Still a nice service for some, though :)
For what it's worth we do have an API to access/export your comments if you ever want to leave. I used DISQUS personally before I joined the company because I didn't want to implement login/avatars/sharing/notifications for what amounts to a pretty small blog, but ymmv.
I don't think that means that people like to make a new login for each site, I think it means that there is more to creating a contributing community on your blog than lowering the barrier to entry.
But there have been plenty of times when I've wanted to contribute something but couldn't be bothered because I'd have to return to site for the next few days to check for replies. While I may do that on HN (like right now) I won't normally do that for Joe Random Blog.
Aside from content and traffic, it's important to lower the barrier for people that may want to comment. I'm not sure what you're using now, but nobody wants to make an account, and people generally like being e-mailed if someone replies to them. DISQUS is a very easy win there. The list goes on, but I don't want to turn this into an informercial.