people sign leases).

Anyway I tell myself to just wait it out and give it a little more time... You always have to work for the money. (=

Re:What I Learned About Life by Becoming a Landlord by arghIdontwantto on Sunday April 23, 2017 @04:59AM (#14177245)
To counter the op.

My family has been in the rental business for more than 30 years. I have 2 of my own. We never had any issues like the op mentions. A couple late payments and 2 evictions from lack of payment and that is it since I remember (I only started helping around 15 years ago, can't say what happened before).

Just really choose your tenants carefully. Better to have someone you know will take care of the house and get 400 a month then someone that can pay 500 but shows a lot of warning signs they will trash it. And if you are even remotely handy, a lot of the small fixes can be done by yourself in a matter of hours.

Re:What I Learned About Life by Becoming a Landlord by dbg31415 on Sunday April 23, 2017 @07:46PM (#14181076)
Sort of depends on the quality, right? I mean, I know your 400-500 range was an example... but the house I'm leasing out rents for like $3500 / month in Austin -- that's on the upper-side of things here. I can fix some things, provided I have time, but a lot of stuff I end up calling a handyman for if it needs to get fixed during the week, or if it's something "nice" that I don't want to mess up trying applying my amateur-level talents towards.

I said this in another post, but my worst tenant by far came from because they were a friend of a neighbor I trusted... it's easier said than done screening folks. You never really know what they are going to be like.

Glad you've had luck with it! Care to share any screening pointers? I'm happy with my current tenant... I did a criminal check, credit check, and asked for some references... but I've gotten those all come up aces in the past too and still had people trash the place. All I've found that works is a verbose contract spelling out penalties if they do things I don't want them to do.

Re:What I Learned About Life by Becoming a Landlord by arghIdontwantto on Wednesday April 26, 2017 @12:11PM (#14204286)
(not in the USA, so things are a bit different, we can't do credit checks or criminal records for example) The tenants I have in my properties were relatives of people I knew. What we do here is we have a concept (fiador) where while you sign the lease yourself, another person/couple (usually parents) are financially responsible for any non payed rent/damages. This has the 2 benefits, a) the fiador knows he will be liable for any crap the renters do, so if they know they will trash the place they will refuse to sign (big warning sign) and b) you have 2 separate entities to go after for damages.
Re:What I Learned About Life by Becoming a Landlord by tbihl on Saturday April 22, 2017 @10:03PM (#14176023)
I fully believe that being a landlord could be shitty. Myself, I'd never do it because the idea of being legally culpable for how I choose whom I entrust with a significant portion of my savings.

Having said that, parent sounds like the type of landlord I wouldn't want to talk to, either. Granted, if I see a 45-page contract, I'm getting out of there. But he sounds like the type to make a very unpleasant experience of reporting the problems that he wants to know about.

As to the rest, that's why I wouldn't get into being a landlord.

Re:What I Learned About Life by Becoming a Landlord by dbg31415 on Sunday April 23, 2017 @07:59PM (#14181111)
You're not wrong... I mean... the first few tenants I was still very emotionally invested in the property. It was my first house, I wanted to move back there... I had just spent a fortune to me at the time decking it out the way I wanted it... but I had to move to be closer to work. My plan was to move back after a few years, so having people trash it really stung.

The first tenant just destroyed these beautiful new hardwood floors I had just put in the year before. Like their dog left run marks all over, and they refused to put any felt feet on their furniture and chairs (even though I provided them)... and they wore shoes and clearly never swept or cleaned so the floors that were all nice and shiny were just obliterated... it was heartbreaking to me. (I sued them and won; just saying that a judge sided with my assessment that they were needlessly hard on the property too.)

But yeah... now I just spell out expectations in the contract and document things and I know we can let the court sort it out if we need to. I always repair things (typically out of my own pocket) when they are reported as broken... like the first time one of my tenants hung some sort of wrought iron bookshelf in the drywall and it ripped out half the wall when it fell... I fixed it. But the second time they did it, that was on them. (And then there wasn't a third time because they knew it was expensive to fix.) When they don't report it, and I catch it during move out... it's on them -- what's the point of trying to be nice at that point? They're moving on... no sense letting them walk with my money.

But I've gotten a lot less emotionally attached to the house over the years... you need to be detached if you want to be a good landlord.

Re:What I Learned About Life by Becoming a Landlord by tbihl on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @06:54PM (#14198941)
Thanks for the reply.

I guess what it comes down to is that a good landlord doesn't want to be exposed to destruction of a property he or she takes pride in, and a good renter doesn't want to get hosed on move-out, jerked around with slow maintenance throughout their time, or have their lives made unpleasant by other, out-of-control tenants.

Both renter and landlord probably expect similar distributions: almost all experiences fall between tolerable and good, with just a few outliers way out in "hellish nightmare." Unfortunately for renters, the signs of a conscientious landlord who's been burnt before can look very much like those for an aspiring slumlord in the way both shield themselves. And a conscientious renter who's been burnt before probably comes off similar to one who's really planning to abuse the landlord's patience.

A couple silly questions, if you're still watching this and care to answer: 1. Regarding the black smudges on the wall from furniture, is discovering several of those grounds for charging against deposit, an annoyance that you just take in stride, or something you expect of everyone? 2. Have you had tenants request additions or modifications to your contract, and have you accepted them?

Re:What I Learned About Life by Becoming a Landlord by Scottn1 on Sunday April 23, 2017 @05:08AM (#14177274)
Thanks for this. It is timely for me as we just bought a another home and I am wrestling daily to sell our current one when new one is ready, or rent it out. We are half way into a 30yr mortgage on it and I have grand visions of renting it to have other people pay off my mortgage for next 14 years and hate to let it go.

From the few in our circle of friends who have been landlords before, none of them have had any stories remotely like yours. They've all seemed to have had model tenants from what I've gathered. Worst cases are just a few have had their leases broken early and they are having to carry double mortgage payments for a month or two scrambling for another tenant. Or some have been late paying rent once in while and you have to chase them down.

They've all just told me it isn't that bad. Just make sure to do a thorough job in screening the applicants. Check credit history, job stabilty/length, etc. Some have even recommended to just pay a property management company to handle renting it out and such as the fee is well worth it.

I thought owning and accumulating real estate was the way to wealth and comfortable retirements so I wresting with letting my 1st house go so deep into a mortgage. I have some friends who own 3-4 homes. But reading this thread and story though, I am just not sure it is worth the trouble and risk of trying to rent it out. Unless of course I knew ahead of time prices would continue to rise unrealistically in my city forever.

Re:What I Learned About Life by Becoming a Landlord by dbg31415 on Sunday April 23, 2017 @07:42PM (#14181056)
You can make your own call... I mean... I'm still renting it out... it's financially beneficial. Just you can't have an emotional investment in the property.

The tenant family I have in there now is OK... they have kids who draw on walls and that sort of thing... and the Dad calls me to tell me he's "fixed" things instead of telling me they are broken... Who knows if he's fixing them correctly or just enough so they hold... but I like the guy. "Oh, you fixed this thing I didn't know was broken, that wasn't broken before you moved in, and now you want money off your rent? Uh... um..." (What's the appropriate response? Ha.)

Worst thing he's done is tell the gardener not to mow the lawn because they had a baby sleeping... so for a few months my gardener was charging me and not doing anything... I got a fine from the HOA that alerted me the lawn needed to be taken care of. (I haven't been in the property though so I don't know what it's really like inside.)

But I think I've got a good contact with them, and I've covered my bases with what it looked like before, I have like 300 images of every wall in room and every faucet and every cupboard... so... I guess worst case I just ding them for repairs. But look... the contract and the photos -- an once of prevention is worth a pound of cure. I never want to have to sue a tenant again.

It's a lot easier said than done "screening the applicants" -- the first time you meet someone, they could drive a BMW, have good credit, have a nice education, and a respectable job, seemingly have well-behaved kids... but you never know what they're going to be like. You get references from past landlords... you never know if it's a real person or if it's just someone keen on getting rid of them... It's all just luck. By far the worst tenant I had was the first one (and I found them because they were friends with one of my neighbors who I trusted).

There are many less stressful ways to make a buck... but sure, if you can get the right tenant... it should in theory be passive income. Good luck!

Re:What I Learned About Life by Becoming a Landlord by abraham_s on Sunday April 23, 2017 @01:38AM (#14176722)
As an Indian who has lived in 7 apartment/homes in the US, I have yet to see a place which good ventilation in the kitchen. Usually the fan (if any) in the kitchen just circulates the air inside, which serves only to spread the smell. If I am lucky to have a window near the kitchen, I keep it open with fan near it as makeshift exhaust.

Houses in india have exhaust fans/ chimneys (electric or otherwise) that take the air in the kitchen and dumps it outside the house, which I believe is the only way to handle smells from indian cooking.

Re:What I Learned About Life by Becoming a Landlord by dbg31415 on Sunday April 23, 2017 @08:14PM (#14181151)
I remember those shitty fans from my days living in an apartment. They just shot the air back out into the house. Yeah... those suck. Totally agree!

I think the open concept layouts of many homes in the US aren't great for pungent cooking. The house also has a circulating air system, so every thing you cook goes into every room and closet.

The stove in my rental house has an exhaust hood, and it vents outside. Any idea what a proper cubic feet per minute rating I should look for?

Re:What I Learned About Life by Becoming a Landlord by mcbruiser3 on Monday April 24, 2017 @01:30PM (#14186186)
I really hope more people read this. It echos a lot of my own experience and I"m sick and tired of being classified as a "rent seeking" evil capitalist just for providing the service of renting out a property I own.
Re:What I Learned About Life by Becoming a Landlord by scurvy on Saturday April 22, 2017 @05:51PM (#14175026)
You need to flood the place with ozone. It takes a few days and it's pricey, but it gets rid of any smell.